3 ms·
> the Emirates cannot trade with Israel Is "cannot" really accurate? Isn't it more like they voluntarily chose not to do so?
by josephcsible 4y ago
> the Emirates cannot trade with Israel
Is "cannot" really accurate? Isn't it more like they voluntarily chose not to do so?
- ericbarrett 4y agoI read that as shorthand for "Emirates-based entities cannot..."
- kps 4y agoUsed to. Israel and UAE normalized relations in 2020 and signed a free trade deal this spring.
- josephcsible 4y agoSure. My point is just that the UAE could have done that whenever they wanted; nobody was ever forcing them to not trade with Israel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- avh02 4y agoI'm not sure that, at least historically, that would be looked upon amicably by their neighbouring countries or populations. That has changed over time though which has allowed this to happen.
- rr888 4y agoThat's what I thought too, not sure why OP said "Emirates cannot trade with Israel", maybe its an old anecdote.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoOld anecdote, and I'm French, so I'm probably using the incorrect tense to tell the story.
- rr888 4y agoYeah makes sense. I love the politics like this where everyone is firmly in solidarity but everyone is making deals out the back door. Like Europeans at war with Russia but buying gas, Americans hating China but spending all their money on stuff made there, Communist leaders hating America but sending their kids to school there.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoCuba getting stuff from America, pro-life manifestants getting abortions, USSR smuggling US computers, KKK members surfing Ebony adult sites. That's just humanity at this point. We are full of contradictions.
- lupire 4y ago
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoThere is this human convention about "can/cannot" that assumes the reader is able to figure out the nuance of it. If I say, "I can't walk it the street naked", I'm expecting you to understand the underlying causes. I'm not expecting that I have to explain to you that, yes, nothing prevent me physically to walk in the street naked, but indeed, I chose every day not to do it because I don't want to pay the social and/or legal price for it. In the same way, given that tensions in the Middle East are pretty famous and that political issues between Muslim & Jews have implications in international trades, I'm making the assumption readers understand what "cannot" means here.
- josephcsible 4y agoMy point is that the UAE is a sovereign country. The only law that prevented trade with Israel was the one they made themselves. There wasn't any legal price for repealing it.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoIndeed, and again, I'm expecting you to understand that they are making this choice because they don't want to pay the consequences of it. And that "cannot" is a short way to state that. Now, from reading your comments, I'm going to assume you are in good faith, and you simply can't see what consequences they can face. Although we can't know for sure such things without being an expert in middle-east politics, one can understand that if two groups of people have been at odds with each others for a long time, suddenly doing business with the opposite party is going to have political consequences. E.G: assuming you are American. If you are a republican group, you can get financed by a left-leaning institution, but this will have political consequences.
- josephcsible 4y ago> they are making this choice because they don't way to pay the consequences of it. And that "cannot" is a short way to state that. I don't think that's a short way of saying the same thing though, for the kind of consequences you mean at least. Imagine if I were a vegan for ethical reasons. It'd be fine for me to say "I don't eat meat", but a lie to say "I can't eat meat", since I'd be perfectly capable of doing so, and be fine if I did, and just not want to anyway. Contrast this with if I had alpha-gal syndrome and someone me offered me a steak. In that case, I could truthfully say "I can't eat that".