4 ms·
Most vegetation is made out of air and water. Mostly air. C, O, and N come from air. H comes from water, and some of that comes from water in air. The inputs fr
by Animats 4y ago
Most vegetation is made out of air and water. Mostly air. C, O, and N come from air. H comes from water, and some of that comes from water in air. The inputs from dirt are under 5% of plant mass. They have to be, or farms would dig holes in the ground.
Feynman talk on this.[1]
So, with that out of the way, what does this company actually have?
* They have a cool web site with no useful info.
* They have another web site with useful info.[2]
* You can't even order samples of the product.
* They have a useful Wikipedia article.[3]
* It's a fermentation process, so it takes heat and water, not just air.
* They've been around since at least 2019 and have burned through about $20 million in funding.
* None of their PR discusses cost of the product.
[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2012/09/25/161753383/trees-come-from-out-of-the-air-says-nobel-laureate-richard-feynman-really https://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2012/09/25/161753383/t...
[2] https://solarfoods.com/ https://solarfoods.com/
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Foods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Foods
- kseistrup 4y agoDoes anyone here know which single celled organism they're using? Is it as fungus, like the one that is used in making quorn?
- kseistrup 4y agoIt seems to be knallgas bacteria: https://wikiless.org/wiki/Hydrogen_oxidizing_bacteria#Knallgas_bacteria https://wikiless.org/wiki/Hydrogen_oxidizing_bacteria#Knallg...
- clomond 4y agoNot to be incredibly nit-picky, but the costs of the product right now don’t matter nearly as much as the ability to scale production and variable unit costs. As a ‘hard tech’, they need to work themselves through the technology readiness framework before the cost of a particular material even tells you anything of value.
- Animats 4y agoSure it does. The competition is growing soybeans, which are really cheap. Are they going to beat that? Most of the high-tech food schemes produce some high-value product. This produces a very low value product. It's Hamburger Helper. Cost dominates.
- washbrain 4y agoThe competition would be carbon neutral pesticide free soybeans, which I'm not sure are readily available? Soybeans also typically use energy intensive nitrogen fertilizers, which I'm not sure this process requires. (It might, not sure.) Also, soybeans need to be shipped from fertile areas. This could be produced in situ in infertile areas. I'm not saying it's a panacea, but it has some benefits over traditional intensive agriculture.
- DesertVarnish 4y agoIs it actually standard practice to use nitrogen fertilizers with soybeans? Soy is a nitrogen fixer and I've read that nitrogen fertilizers often reduce yields for soybeans because it interferes with nodulation and undermines that plant's nitrogen fixing capacities.
- washbrain 4y agoOh, great question actually. I mostly know wheat farmers, so that's the model that I have in my head, but yeah it would make sense they fix nitrogen.
- photochemsyn 4y agoApparently soybeans are often grown in a double-cropping rotation, in which maize is planted first (along with N and P fertilization), and then no additional fertilizer is applied to the following soybean crop. This seems to be a comprehensive discussion (for South Dakota farmers anyway, pdf): https://extension.sdstate.edu/sites/default/files/2020-03/S-0004-21-Soybean.pdf https://extension.sdstate.edu/sites/default/files/2020-03/S-...
- 88913527 4y agoThe 'holes' created by industrial farming aren't missing dirt, it's missing water. https://blogs.agu.org/geospace/files/2019/03/Subsidence.jpg https://blogs.agu.org/geospace/files/2019/03/Subsidence.jpg https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/land-subsidence https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/sci...
- mrguyorama 4y agoDon't worry, kevin over there in silicon valley is doing his part by taking a short shower! /s
- southerntofu 4y agoTo add to this, it appears many scientists/ecologists around Europe are very worried about practical desertification due to monoculture (industrial/chemical growing of one crop across vast areas). This is so much of a problem that even skeptical industrial farmers are starting to use organic farming techniques (such as compost or nettle manure) to replenish their soils for monoculture. Which is of course not as good as smart permaculture setups, but well.
- knodi123 4y ago> Most vegetation is made out of air and water. Mostly air. Most vegetation is water. Vegetables, at least, are about 90% water. https://www.myfooddata.com/articles/vegetables-high-in-water.php https://www.myfooddata.com/articles/vegetables-high-in-water... So yeah, except for the water content, most of the molecular weight is atoms that come from air- but the water content is *HUGE*.
- outworlder 4y agoMost vegetation is not made out of vegetables :) Fruits and vegetables tend to have a very high water content, specially the ones we bred for human consumption. Any random tree will have about 50% water and close to that amount in carbon, with trace amounts of other elements. That's less water than you and me.
- dane-pgp 4y ago> * It's a fermentation process, so it takes heat and water, not just air. To be fair, if the heat is from solar or wind energy, and the water is collected from rain (which I guess includes river water?) then those are also "out of thin air". Or I suppose you could say that air containing rain is not as thin (i.e. contains more mass) than "normal" air, or that "air" only refers to the gases, not the rain falling through it, in which case they'd have to rely on moisture vaporators, like in Star Wars.
- highwaylights 4y ago> None of their PR discusses cost of the product. Or a licensing deal with Dolly Parton. It’s right there. The ad makes itself.