3 ms·
> Not to detract from the overall point, but increased healthcare spending during a pandemic seems completely reasonable Public health spending yes, healthcare
by astrange 4y ago
> Not to detract from the overall point, but increased healthcare spending during a pandemic seems completely reasonable
Public health spending yes, healthcare spending maybe not. (For instance, if everyone's staying home they can't get injured in workplace or car accidents.)
I've seen this argument used for universal healthcare in the US too, but it doesn't really make sense. Formal healthcare couldn't do much for you if you got covid since there weren't treatments for it, and now there is an antiviral and vaccine you don't need to go visit a doctor to get them.
- Retric 4y agoSupplemental care was shockingly effective even when we didn’t have disease specific treatments. It’s hard to make an exact estimate supplemental care like IV’s, oxygen, and in extreme case ventilators roughly cut peoples likelihood of dying in half. Unfortunately that shit gets expensive. Mean intensive care unit cost and length of stay were 31,574 +/- 42,570 dollars and 14.4 days +/- 15.8 for patients requiring mechanical ventilation and 12,931 +/- 20,569 dollars and 8.5 days +/- 10.5 for those not requiring mechanical ventilation. Daily costs were greatest on intensive care unit day 1 (mechanical ventilation, 10,794 dollars; no mechanical ventilation, 6,667 dollars), decreased on day 2 (mechanical ventilation:, 4,796 dollars; no mechanical ventilation, 3,496 dollars), and became stable after day 3 (mechanical ventilation, 3,968 dollars; no mechanical ventilation, 3,184 dollars). Adjusting for patient and hospital characteristics, the mean incremental cost of mechanical ventilation in intensive care unit patients was 1,522 dollars per day (p < .001). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15942342/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15942342/ Meanwhile because people assumed there was little medicine could do many preventable deaths occurred at home.
- astrange 4y ago> It’s hard to make an exact estimate supplemental care like IV’s, oxygen, and in extreme case ventilators roughly cut peoples likelihood of dying in half. Does that mean people admitted to hospital? Even before vaccination most people who caught it didn’t get sick enough to require hospitalization - there were some (expensive) covid-specific treatments like mABs for those who did of course.
- Retric 4y agoEveryone had a lower risk of death due to such things even if only a small percentage of the population needed treatment. Using hypothetical numbers: Set A with modern medicine out of X people: 40 get seriously ill, 30 get hospitalized, 20 of those end up in intensive care, and 10 of them die. Set B wihtout modern medicine out of X people: 40 get seriously ill, and 20 of those die. People in set B are twice as likely to die even if most people in set A didn't get treatment. This holds true even if your personal odds of getting seriously sick might have bea well below average, the odds of surviving if you had gotten seriously sick improved. The important takeaway is hospitalization was mostly limited to people who got really sick.