4 ms·
Issues: Discovery - Other than spots where part of a lava tube's roof has already collapsed, how quick & cheap is it to discover and map the lava tubes under s
by bell-cot 4y ago
Issues:
Discovery - Other than spots where part of a lava tube's roof has already collapsed, how quick & cheap is it to discover and map the lava tubes under some non-trivial part of the lunar surface?
Scale - Let's say there's a lovely lava tube, X meters in diameter and Y meters below the surface, in a location where we'd like to build a moonbase. For a give size of moonbase, there will be fairly narrow ranges of X and Y values where the lava tube is actually suitable for housing the moonbase.
Cut & Fill Competition - Lava tubes aren't magical. If an area on the moon has deep, stable "soil" (vs. near-surface bedrock) containing ~few larger pieces of rock, then "dig a trench, install tubular habitat, fill trench back in" may give a far lower cost and/or higher predictability than "starting looking for the perfect lava tube...".
Stability - If you're not familiar with the things that often go wrong when humans start digging and building structures, Practical Engineering ( https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMOqf8ab-42UUQIdVoKwjlQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMOqf8ab-42UUQIdVoKwjlQ ) is a pretty good intro. Note that we have a lot of experience with and data on how to do such things on the Earth. On the moon...not so much. Some very painful and expensive lessons seem inevitable.
- DennisP 4y ago> If the scientists' gravity analyses are correct, the lava tube near Marius Hills could easily house a large U.S. city such as Philadelphia https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/gigantic-lava-tube-could-be-home-moon-colonists-ncna813396 https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/gigantic-lava-tube-coul...
- wolfram74 4y agowhich would be a bit excessive for a 10 person base, yes?
- bell-cot 4y agoLooking at that article...it appears to show Philadelphia being a mere 1km or so wide. Vs. Wikipedia says that Philadelphia is >350 sq. km. Even if that's not horribly wrong (maybe they figure that New Philly, on the moon, will be a ~1km x ~350km strip?), they still show the bottom of the lava tube being 3km or so below the lunar surface. The moon's gravity may be weak...but just building a few 3km-tall freight elevators, to provide minimal transport to/from the surface, would be a huge infrastructure project. Vs. "Philadelphia" suggests that you'd have ~1.6 million people living down there. And are they figuring that the city will have it's own pressure dome(s), totaling ~350 sq. km., to hold the air in? At some point, the ideas start to sound like "wouldn't it be great to build a thousand-square-mile tropical island, in this spot where the ocean is only 3 miles deep?" Sure, if you know somebody who'll give you ~5,000 cubic miles of good rock, delivers cheap, and there's no "asteroid impact" in the fine print.