3 ms·
What's the point in buying shares of a company with no possible upside? That's not a useful product for a retail investor, and it's not usable for stock compens
by astrange 4y ago
What's the point in buying shares of a company with no possible upside? That's not a useful product for a retail investor, and it's not usable for stock compensation for employees either.
- yazaddaruvala 4y agoIn this example by the parent commenter the $100 BB divided up as dividends or stock buy backs is useful regardless of y/y revenue or profit growth.
- astrange 4y agoThat's not useful to a retail investor though. You know its exact value and so does whoever's selling it to you, meaning you can't get a bargain on it. It might be useful if you got it for free, but in that case you should sell it to a bank or someone who can actually use a fixed-income asset.
- kgwgk 4y agoRemember that this subthread started when someone claimed that « With 0% growth their equity price is near 0. »
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoIncome
- astrange 4y agoTax-inefficient income with no inflation protection. Unless it's a whole small business you're buying into, government bonds are better.
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoBecause a company has more downside risk than government bonds, the income they produce would need to be higher. Probably would look very similar to other corporate bonds which is basically what zero upside stock would look like.
- kgwgk 4y ago> What's the point in buying shares of a company with no possible upside? As the Beatles would say, to get you money to buy you things. A black box that spits out one dollar bill (after tax, if that’s your concern) every hour is a useful product to anyone even if there is « no possible upside ». Don’t you see the point in getting one if the price is right? Wouldn’t you pay $10000 to get one? $1000? $100? $10? $1?