6 ms·
There’s a certain dark humor in the way that Google Talk/Reader kind of marks the apex of their reputation - they sacrificed so much trying to beat Facebook at
by acdha 4y ago
There’s a certain dark humor in the way that Google Talk/Reader kind of marks the apex of their reputation - they sacrificed so much trying to beat Facebook at its own game, and all they got for that devil’s bargain was G+.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoExcuse me, there was Wave.
- nerdjon 4y agoReader really was the turning point for me personally. Before that I was a strong advocate for Google, I used any of their products that made sense and I would jump in and try anything new. Then reader was shut down and I had to start re-evaluating the services I used. Slowly that meant distancing myself from anything google.
- acdha 4y agoSame. One of the big things I don't think their management appreciated was how Reader's users skewed towards people who influenced others — journalists, libraries, the family “tech expert”, etc. — and how forcing them out of something which worked into something which simply wasn't ready to launch ensured that, unlike almost every previous Google launch, the coverage was predominantly negative. They'd had flops before (e.g. Buzz) but since nobody was forced to stop using something they liked to use the flop those didn't damage the brand anywhere near as much.
- MrPatan 4y agoYes, Reader was Google's Twitter, in the way that maybe it doesn't make money but it can be used to put the right info in front of the right people. Throwing away that capability is demented. We were lucky, really.
- nerdjon 4y agoYeah I do think that was seriously under calculated. It seems like reader comes up on nearly every article about google screwing up something like this. What I never understood though, why did they cancel it in the first place. I always figured that the crawler likely used RSS for discovery. I mean why wouldn't it? I constantly find that RSS has articles before I see them on the website. So how much extra data were they really storing for supporting Reader? I mean they had to support the UI but it just seemed like an odd removal.
- acdha 4y agoI’ve heard it brought up by C-level executives considering GCP. The business models are different but the idea that things will be cancelled has been well linked to the brand. My understanding on Reader is that it was less the data than that it was older code and the internal dependencies were rotting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HeyItsMatt 4y agoGoogle+ and circles were a good idea and should have been given a team with a lot of free rein and left to grow organically. Google+ died because it was forced on everyone that had a Google and a Youtube account by psychopathic managers to "grow the numbers". This included forcing a realname policy on non-G+ users that explicitly did not want their online persona connected to their identity. It became the least cool platform on the internet overnight.
- acdha 4y agoThere were also some really bad decisions: for example, G+ on iOS would send you a push notification every time some rando who had you in their Gmail contacts joined G+ or added you to a circle. There was no way to turn that off other than disabling notifications entirely or deleting the app for something like half a year. I chose the latter long before they implemented it. Circles were potentially interesting but if memory serves the first implementation was clumsy and I found it limiting because it required you to know what your followers were interested in and, if memory serves, didn't have a way to de-dupe shares so you'd see the same blog post shared by 20 people as separate notifications. My impression of that time was mostly seeing things I wasn't interested in or had seen before.
- raverbashing 4y agoYeah, that was the weirdest part, period Forced increased followers + notification of every single one: creepy experience
- acdha 4y agoYeah, it was like something out of a cautionary short story. Cool, I know them. Oh, yeah, I haven’t talked with her in a while. Wait, who’s that guy? Huh, she responded to one Craigslist free stuff listing 3 years ago. Who cares? That’s the landlord we sublet from for 3 months a decade ago. … repeat for days … Make it stop!
- epmatsw 4y agoThe mistake they made was having it be closed invites for so long. Facebook butchered Facebook Chat, and my whole friend group was ready to jump ship. Except Google wouldn’t let us, and then Facebook had enough time to get Chat/Messages kind of good enough again, and by the time anyone could get on Google+ no one cared to.
- anyfoo 4y agoI was an intern at Google right around the time where Google+ (long before it was known under that name) became a thing for Google engineers internally. I sat next to a team that was majorly impacted by that. It's all subjective of course, but I could practically "feel" Google changing. Before I started my internship and still during it for the most time, Google was this incredible company that people, including me, were in awe about. All their products were so good. So technically refined, so methodical, you could really see that the people working on them were really smart, and really cared about it all. And then it changed and became this "corporation", and nowadays it's sometimes seen as almost the opposite of what it was, working there being boring but stable. Part of that is probably just a normal consequence of the immense growth, but personally I can't shake the feeling that Google+ had a large part in it.
- acdha 4y agoThanks for that perspective – your subjective impression certainly matches my outside experience. That seemed like the point where the halo faded.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt didn't so much fade as that it got switched off. Suddenly Google was just another evil US corporation when before you might have had the impression that they meant what they said. To be fair to your comment: there were some earlier signs but they could all explained away in one way or another, but that time the mask fell and they never managed to put it back on again. Now they get a lot of business because they are the least bad option. Which still makes Google useful but I'd love for some actual competition. But with the network effects at play any viable competition can be stifled.
- gwillen 4y agoI was a fulltimer there around the same time, and I agree. I ended up quitting fairly soon after the G+ real names fiasco blew up, and it felt like a lot of internal "social capital" got burned on that, which was never really recovered. I don't think the whole place went to hell at that moment, or anything, and your description is maybe a little more dramatic than I'd go with, as to the role of G+... but it definitely seemed like one of the big turning points.
- rakoo 4y agoIf memory serves well that was also the time Wave was supposed to take our communication to the 21st century
- nfhshy68 4y agoDidn't Orkut actually have a good organic following in Brazil before they axed it for G+? So much stupid.
- Sunspark 4y agoThey did, it has always surprised me that they threw away a market they were leading in.
- nl 4y agoWave was never really pitched as a social network - although some people sort of talked about it like it was. It was more an intergrated workplace thing - sort of a predecessor to Notion+Slack in a single app. But it was very flaky to use.
- rakoo 4y agoOh sure, it wasn't a social network, but it was, like the GP said, the apex of what Google once was: innovation in the field with completely new, potentially useless, but ultimately eyes-opening tech
- nl 4y agoIt was pretty innovative, but it also showed such incredible hubris. The famous post (now gone but referenced from [1]) about how they spend who-knows-how-long reimplementing scroll bars in the browser when the app was so janky it barely worked was the kind of thing that doomed it. The HN discussion at the time is interesting too[2] [1] http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2009/11/15/google_waves_scrollbars/ http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2009/11/15/google_waves_scroll... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943947 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943947