3 ms·
> “Corporate personhood” is just a fancy legal word for “group of people”. It absolutely is not. It creates an entity to which actions can be attributed but th
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> “Corporate personhood” is just a fancy legal word for “group of people”.
It absolutely is not. It creates an entity to which actions can be attributed but the responsibility for its actions does not and generally cannot extend to "people who make up the group".
Somce of us believe that even though there are benefits to society from allowing such entities to exist, these entities should not be accorded the rights of personhood.
[ EDIT: should NOT be accorded ]
- kube-system 4y ago“Natural person” is the legal term used to differentiate between humans and corporations when necessary. The concept of corporate personhood does not undermine the legal systems ability to differentiate between the two. If a law shouldn’t apply to human person but not a corporation, the law simply need to specify “natural person”. Corporate personhood doesn’t interfere with this.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoCitizens was decided not on the basis of a law, but the US Constitution, which does not make the distinction you refer to. SCOTUS ruled that it was unconstitutional to restrict the speech rights of corporations, so even if the original Congressionally-passed, Presidentially-signed law had been specific about the type of "persons" it referred to, SCOTUS would (under the logic of Citizens) have overruled it as unconstitutional.
- kube-system 4y agoThe US constitution is a subset of law. > which does not make the distinction you refer to Maybe it should, then. Congress can change it.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> The US constitution is a subset of law. "the law", yes. But the US constitution is not "a law". > Congress can change it. Proposing changes to the US constitution as a method of dealing with contemporary policy and procedural issues deserves a name ala Godwin's Law. I mean, it's not that I disagree with you, it just that it's not going to happen.