47 ms·
I think you're giving too much weight to this angle - if OP had happened to be in the beta, that part wouldn't have been found or mentioned at all. Bypassing a
by OJFord 4y ago
I think you're giving too much weight to this angle - if OP had happened to be in the beta, that part wouldn't have been found or mentioned at all.
Bypassing a beta feature toggle isn't really a vulnerability IMO, it just allowed OP to find one in this case.
- mox1 4y agoWhat!? So nobody here can think of any possible scenario where bypassing a server-side check for 'Account X can access Feature Y' could directly lead to a security issue? This is absolutely 100% a vulnerability - insomuch as that CloudFlare should have an explicit policy that ALL account features are enabled / verified server-side, not client side. Think of all the spam that would have happened, had this been discovered on underground black-hat forums.
- OJFord 4y agoDo you want to offer some? It's not clear this even bypassed payment that should have been due. That would be worse, and still not really a vulnerability. > Think of all the spam that would have happened, had this been discovered on underground black-hat forums. What spam would have happened as a result of early access to a new Cloudflare feature, that's independent of any (other) bugs/security flaws in that feature? (Also, even with the actual vulnerability here, what 'spam' would have happened? This hijacks recieving. Worse, yes, but I don't see how it helps spammers.)
- BeefWellington 4y agoAccessing functionality you should not otherwise have access to is by definition a vulnerability. CF apparently agrees since they paid out a bounty for it.
- OJFord 4y ago> CF apparently agrees since they paid out a bounty for it. Not really, it was mentioned as part of a report of the main, much more critical issue of 'hijacking email with Cloudflare Email Routing' - note that's the title itself, not 'accessing a cloudflare beta feature'...
- systemvoltage 4y agojgc is just responding to the OP, don't strawman him. OP is the person focusing on the client-side beta check, so jgc is responding to that particular thing. Has zero bearing on the overall issue.
- OJFord 4y agoI'm not 'strawmanning' him, I'm saying responding to that line of argument (or at least in the way that he did, accepting the claim it's bad and defending on the back foot) lends it undeserved credence. I agree it 'has zero bearing on the overall issue'. That is pretty much my entire point.