That's a interesting form of tribal mentality, that a group of people sharing a common trait has some persistent identity, a "hive soul", that commits crimes an

That's a interesting form of tribal mentality, that a group of people sharing a common trait has some persistent identity, a "hive soul", that commits crimes and can be held responsible by punishing any member of that tribe. That hive soul replicates itself by producing members with the same apparent trait, competes for resources with other hives and so on. I don't believe such tribe souls exist, but one thing I'd agree with is that the moment a man makes a decision to benefit from some organisation or nation, he becomes entangled with it, like a bus passenger gets entangled with the bus, and faces consequences for the deeds of the organisation, whether it's "fair" or not.