4 ms·
>Apple hasn't been anti-ad You mean Apple played the tracking and Anti Ads cards with all of its PR submarine articles and marketing, how Apple is not an Ad co
by ksec 4y ago
>Apple hasn't been anti-ad
You mean Apple played the tracking and Anti Ads cards with all of its PR submarine articles and marketing, how Apple is not an Ad company and doesn't sell ad ( not true then and not true now, to the point the App Store Head questioned whether putting Ads on App Store search would go against Tim Cook's public image ). Fuel the public discourse against data collection AND Ads, push the narrative on all forms of media ( including Social Media ) how every single ad is tracking. ( You may want to read Benedict Evan's piece on Ad and Tracking ) And only to backtrack when the whole Ad industry questions Apple's motive on why are they all of a sudden Anti Ad? ( Tim Cook, somehow, for some reason, had to made a few public statement on how Apple is not "Anti-Ads". )
The whole tracking and Ads PR strategy got to the point where Ad is evil on HN. It wasn't "Personally I hate ads but I understand their place in the world ". It was simply I hate Ads. ( People working inside Ad industry rarely comments on HN anymore ) And when other players in the industry does "targeting" Ads, it is tracking. When Apple does it, it is "personalised". [1]
I guess the pandemic had people forget how Apple started their grand strategy play against Facebook.
I still cant believe nearly 20 years later how Apple has outdone Google's "Do No Evil" hypocrisy.
[1] https://twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1532861766492774400 https://twitter.com/Carnage4Life/status/1532861766492774400
- CharlesW 4y agoYou're doing what the parent comment says, which is conflating Apple's pro-privacy behavior with "anti-advertising" behavior. You're far from the only one, to the point that folks like Tim Cook regularly talk about this. "We’re not against digital advertising. I think digital advertising is going to thrive in any situation, because more and more time is spent online, less and less is spent on linear TV. And digital advertising will do well in any situation. The question is, do we allow the building of this detailed profile to exist without your consent? "We think that some number of people, I don’t know how many, don’t want to be tracked like that. And they should be able to say they don’t."¹ Apple has never disparaged advertising as a revenue model for developers. They even have regular WWDC sessions on the topic². What they have been very vocal about is user control. ¹ https://www.thestar.com/business/2021/04/12/apple-ceo-tim-cook-on-privacy-permission-and-tracking-users.html https://www.thestar.com/business/2021/04/12/apple-ceo-tim-co... ² https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2022/10038/ https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2022/10038/
- tehwebguy 4y agoRight, if Apple doesn't let people hyper target it's not necessarily a privacy issue. Main issue with Facebook ads is when you interact & identify (e.g. click an ad and sign up[0]) you are confirming to some advertiser that their campaign targeting applies to you. If this ever changes that will be a big privacy issue. [0] Advertisers can also identify you if you only click (and don't sign up or otherwise identify yourself) via some other data source like their own data, a third party service
- ksec 4y agoI can assure you, I am not. Apple's pro-privacy behaviour was their message, explicitly speaking. But ultimately the market received it as "anti-advertising". The best of marketing isn't telling you what to think, ( pro-privacy ) but leads you what to think ( anti-advertising ). And Apple was happy to play along with it. They were absolutely against advertising, or more precisely Facebook's advertising revenue. The two example you show were already well pass 2020. As I said Tim Cook had to make a few statement about how they are not anti Advertising cough. after the damage was done. And only after the Ad industry were furious.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Apple's pro-privacy behaviour was their message, explicitly speaking. But ultimately the market received it as "anti-advertising". I hear what you're saying — privacy protections impact anti-privacy business models, absolutely — but I'd argue that it's not "anti-advertising" in the sense that more digital advertising dollars are being spent to target iOS users in 2022 vs. 2021. > And only after the Ad industry were furious. It's ad networks' fiduciary duty to hate this. My response to them: Suck an egg.