7 ms·
These remind me of a category of "joke" that some of my middle-school peers and I engaged in: the non-joke. The only one I can remember went something like: a m
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
These remind me of a category of "joke" that some of my middle-school peers and I engaged in: the non-joke. The only one I can remember went something like: a man walks into a bakery and asks for two baguettes. The baker looks at him, thinks for a moment and says "It's OK, you can leave your bike outside".
Looking back, I think this idea was somehow rooted in the idea that jokes have delivery and that if you use that delivery (rythmn, emphasis, body language) maybe you could say anything and be funny. There was also the peer effect - if you had an audience "plant" in the school yard that would start the laughter, sometimes it would catch even for these non-jokes.
Decades later, the idea I described above seems both obviously false, but also true, in the sense that a lot of modern stand up is based on "say anything the right way and people laugh". However, "the right way" for standup is very different than the "telling a joke" structure.
On the other hand, it does feel to me at this point that this is the crux of the contemporary poetry slam: read an arbitrary text in the right way, and while it may not win any prizes, it will feel like poetry, because that's what make it poetry.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoI remember a similarly themed non joke where the meaningless and irrelevant punchline was "no soap, radio."
- Apocryphon 4y agoWhat a delightful practice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_soap_radio#Execution_of_the_prank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_soap_radio#Execution_of_the...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- saghm 4y agoWhen my father first told me that joke when I was a kid (with "two elephants in a bathtub" rather than one being hippo), I just assumed that the elephant who wanted the soap was named Radio.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Todd 4y agoThere was a thread on HN a week ago about this. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32250203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32250203
- dtech 4y agoThis is also because laughing at jokes is a way to (unconsciously) show that you get it, and/or belong with the "in-crowd". So people tend to laugh at jokes other's find funny, even if they wouldn't themselves, and remember the joke must've been funny because they laughed. Also see: laugh tracks.
- anyfoo 4y agoI know what you mean, but it isn't quite the same I think. The anecdote I told in a sibling comment about a friend and me sitting in the back of my mom's car is an example. We were two very good friends, so there was no "in-crowd" dynamic at all, and we were absolutely loosing over it, it was genuinely funny to us. Roughly the same age as what OP stated, so there just seems to be something inherently funny about those non-sequiturs to young folks... maybe that's when you start to "deconstruct" concepts like humor.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoMy favorite non-joke. What did the farmer say when he walked outside and saw that his tractor was gone? Damn it. My tractor is gone.
- xxs 4y agoUnrealistic - insufficient cursing.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoI wouldn't expect a lot of cursing in that scenario. I'd expect a lot of cursing from a farmer experiencing some sort of understandable problem that happens to him all the time, but not from one experiencing a mysterious, unexplained emergency.
- spc476 4y ago"I see," said the blind man, as he picked up his hammer and saw.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoI seent it!
- guelo 4y agoDelivery is the crux of a lot of comedians. If they have good delivery they can get away with saying a lot of unfunny, even mean repulsive things, and have the audience laugh along with them
- humanistbot 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-humor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-humor You might enjoy the work of Andy Kaufman.
- gregstoll 4y agoThe author just wrote an article about this as well - https://dynomight.net/no-soap-radio/ https://dynomight.net/no-soap-radio/
- yccs27 4y agoSome of the variations just had me in tears and I can‘t really explain why. Edit: I guess it‘s the same formula as most jokes: There is some logic in the setup, and the punchline replaces it with a different logic or pattern. Only in this case, the original logic isn‘t common sense, but the expected pattern of each type of joke. A meta-joke in that regard. It really depends on you being blindsided, but immediately recognizing the new “logic“ at the punchline.
- ranger207 4y agoYeah this is a meme in the modern internet sense, where a large portion of the humor comes from recognizing the format
- brianpan 4y agoA joke breaks expectations. Setup: "What kind of bear has no teeth?" Punchline: "A gummy bear" breaks the expectation you have trying to think of a type of animal bear. Non-jokes or meta-jokes break the expectation but in an unusual way. "Why did the chicken cross the road?" punchline breaks your expectation of an broken expectation. You thought it was a joke, but it turned out to be a statement. The aristocrats joke turns out to be just a dirty story- the story is the "joke". Memes are not non-jokes or meta jokes. Memes are refillable jokes in a known container. You see the picture, you know what the joke is. Just like a TV sitcom is storytelling/joketelling in a refillable container. You see the kooky friend character, you know how he/she is going to react. The aristocrats joke happens to also be a refillable container (you can tell/retell it however you want), but that's not the part that makes it a non-joke.
- manimino 4y ago
- aantix 4y ago"Some people say funny things. Other people say things funny." Both can be equally comedic. Looks like you and your friends discovered that.
- nyx 4y agoMichael Davis, comedy juggling act: "They say a comic says funny things, but a comedian says things funny. This makes me a juggler." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKRrfAzdpW8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKRrfAzdpW8
- DonHopkins 4y agoSpeaking of comedy juggling acts: I was watching The Flying Karamazov Brothers performing their amazing comedy juggling act on stage, when they suddenly all messed up at once and dropped their pins, which caused the entire audience to burst out in uproarious laughter. Taken aback, they asked the audience: "Are you laughing AT US or WITH IS?" The audience unanimously replied together at once: "AT YOU!!!" They smugly shouted back: "Gesundheit!!!" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Flying_Karamazov_Brothers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Flying_Karamazov_Brothers
- wizofaus 4y agoSurely the ultimate non-joke involves querying the purpose of a chicken's road-crossing adventures...
- happimess 4y agoIt's a pun. The chicken gets hit by a car and dies. It reaches The Other Side.
- swores 4y agoNope, that's a pun you've shared, but it's not the definitive answer in any way as you seem to think. There is no single correct chicken crossing the road joke, but specifically the person you're talking to is speaking about an anti-joke where you don't even get to it crossing the road because you're stuck on the question of why cross the road rather than the act of crossing it.
- wizofaus 4y agoIf there's a pun it's one referencing the line from Othello about "this foul proceeding", but good luck coming up with one that would get a laugh outside very select circles.
- anyfoo 4y agoThat seems to be the recent interpretation (or at least I only recently read about it, it seems to be a thing right now), but I remain unconvinced. It's just entirely plausible to me that the pun was just a "happy accident", and the originator of the joke really did mean to give a groan-inducing borderline-tautological answer that does not offer any insight besides the obvious. You were expecting a punchline, but your expectation was subverted! And at least that's also funnier than that lame pun. I'd be pretty disappointed to be honest, but we'll probably never really find out.
- Biganon 4y agoA friend of mine swears that it's the intended meaning and that it was a pun all along I'm absolutely certain he's wrong Some jokes simply don't mean anything
- stryan 4y ago> Looking back, I think this idea was somehow rooted in the idea that jokes have delivery and that if you use that delivery (rhythm, emphasis, body language) maybe you could say anything and be funny. Reminds me of the Code Geass abridged series Code MENT (most famously known for the Soup Store[0] meme) which relies on this type of humor heavily. Most of the jokes in it aren't really funny on their own and are essentially just nonsensical statements delivered in strange and distinctive ways rapid fire while VERY loosely related to the plot of Code Geass. But with the right delivery the lines become hilarious and easily quotable: just look at how many Soup Store parodies there are. [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAUnDDTz30k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAUnDDTz30k
- thaumasiotes 4y agoI had a somewhat similar feeling watching How I Met Your Mother -- there are many places where it's obvious that the show expects you to laugh, but in most of those places, there is no joke. Instead, there's a continuity reference.
- Max-q 4y ago> Looking back, I think this idea was somehow rooted in the idea that jokes have delivery and that if you use that delivery (rythmn, emphasis, body language) maybe you could say anything and be funny. This is “Friends” summed up. We are only laughing because they tell something like it was funny, and the canned laughter tells our brain to laugh.
- triceratops 4y ago> This is “Friends” summed up... the canned laughter Are you not aware that the show was filmed before a live audience? Watch how the actors pause between lines - they're actually waiting for the crowd to finish laughing. And that's the case for most sitcoms from the previous century. It might not be your kind of humor. But real audiences found the show funny enough to laugh so long and hard, when they were under no obligation to do so, that the actors had to have unnaturally long pauses between their lines. Many modern internet commenters have a misguided tendency to automatically dismiss any show with a laugh track as inferior. FWIW I think Friends was a great show for most of its run, with top-notch comic writing, within the constraints of the medium at the time. Sitcoms were nearly always single-camera format, and shot in a studio with a live audience. The storylines had to be accessible to casual watchers. The shows lived and died by weekly ratings, and needed to have ad breaks at specific times, which also influenced the writing, casting, and pacing. Just to show you that I'm not swayed by mere laugh tracks and longevity, let me also announce that anything made by Chuck Lorre is absolute drivel.
- darkerside 4y agoFriends was funny, but I'm sure they also had a big Laugh sign to tell people when to laugh
- triceratops 4y agoEvery show with a live audience does. But notice how long they laugh at some points. You can't fake that.
- function_seven 4y agoMy favorite: How many pancakes does it take to shingle a roof? Orange, because snakes don't have armpits!
- twodave 4y agoMy Dad used to tell this one, but the punchline was "because fish can't eat ice cream!" Thanks for taking me back in time :)
- Biganon 4y agoThere used to be a joke in French, popularised by comic book author Gotlib afaik, that went like that: "Why do ocean liners have 3 big chimneys? Because Transatlantic!" You could replace the question with anything nonsensical. In the comic, a father becomes crazy after his son tells him this joke. He just wants to understand it so bad...
- tomjakubowski 4y agoI really like this one. "Transatlantic" is related just barely enough to "ocean liner" that it would make me think there's gotta be something to get.
- DonHopkins 4y agoQ: How many surrealists does it take to change a lightbulb? A: Two: one to hold the giraffe, and one to fill the bathtub with brightly colored machine pieces. Q: What's the difference between a duck? A: One of its legs are the same. Penguin jokes are even funnier when monkeys tell and laugh at them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTQMRC5Pm6k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTQMRC5Pm6k Joking aside, this is Marvin Minsky's paper "Jokes and their Relation to the Cognitive Unconscious", published in Cognitive Constraints on Communication, Vaina and Hintikka (eds.) Reidel, 1981: https://web.media.mit.edu/~minsky/papers/jokes.cognitive.txt https://web.media.mit.edu/~minsky/papers/jokes.cognitive.txt >Abstract: Freud's theory of jokes explains how they overcome the mental "censors" that make it hard for us to think "forbidden" thoughts. But his theory did not work so well for humorous nonsense as for other comical subjects. In this essay I argue that the different forms of humor can be seen as much more similar, once we recognize the importance of knowledge about knowledge and, particularly, aspects of thinking concerned with recognizing and suppressing bugs -- ineffective or destructive thought processes. When seen in this light, much humor that at first seems pointless, or mysterious, becomes more understandable. [...] >ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: I thank Howard Cannon, Danny Hillis, William Kornfeld, David Levitt, Gloria Rudisch, and Richard Stallman for suggestions. Gosrdon Oro provided the dog-joke.
- amadeuspagel 4y ago“What is purple and hums? An electric grape. Why does it hum? Because it doesn’t know the words.”
- smitty1e 4y agoThat's a non-sequitur, no?
- joosters 4y agoKind of related: https://twitter.com/KidsWriteJokes https://twitter.com/KidsWriteJokes It's a collection of jokes (apparently) written by children. They aren't funny, in the sense that they make no damn sense. Yet, lots of them are funny in the sense that they are completely ridiculous but you can see what the child was trying to do, i.e. deliver a joke in the same style as they have heard before, e.g. Knock, knock Who's there? A ladybug. Ladybug who? A LADYBUG. I just SAID that.
- leonhard 4y agowhats a fish with no eyes. dead That one I found way too funny haha
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI like to send messages to my partner where I say “I wrote a song for you” and then what follows is a few lines about how they’re great, and in my head it COULD be sung as like a really awkward song, but when you read it it doesn’t really look like a song at all. No rhythm and no rhyme. I guess it’s fun to write a non-song and pretend it’s a song.
- anyfoo 4y agoI remember how intensely funny such non-sequitur jokes were to us at the same age. And they were quite similar to the one you quoted, absolute nonsense. I vividly remember sitting in the back of my mothers car with a friend and just losing it for laughter. It was uncontrollable and my mother was rather annoyed. It's almost sad that it doesn't work at all anymore.
- lIl-IIIl 4y agoIn one of his auto biographical boom John Hodgman reflects how his nonsense books ("The Areas of my Expertise") were unexpectedly wildly popular among 12 year olds, and this popularity was the primary reason those books and their sequels we're successful.
- fastaguy88 4y agoAnyone can tell a joke: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=m8raDUn0UgQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=m8raDUn0UgQ
- salmo 4y agoWe used to really enjoy a long elaborate joke setup with a let down as the punchline in college. My favorite was "A patron sees a whale sitting in a booth at the bar". You go on and on about him coming back day after day seeing the wale, describing the beverage, etc. Just improv it. The key is going as long as you can while keeping the audience, but still getting that frustration and tension from them. At the end the patron gets up the courage to talk to the whale explains to the whale that he had seen him for days, was amazed, etc. Then the whale looked at him and responded [insert best whale noise impression]. Since he passed I've seen a bunch of Norm Macdonald videos of this. He really was the best. The moth joke and others that go on for ~30 mins each on Conan are amazing. He plays them dumb but is basing them off like Russian literature tropes that go way over the audience's head. The repeated build up, let down, and then finally just a silly punch line that could have landed in 3 sentences is incredible. And his ability to play off Conan's occasional shots...
- luhn 4y agoThe name for these jokes is a shaggy dog story. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaggy_dog_story https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaggy_dog_story It's one of my favorite categories of joke. It gets even better if you can retell it to intersecting groups of people, as the people who have heard it before are now "in on it." They can see you leading the audience on a wild goose chase and will react with amusement throughout, increasing the excitement of the fresh audience and making the punchline (or lack thereof) all the better.
- jaybrendansmith 4y agoSo there's a farm. On this farm, there's a cow, a chicken, and a horse, and the three of them are best friends. They do just about everything together. And one day, they're sitting at the window of the house, and the farmer's kid is watching MTV, and they're watching it, and they hear the music, and the horse says "you know what? I'm gonna learn how to do that." So the horse calls up Guitar Center, and he says to the guy on the phone, "Hey, listen. I wanna learn to play guitar." Guy on the phone says "no problem. Come on down." "No, there might be one problem. I'm a horse." "Naw, it ain't a problem. We'll get some attachments, I can teach you to play. Promise." So horse turns out to be a natural. He gets GOOD. And he calls over Cow and Chicken and he's like "LOOK WHAT I CAN DO" and he jams out like Jimi Hendrix. And Cow says "Holy shit. That's awesome. I want to learn to do something like that too. What's like that?" And horse says "Bass. Learn to play bass." So Cow calls up Guitar Center, and she says "Hey, listen, I wanna learn to play bass guitar." Guy on the phone says "No problem, miss, come on down." "Eh, this might be a problem. I'm a cow." "Nah, no problem. I helped a horse recently, I can teach you to play too. Promise." So Cow learns to play the bass, and Cow is fucking amazing at it. So Cow and Horse are jamming, and Chicken gets a bit jealous. He says "Damn, I wanna learn something too. But not like that." Horse says "Well, I mean, we need a drummer around here." So Chicken calls up Guitar Center, and he says "Hey, listen, I wanna learn to play drums." Guy on the phone says "No problem, man. Come on down." "Eh, maybe a problem. I'm a chicken." "Naw. Ain't no thing. I taught a horse guitar and a cow bass. I can teach you drums." So chicken learns the drums, and he's fucking amazing. So Cow, Horse, and Chicken all start having jam sessions whenever the farmer's out. And one day they're playing, and a big record agent is driving down the road. And he hears them, and he’s like "What the fuck? That sounds amazing." So he stops at the farm, and he finds them all playing in the barn. And he says "Holy shit. You guys sound AWESOME. I wanna represent you, make this a real band, make some music. You're gonna be HUGE." So Cow and Chicken and Horse take this guy's deal, and they move to the city, they cut albums, and they're big. REAL big. Top 10 hits, platinum albums, the works. They get set for their first tour. But there's a problem, see. Horse gets a phone call, his mom's real sick. Cow and Chicken, though, they're cool as hell. They say "Listen. Go see your mom. We'll delay the first show a couple of days, so fly back home, spend some time with her, and then jump on a plane and come meet us." Horse says "Thanks, guys. you're the best," and he takes off. Couple of days later, Horse's mom is just fine. Turned out to be a real bad cold, she gets over it, and he spends another night there. The following morning, he gets a call. It's his agent. Cow and Chicken's plane went down, they died in the crash. The band is done. He's lost his best friends. And Horse, this breaks him, man. He's been through so much with them, and he feels real down in the dumps. So he takes a walk, and while he's on that walk, he just can't shake the blue, so he figures to himself "Alright, alright. One drink, just to get over it." So Horse walks into the local bar. Bartender looks at him and says "Hey. Why the long face?" ... this one can be extended for 30 minutes ...
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agoWhen I was a summer camp counselor, on the first day I would always tell the joke/riddle Two canadians are paddling a canoe across a vast hot walmart parking lot. One of them turns to the other and says "Where's the paddles, Eh?" His buddy replies "Eh, sure does." It's a real slow burner, but invariably after an hour or a day one of the kids would get it and share the answer around and they'd all laugh. Then I would tell Two seals are sitting in a bathtub full of warm crisco. One of them turns to the other and says "Hey, could you pass the soap?" and the other answers "What do I look like, a typewriter?" And, primed to believe that if you think hard enough, QuadmasterXLII jokes really do make sense / have a punchline, they'd entertain themselves the rest of the week hunting for an explanation that doesn't exist.
- taurusnoises 4y agoMy aunt used to the tell the second as: Two elephants are sitting in a tub. The one elephant says to the other, "Pass the soap." The other elephant says, "No soap. Just radio." Get it? And then her and my mom would laugh, and wait for me to do the same. The joke being that anyone not in on it who laughs is faking. The joke is on them. 'Twas my fav joke.
- sethammons 4y agoOk, I need help. I don't get it nor the seals one. Edit: saw a link - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32250203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32250203
- unwind 4y agoSpoilers for the first one welcome at this point. Thanks. Gaaaah.
- mistersquid 4y ago“Where’s” is a homophone for “wears (down)”. [0] [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/9a7k0p/can_someone_explain_this_joke_about_two_penguins/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/9a7k0p/c...
- ep103 4y agoYou sir, may be interested in /r/antiantijokes
- martopix 4y agoI remember a high school friend once telling a non-joke to us. We did find it hilariously funny at the time. I did not manage to make anyone laugh with it since. She was very good at it, but as you say the audience matters.
- djmips 4y agoMy daughter when maybe 4 or 5 made this knock knock 'joke'. Knock Knock. Who's there? Laughing cow. Laughing cow who? Laughing cow is laughing at you! That's why!