3 ms·
i think i've found a way to hate it. the author is spot on, but entirely misses the point by labeling us "generation sell". it's not about the selling, it's a
by notatoad 15y ago
i think i've found a way to hate it. the author is spot on, but entirely misses the point by labeling us "generation sell". it's not about the selling, it's about working for ourselves. the band as a self-promoting, self-managing independent entity isn't doing it to make money, they're doing their own sales so that their music remains their own. small-time independent entrepreneurs are very specifically not selling themselves. they're selling a product so they don't have to sell themselves to an employer. being a small business owner isn't about selling something, it's about not selling out.
- bluedanieru 15y agoThanks for pointing this out. The part describing starting a business as "selling out" was infuriating.
- danssig 15y agowtf? Having a business is "selling out"? IMO, having your own business is about the only thing that isn't "selling out".
- trevelyan 15y agoI suspect most people still want the comfort of a stable job or career. Problem is that for the last ten years it has been hard to find good ones in the general economy, outside a few growth areas of questionable sustainability (housing, finance, health care). So the opportunity cost for 20-30 somethings to doing their own thing has fallen, even if people don't want to admit it. The other difference is that startups and small businesses give people a more comfortable narrative of how their life is going. It is a lot more comforting to tell yourself, "I'm doing badly now so I will do better in the future," than "I'll never get a job that pays as well as my parents." If this was not the case, there would be much less romanticization of venture capital and angel investment on these boards, more startups would be focused on revenue-generating than traction-generating products, and lifestyle businesses would not be perceived as failures of boldness for "not swinging for the fences".
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jahmed 15y agoWhile some might desire the comfort of a stable job or career, the world is developing down a path where mobility is what counts and flexibility pays off. Companies can shift production fairly rapidly due to local economic conditions and the people that best adapt to this are generally the winners. I think with current globalization trends we are going to start to see more economic nomads maintaining a sense of community through the internet.
- danssig 15y ago>I suspect most people still want the comfort of a stable job or career. I suspect a lot of people are starting to realize there is no such thing.
- _delirium 15y agoI'm not sure that's the angle many people are actually taking, though. It is possible to take the approach of being independent for creative control, and making money is a means to that end (so you don't have to sell yourself to a corporation). It's very tempting to subtly infuse everything with the selling goal, though, where all your decisions have this nagging backdrop of "will this sell? how will this contribute to my personal brand?" etc. It's pretty difficult to keep the selling boxed up even if you want to, and really have it be only a means to an end that isn't the main influence on what you do. Even independent businesses that make a conscious effort not to have all their decisions driven by marketing (say, Dischord Records) don't entirely succeed, and it's probably even less the case for people who don't have that kind of active "anti-selling-out" mindset. It might even be harder, in some cases, than in a normal job. There are a lot of corners of the corporate world where you can make decisions either entirely, or at least mostly, based on technical considerations, because how it's going to make money is someone else's job. The limit case is corporate research labs, where e.g. Bell Labs employees spent very little time thinking about whether their research was sellable; but in a more limited way it appears in lots of places. If you're an independent technical researcher, it's much harder to keep your thoughts off the selling angle, because your livelihood more directly depends on whether your research output will produce revenue.
- danmaz74 15y agoAgreed. If you are an entrepreneur, it just becomes natural to think about everything in terms of market-value. I guess that this article could be a good alert to remember not to do that completely.
- balsam 15y agoSelling is only a means for "Generation Sell". This fan of David Brooks is off the mark, mefeels. Millennials are not Mad Men. They want to create culture. (He mentions it offhand, in the article, though, so he knows it at some -- probably subconscious -- level. I gather that, as a self-described bobo -- he's kind of envious.) Creating culture -- that goes well with OWS.