5 ms·
"Is there a HN post that made you money?" Nope. I assume very few people made any money from an HN post, directly or indirectly. Edit: Why disagree without re
by giantg2 4y ago
"Is there a HN post that made you money?"
Nope. I assume very few people made any money from an HN post, directly or indirectly.
Edit: Why disagree without reply? Most of us (even on HN) are just normal devs and nothing we do on here will make us money.
- joshmanders 4y ago> Edit: Why disagree without reply? Most of us (even on HN) are just normal devs and nothing we do on here will make us money. Probably being downvoted because you have no evidence to back this up. HN posts have made people money directly AND indirectly.
- giantg2 4y agoEveryone is posting anecdotes. My anecdote is that it hasn't made me any money. The number of commenters on this post is much less than the overall number of users on HN. I see no evidence against my statements either. "HN posts have made people money directly AND indirectly." This doesn't negate my claim. Some people do make money on here. I feel that number is very low.
- joshmanders 4y agoThis thread was made 2 hours ago, it's 745AM in silicon valley, where majority of people on this site are at... Don't expect it to explode so fast with people sharing. The difference between your anecdotes and everyone else's is they aren't saying "Well only 6 people replied to this thread in the first hour and a half, therefore I claim nobody has made money from HN"
- giantg2 4y ago"in silicon valley, where majority of people on this site are at" Do you have a source? I find it hard to believe that even 51% are in SV. The second paragraph is a gross misrepresention of my position. And it seems you're implying that as more people wake up, this will somehow prove that the majority of HN users have made money on posts here... which isn't any different the (misrepresented) argument that you were just complaining about. I'll wait for you to provide some actual evidence that 51% of users have directly or indirectly made money on posts here.
- joshmanders 4y ago> I'll wait for you to provide some actual evidence that 51% of users have directly or indirectly made money on posts here. I'll provide that when you provide evidence that nobody has. Interesting how you can make claims without facts to back them up, but demand me to back up my claims against yours.
- giantg2 4y ago"Interesting how you can make claims without facts to back them up, but demand me to back up my claims against yours." Yep, that's intentional. That's exactly how you started attacking me. And now I have you making the statement/point about the lack of evidence for me.
- jodrellblank 4y ago> "I'll provide that when you provide evidence that nobody has." Where did giantg2 claim that?
- jader201 4y ago> Edit: Why disagree without reply? Most of us (even on HN) are just normal devs and nothing we do on here will make us money. Because your personal anecdote of "Nope." doesn't really add much value to the thread, and the second sentence is an assumption (so it may not even be correct), and either way, it also doesn't really contribute to the discussion.
- giantg2 4y agoI'm not sure how someone who hasn't had that experience would elaborate on it. The point is that not everyone makes money on these posts. The way the question was worded indicates that those who didn't make money are still welcome to answer. The fact that it (at least at the time) was the only response about not making money does add to the conversation, as prior to that the conversation was very one sided. So all you're really hearing is how some people made money, but it's not accurately representing how many people do or don't make money on here. I would like to see responses by other normal devs saying they did or did not make money on here since that can give insight into the assumption to determine what kinds of people benefit. Or perhaps I'm looking for too deep of a discussion?
- jader201 4y agoI guess, as the title (What HN post made you money?) implies, it's looking more for responses from those that made money from HN posts, vs. a poll with a title more along the lines of "Have you made money from an HN post?". I'm sure there are several that haven't made money from HN posts, but I'd imagine there's not much to discuss around that, other than just collecting raw numbers. Unless some can offer discussion around how they tried and failed to do that, but again, the title doesn't really suggest that sort of discussion.