3 ms·
Okay there are a few things going on here: 1. A substantially similar product I think we both agree this is legal (given your laundry detergent example) 2. C
by aidenn0 4y ago
Okay there are a few things going on here:
1. A substantially similar product
I think we both agree this is legal (given your laundry detergent example)
2. Confusion for the original product in marketing materials (including packaging)
- This relates primarily to trademarks law; I partially addressed this in my original comment pointing out that simply the name being of the form "X Commander" isn't likely an enforceable trademark.
- The DC homepage has a screenshot, then some text, which includes the text "it is inspired by Total Commander." This seems analogous to a picture of cornflakes followed by "compare to Kellogg's Cornflakes"
3. The UI looking an awful lot like TC
If the icons TC used were copyrighted, and DC used them, that's clear copyright infringement, but I don't think this is being alleged here.
This gets complicated quickly; the general layout (status bar at top, clickable reminders of keyboard shortcuts at bottom, two side-by-side panes, &c) did not originate with TC, so if DC is in trouble for this, it's not with TC
The great similarity in the general look is at least partly to them both using Lazarus, and partly intentional to make it easier to use by existing TC users.
The similarities just from using the same toolkit are generally fine. I think the point you are raising that when combined with the intentional layout similarities this could rise to the level of product confusion; if the buttons all looked very different, but were in the same screen positions and did the exact same things, then DC would look very different from TC.
As far as copying the "look and feel" Lotus v. Borland strongly suggests that the interface of an application is not subject to copyright. If TC had a design patent or trademark on the menu or toolbar look, then they could almost certainly enforce this, but it would have had to have been registered in advance.