3 ms·
Trains can be fairly easily electrified (via overhead rails) and hydridized with batteries. Generally they're diesel electric in the first place, so you're just
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
Trains can be fairly easily electrified (via overhead rails) and hydridized with batteries. Generally they're diesel electric in the first place, so you're just switching electricity source which makes it a smooth transition.
So I feel this will lose to batteries, which can be use to brake at every motor, and so can be easily distributed along a train. (Though you don't need batteries for regen braking, you can feed the power back to the grid if you have a connection). And once you have a decent sized battery you can charge from overhead lines when available, which opens up other possibilities.
https://www.alstom.com/press-releases-news/2021/9/alstom-presents-its-battery-powered-multiple-unit-train-saxony https://www.alstom.com/press-releases-news/2021/9/alstom-pre...
> The studies have revealed, for example, that a large proportion of the lines currently operated with diesel vehicles include non-electrified sections of well under 60 miles. The use of the existing catenary infrastructure allows battery-powered electric vehicles to be operated on these lines without major upgrades to the existing infrastructure. Extensive travel dynamics and energy simulations were also carried out as part of the project.
A similarly wacky concept, that I perhaps like is shipping full batteries to places where energy is expensive via train. So charge up a train battery from solar as it travels east, then feed that back to the grid as you meet a post sunset peak. Possibly wouldn't make sense if you were to do it for it's own sake, but if you already have a network of battery trains that can time their charge, you can probably save a reasonable amount of money by optimising when/where you charge based on time of use and demand response events.
Coordinated Demand Response of Rail Transit Load and Energy Storage System Considering Driving Comfort
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347975248_Coordinated_Demand_Response_of_Rail_Transit_Load_and_Energy_Storage_System_Considering_Driving_Comfort https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347975248_Coordinat...
- lstodd 4y agoBatteries are no-go. Typical electric locomotive is like 5MW sustained for multiple hours. It wouldn't be able to pull just its own batteries for any reasonable distance. 60 miles of catenary is way cheaper than wasting energy pulling dead weight that batteries are.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNote that batteries aren't an all or nothing thing. Just like a Prius, you can start with small batteries that just save you burning fossil fuels (even with the added weight), and help you reclaim energy when braking or going downhill and then add bigger and bigger batteries, as batteries get better, lighter, cheaper, electricity gets cheaper, greener or diesel gets more expensive. It's already started, real battery trains are in operation in niche roles (and nearly always have been since before lithium ion) but the process will accelerate and expand over time. They complement electrification of lines, they don't compete with them as you can use one or the other based on which works best for a particular stretch of track, or task.