3 ms·
I'd be surprised if depression turns out to have a singular cause or mechanism. It's simply a group of symptoms that often occur together. The way we currently
by wongarsu 4y ago
I'd be surprised if depression turns out to have a singular cause or mechanism. It's simply a group of symptoms that often occur together.
The way we currently speak about depression is as if we labeled the combination of fever, coughing and sweating as "the hots". You'd expect to quickly find remedies like "Tylenol reduces symptoms of the hots", followed a decade later by papers "the hots not caused by Tylenol imbalance", with people contradicting it with "I can't live without Tylenol, it's as important to me as insulin for a diabetic". Both can be right, Tylenol just happens to reduce the symptoms without doing anything about the cause. Any actual cure you find would appear to only work for a small portion of patients. Not because it's ineffective, but because "the hots" isn't one distinct illness, but a symptom of many possible conditions, and you have to use different strategies to cure each one.
- moron4hire 4y agoYeah, any study that says something like "This specific SSRI doesn't work for some people, works massively well for others, therefore it's not an effective treatment" should really be tossed in the bin. It's funny that you mention Tylenol as an example, as acetaminophen/paracetamol is the only over-the-counter pain killer that works for me. Ibuprofen does literally nothing for me and I've had to convince my doctors to list it as an "allergy" on my medical records just so my health care providers will stop suggesting it. But that doesn't mean ibuprofen is not effective for other people. I was prescribed SSRIs for a while, back in a particular bad part of my life (financial stress, job I hated, lots of health problems with everyone in my family). If we're going to say that all SSRIs are basically placebo, then I was not in any mental mood to believe that anything a doctor would prescribe to me would be effective. And in my case, Wellbutrin was not. In fact, it had a very significant deleterious effect in that it made me a raging asshole. But Lexapro, on the other hand... night and day difference. (Thankfully, job changed, everyone's health got better, and now I'm no longer on anything other than blood pressure and cholesterol meds, which, come to think of it, is round-about treating the knock-on effects of my years of untreated depression). Placebo effect is never a large effect. If you see a large effect, it's pretty safe to say it's not placebo.