4 ms·
AirPods, just like any other Bluetooth device, basically have two modes of operation. If you're just listening to audio, they use the A2DP profile, which lets o
by miki123211 4y ago
AirPods, just like any other Bluetooth device, basically have two modes of operation. If you're just listening to audio, they use the A2DP profile, which lets one side send high-quality, stereo audio to the other, but not vice versa. The other profile, called HSP, works in both directions, but the audio quality is much lower, both for the headphones and the microphone. Therefore, as soon as you start using the AirPods' mic, your audio quality drops massively.
In fact, AirPods are slightly better than this than other headsets in some ways, if they're new enough and are connected to a compatible device, they use a slightly better codec than any other Bluetooth headset on the market, although they seem to have an obscene amount of noise reduction and other such filters.
Because of the fact that Bluetooth cuts out the higher frequencies, the effect is a lot less noticeable on male voices than on female ones, at least that's my impression. Women with higher voices, especially younger ones, are almost impossible to understand on some headsets, while some very masculine voices are almost perfectly clear.
If you desperately need a wireless headset that doesn't suck, they do exist, but they don't use Bluetooth. They are usually intended for gaming, so they offer low-latency, a much better microphone quality (although still not as good as what a wired mic can do), and work through a USB dongle. Therefore, you can only use these with a computer, not a phone. If you're going into that market, don't expect anything decent under $100 though, and you might even pay a lot more.
- dogma1138 4y agoMost Bluetooth headsets these days use HFP profile for headset mode not HSP since HFP does come with more features and most importantly higher quality audio codec for call mode than the GSM coded that HSP supports.
- andruc 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but OP is complaining (IMO rightfully) about the quality of Airpod microphones, not the quality of incoming audio while using Airpods.
- pseudosaid 4y agohow this is the top comment here illustrates the kind of intellectual folly I come here for
- kkielhofner 4y agoI cringe whenever I join a call and someone is using Air Pods. You know you’re in for a muddied audio experience due to the aggressive noise reduction and the higher cognitive load for understanding speech that comes along with it. Most of the time the person is in a quiet home office type environment. Almost any other mic is a better option. I suspect the Air Pods input audio design was largely intended for a walk and talk on a busy urban street (as one example) and they do very well under those conditions. Hopefully the implementation will eventually be a lot more adaptive. That said the gaming headsets are cringey as well - audio quality is good but it’s visually distracting to see someone in a meeting look like they’re doing air traffic control.