4 ms·
>This is a silly piece. The author just doesn't seem to be aware that the two things he complains about are just simply industry standards in journalism. He wan
by coldtea 4y ago
>This is a silly piece. The author just doesn't seem to be aware that the two things he complains about are just simply industry standards in journalism. He wants journalism something to be that it isn't and has never been, and then critiques it for not being that thing.
This is a silly comment. The author just doesn't seem to be aware that "standards" can still be bad and people can legitimately complain about them.
Especially since the "standards" are not some professional legal code or technical protocols that have to be followed, but just common practices.
Doubly so, since, besides some standards being inherently bad, even good standards can go stale over time. For example, newspapers not providing references might have been OK back in the days of print, but it's not in the web era, when a reference via a link to the source is trivial and gives immediate access to it to the reader.
Triply so, since there do exist news outlets that do far better than the "standard": giving actual links, properly attributing, not pulling quotes out of their ass or unrelated interviews, and so on. So it's not "standards" being followed here, it's more like "minimum-effort common practices" being followed. [Heck, all kinds of "dark patterns" are now standard behavior in news outlets too. Doesn't make them ok].
Quadruply so, since "syndication" is not an excuse either. News outlets can (and some do) edit, restructure, and add links or other annotations to syndicated content from news agencies and other sources.
In other words? A typical HN "piss on TFA" comment, promoting bad practices (sorry, standards), and being upvoted for no discernible reason.