7 ms·
Free online textbooks work
- osipov 4y ago
- civilized 4y agoI believe free online materials can be tremendously valuable, but... > To see how effective these courses can be, look at Big History’s impact on students’ writing skills, and particularly how it helps close the gap between high- and low-income students. At the beginning and end of the school year, teachers who use the course get a measure of how well each of their students is writing. According to the OER Project’s internal data, on average, only 26 percent of the students taking Big History in low-income schools start the academic year rated “proficient” or better in writing. By the end of the school year, that number has jumped to 62 percent—which is roughly on par with Big History students at private schools. Color me skeptical that a history course can magically turn students into proficient writers over one school year.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI'm not skeptical. The data appears to be there.
- vorpalhex 4y agoI believe it. History is the process of reading - digesting - synthesising - formulating. That is the "write better" treadmill. Run it long enough (on any meaty topic) and you will improve.
- rg111 4y agoI agree. I write a lot nowadays. Proposals, reports, documentation, papers. One might think that scientific writing is entirely different from humanities writing. That would not be true. I had a very good middle school education in humanities, and that education comes in handy whenever I write something, anything. Writing has some core characteristics that are everywhere. Once you learn them well, they keep paying forever.
- bigyikes 4y agoAs a mid-level engineer, lately I’ve come to think that improving my writing (or more broadly, communication) skills is the best way to grow my career. All of those great ideas you have aren’t worth anything if you can’t communicate them. We try to make technical decisions as objectively as possible, but often some amount of persuasion is required to align everyone on your preferred outcome.
- thrixton 4y agoJust anecdata but this matches my (as an engineer) experience exactly. For any engineer, transitioning to people management of any sort, or just to have a better voice in any decisions, I think that broadly communication improvement, and probably some sort of project management should be a very high priority.
- kragen 4y agoAs every fiction author knows, you can't tell people anything. You have to show them. http://habitatchronicles.com/2004/04/you-cant-tell-people-anything/ http://habitatchronicles.com/2004/04/you-cant-tell-people-an...
- Didyourestart 4y agoAnother note is that if the material is actually something that a student can engage with the work tends to be a lot better because people take more pride in it. In high school I tended to get lousy grades and struggled to focus, but in college it's been easier because I have more flexibility in my topics and can choose things that matter more to me.
- Taikonerd 4y agoYeah, I was wondering about some kind of selection effect... not sure if the kids get to pick whether they're taking the course or not.
- powersnail 4y agoI'm not. A course that is heavy on reading and writing can transform the writing ability of a student, especially when the starting point is relatively low. I've witnessed this in my friends when we were in college. English was not our first language, and we started with roughly the same level of writing ability. But the ones in philosophy/history/sociology classes quickly outgrew those of us in engineering school. I've read some of their assignments, and the improvement could be seen on a weekly basis. Practice matters. Feedback loop matters.
- lilgreenland 4y agoIt's important that digital textbooks are more than a pdf of the pages found in a traditional textbook. You can do so much more with an explorable interactive experience. I shared my attempt at this on Hacker News a few years ago. https://landgreen.github.io/physics/index.html https://landgreen.github.io/physics/index.html https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17178031 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17178031
- stevejpurves 4y agogreat work! it' such a pity that so much gets put into PDFs still as a medium for textbooks when interactive content is so much better. I've been working on some integrations along the lines of explorable texts that are backend by compute in jupyter - like this mini one on fourier series https://curvenote.github.io/demo-fourier/ https://curvenote.github.io/demo-fourier/ (pres the power button to connect to a binder instance). There ia notebook behind the scenes, and the idea is to try and move from custom web/js development towards something that a content creator say who is familar with python can use. Also open up the possibility of computing with libraries in the python ecosystem, and with compute needs beyond what we can achieve in the browser. Still this example is a one off react site, built with JS knowledge. Working from the other direction I'm also working with folks on a static site generator that can use Markdown(MyST) and Juptyer Notebooks to build book like content, this is a little like JupyterBook but with a JS stack that can integrate the explorable JS based interactivity on the link above. The idea is again to let people focus on content and have a site generator let them build the deployable book. The cli that does that is open source and in beta at the moment in terms of readiness https://curvenote.com/docs/web https://curvenote.com/docs/web but we're excited about what it can do already and busy working on the explorable integrations - looking for feedback and direction too :) some example of building with it: - my blog https://www.stevejpurves.com/la-palma-earthquakes https://www.stevejpurves.com/la-palma-earthquakes - a book like report https://climasoma.curve.space/ https://climasoma.curve.space/
- cxr 4y agoDitch the build-with-CLI requirement. If you're working on notebooks, show your commitment and make the static site generator a notebook itself.
- sputknick 4y agoI'm a homeschool parent, I used https://openstax.org/ https://openstax.org/ high school physics book with my son last year. Really great resource, its essentially Newtonian physics for the first 3/4ths, so hasn't really changed in 300 years, no need to publish a new textbook every year. Also they embed Khan Academy videos, embedded Flash based "games", and they have really well done end of chapter questions with answer key (need to show proof of homeschooling to get them to email you the answer key). Highly recommend it!
- kragen 4y agoAnd, unlike the OER project Gates is funding, the resources from OpenStax and Khan Academy are under Creative Commons licenses that guarantees they'll stay free. The OER resources here are "open" only in the sense that, for the time being, they don't charge you to access them. Gates carefully avoids any mention of licensing throughout his entire article. So I'm comfortable labeling OER as "openwashing", given the current draconian copyright environment. In addition to OpenStax and Khan Academy, I can recommend MIT OCW and, if it's legal in your country, downloading textbooks from Library Genesis. However, surely Gates is correct when he says, "Courses should be created by educators and subject-matter experts, supplemented with professional development, and regularly improved with feedback from the teachers who use them."
- gnicholas 4y agoThere's also LibreTexts, which are designed to be remix-able. I think they pull in most/all of the OpenStax content into their platform as well as generating their own.
- kragen 4y agoThanks! I didn't know about LibreTexts! It's probably also worth mentioning Project Gutenberg and the Internet Archive, although you probably won't find an up-to-date textbook for a class in them unless you're studying Classical Greek or something. And no lesson plans.
- 4y ago
- gnicholas 4y agoIs there an easy way to see the textbooks themselves? I clicked around but wasn't able to figure this out.
- thebooktocome 4y agoI’ve been thinking about writing an open textbook (on a graduate level math topic that comes up frequently in undergrad math courses) but haven’t quite found a publication route that I like. Anyone have any advice on where to publish such a thing, or how to go about distributing it?
- stevejpurves 4y agoIf you want to write, publish and deploy - online the tool I am building can help you do that, either via markdown+git or an online editor https://curvenote.com https://curvenote.com . That would let you write but also use LaTeX math for equation typesetting as well ad numbering, referencing etc... you can also host and deploy it on a free service too as well as convert to PDF/Tex when/if you need to generate a hard copy.
- jamesash 4y agoI would start by just publishing articles to a Wordpress site. You'll get long-tail SEO on articles and often helpful feedback. Build up from there and eventually you'll find you've written a textbook. That's basically what I did with organic chemistry.
- jimhefferon 4y agoAdvice about what? Not snarky, genuinely interested. I released v 1.0 of an open undergrad text just yesterday so I have some ideas anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TheRealPomax 4y agoStart by just putting it online. Get a wordpress, or use github pages, or dump a bunch of files in an AWS bucket, but get it online first. Worry about publishing once people start actually asking whether they can get paper or ebook copies, at which point you'll also get people suggesting ways to get it published. The biggest hurdle to having good information accessible to all is folks never putting that information online for the rest of the world to actually learn from =)
- aperrien 4y agoAre there any open source elementary school textbooks? That seems to be a demographic that could use them.
- gnicholas 4y agoCK12: https://www.ck12.org/student/ https://www.ck12.org/student/
- mncharity 4y ago> Free online textbooks work Work? Being no worse than commercial textbooks can be a surprisingly low bar. "[A]ligned to state standards and created by well-known subject-matter experts and master teachers" is regrettably far from sufficient to avoid being really really bad. OER authorship processes and incentives seem regrettably similar to those of closed textbooks. Especially around correctness. Even the few which manage an online errata/issue database can still struggle because of culture and incentives. Eg, "Ok, we'll tweak that wording so it's "not wrong"", rather than crafting a much harder real fix, despite no hope that students won't be left harmed. Anyone know of any efforts somewhere getting this right? So for instance, openstax and Utah Open Text (two projects in comments here) have astronomy texts, which like the most popular commercial intro astronomy college textbooks, teach the Sun as yellow. Another place this conception shows up, is on astronomy education research's lists of common misconceptions in astronomy education. :/ Conversations with even first-tier astronomy graduate students can go "What color is the Sun? Yellow. Sunlight? White... wait.. err... that doesn't make sense, does it?" Incompatible conceptions, perhaps first learned in kindergarten, persisting unintegrated into graduate school. Persisting with repeated reinforcement. Because the incentives around textbook correctness, let alone around transferable understanding, are just that severely dysfunctional. Even Wikipedia has been managing to more-or-less get this one right for a few years now. But not textbooks. And not OER textbooks. The OER bit seems like it could help, by enabling different processes and incentives, but... not just yet. I'd like to suggest there's an untapped market and opportunity for disruption... but what might that look like?
- cxr 4y agoI had a look at the OERProject YouTube channel[1] (which it turns out _is_ freely licensed—at least for some videos, as pointed out in another comment here[2]). But the thing that bothers me so often about video content is a dearth of sources cited. We can start out small potatoes: simple attribution—okay, great, your video is CC-BY-SA, but where did you get the still that you used @x:29 into the video? From there, though, what I'd like to see is Wikipedia-style sourcing, or, failing that, where all major inflection points in the video come with at a minimum a sort of "See more" block of links that you can use to dive further into the topic. Not only is it the right thing to do, it would be a tremendous boon to teaching the fundamentals of scholarship, which students already have dedicated classes for, to learn e.g. how to write research papers and discriminate between reliable and unreliable sources. What these videos do, on the other hand, is to say, "Hey, you know all that stuff that you're learning in your writing class? It's all bullshit—after all, look at us; we're actually a part of a professional publishing pipeline, and we don't do anything like that." 1. <https://www.youtube.com/c/OERProject https://www.youtube.com/c/OERProject> 2. <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32338460 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32338460>