4 ms·
> Is it because file usage in general has declined? Generally mabye, but not in that target demographic. Absolutely file usage has declined, even among power u
by crazygringo 4y ago
> Is it because file usage in general has declined? Generally mabye, but not in that target demographic.
Absolutely file usage has declined, even among power users.
My god, two decades ago everything was files -- my MP3 collection, all the photos I'd ever taken, everything I'd ever written. My whole life organization was based around organizing files inside of folders.
Now it's all Spotify, Photos, Docs. Everything is search-based rather than folder-based, thank god. A handful of playlists, starred items, a handful of folders for select projects, and that's it.
And then all of the power user stuff, when it comes to coding or otherwise advanced processing of files with data? It's all command-line now, also thank god -- you can do pretty much anything you want, rather than be limited to the feature set of your secondary file manager. The command line was pretty limited in Windows 3.1 and Windows 95. Now we're thankfully in a different era.
- themodelplumber 4y ago> Everything is search-based rather than folder-based, thank god Huh. At the very least I use both and couldn't live without both. Especially the really nice, super-subjective folder hierarchies that I built myself and know like the back of my hand...whether local or in the cloud. No clutter, no folders with thousands of different loose files.
- msravi 4y agoI still use vifm as a filemanager a lot, and couldn't do without it. Bulk renaming of files, moving and categorizing downloaded files (documents, books, music, ...). A lot of stuff that I download gets cleaned up periodically unless it's properly categorized and tucked away. What do you use for that? I do use fzf to search, but it's so much easier with vifm. vifm also makes bulk operations on filenames a breeze with vi keybindings
- jonathankoren 4y agoSearch is useful, but image search is vastly inferior to proper organization. Whenever I search for an image using Google or Apple, I never find what I'm looking for. I may find something related to the event, but never the actual photo. The photo might as well be lost. The sole advantage to search, is that no one properly organizes their photos beyond something like date.
- jprd 4y agoI honestly can't imagine how this is true, but of course, experience is a hell of a filter. I use search for everything (though a lot of the time some folders is all that is needed), and Google Photos is a sin greater than Central Air (#Dogma). If you tag faces, Google Photos will go out of its way to find decades old photos of the same person and merge that tag for easy search. It will periodically ask me to validate that a half face in the background from 2004 matches the same person in a full portrait from 2018. I search a loved one, scene or year to go with it and nearly always get what I want back. It gives me Star Trek vibes.
- Barrin92 4y agoIf you tag things you're effectively recreating an organizational hierarchy, just with labels instead of literal folders. Plain search itself will always lack the feedback you get from the semantics you create by organizing things, unless you attach metadata to your search in some way. Simple example, you look for a math paper in your paper directory, and you find an even better one that you didn't remember. Of course recommender systems in search help with some of this, but search is mostly literal, it doesn't make connections the way you can. Spotify can give you some popular punk bands that are like the ones you like, but it's unlikely to give you that one record from the local band that nobody else listens to that you manually curated in your playlist 12 years ago.
- jonathankoren 4y agoImage search has a recall problem. This is obvious if you search for a specific photo. I have a photo of my daughter as a toddler wearing a red vest or coat that reads, “Coca-Cola Security Forces” (She was a child soldier in the Cola Wars. Thank her for her service.) I can not search for that photo. I know the picture was taken at my house, but only vaguely when. If I search for her name and location, I’ll get thousands of photos. If I add some years, I get fewer, but not necessarily the one I’m looking for. Add some content descriptors like “red vest” or “red coat”, it’s totally random. Search for the words on the coat? Lol. That’s not indexed. If I breakdown and scroll through the list of thousands of photos, it’s not there. Why isn’t it there? I have no idea. Maybe it’s not facially tagged? Maybe it just ranked low in some algo? No clue. No way even to figure it out. I have to resort scrolling through every photo for the date range to find it. It sucks.