2 ms·
The question is this: Do non-geeks not care or are they just slower than geeks to find out that they care, or are there underlying economic dynamics that will i
by fauigerzigerk 15y ago
The question is this: Do non-geeks not care or are they just slower than geeks to find out that they care, or are there underlying economic dynamics that will inevitably lead to a point where they must care?
I think the answer to that question is so varied in different situations that any regular-people-don't-care observation has very little predictive power. You could easily be wrong either way.
Also, caring about something is sometimes very indrect. Sometimes you care about the price of something not knowing that it means to care about some obscure piece of proprietary technology.
- vidarh 15y agoMy personal concern with the walled garden is that a lot of the content I care about is niche 25 year old+ stuff (like old Amiga computer magazines). Ordinary users will learn to pick up on this as/when/if they start running into situations where they lose access to content because a provider stops providing access to something they care about or goes out of business. I have no idea what portion of regular users will ever even want to access content that is obscure enough at any point in time to not be offered by providers like Amazon, but my guess is it's never going to be all that huge, and as long as devices like the Kindle offers some way of getting user supplied content onto it, then it will likely never matter all that much to ordinary users. This is what it boils down to, I think: A walled garden is fine as long as there's a public park outside where you can do the stuff that's frowned upon in the walled garden. If I have to pick one or the other, on the other hand, I'd pick the public park any day. I'm getting more and more inclined to pick up a Kindle. My biggest issue is that I refuse to buy DRM'd content because of the walled garden issue, and so the content offering has not yet been compelling enough. It will never replace a more open device for me, but they're cheap enough that picking them up for the purpose of media delivery on rental plans of just stuff I don't care if I own would be attractive even if buying DRM'd content is not. After all, I pay a fortune in cable fees to add in all the available movie channels - if Amazon offered me an option with similar selections of content that'd cost me a similar amount every month (whether charged monthly or per download/view), then I'd have no real reason to care if it's a walled garden.
- pnathan 15y agoIf you are concerned with your books being DRM'd and Amazon disappearing (as corporate megaliths do from time to time cough SGI, Sun, DEC cough), I would suggest downloading them onto your 'real' computer, saving off the files, and then unwrapping the DRM.
- tptacek 15y agoWhy would they care? The walled-garden experiences tend to be better, often by a lot.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoOh, there are many potential reasons. Overpriced components, restrictive rules (e.g no porn/satire/politics), unnecessary and complex dependencies between features/plans/versions (Microsoft is specializing in those), interoperatility/data portability issues, little choice of devices/software/content, forced upgrades or end of life policies, privacy issues due to centralized data mining, clashes between a vendor's business model and consumer interests, inflated prices caused by the cost or effort of switching to a different vendor/provider, lack of competition leading to bad service, etc. Generally, what walled gardens do is to partially suspend market forces (on the inside) replacing them by a planned economy. Sometimes that enables more streamlined experiences, as you say, or reduced complexity, sometimes it doesn't. It can certainly work well, particularly if there is a sufficient number of medium sized walled gardens that compete with each other and have some incentive to interoperate. Some problems with walled gardens become bigger with size and others become smaller, so there's a tradeoff, and it's hard to tell when the system turns nasty or boring. It's not necessrily a big deal though.