4 ms·
If you include air pollution and carbon, the price of nuclear is more than competitive with coal. And the electricity it generates can do lots of things cheaper
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
If you include air pollution and carbon, the price of nuclear is more than competitive with coal. And the electricity it generates can do lots of things cheaper and cleaner than unsubsidized oil and gas can (EVs and heat pumps) and it pretty fungible.
So, it's incorrect to say nuclear is more expensive, it's just easier to trace the costs compared with fossil fuels.
That might be a hard political argument to make when the government is controlled by the people getting the fossil fuel subsidies from everyone else and using them to buy politicians, but if we're talking about global civilization collapse, then we can't just sweep those things under the carpet and ignore them.
- ncmncm 4y agoCoal could turn out to be the most expensive fuel ever. That depends on whether we avert disaster. Similarly, when the nukes are mothballed, long before their design life is over because their power is too expensive to find any buyers, the actual cost of each kWh produced up to that end will balloon out of sight, as the exorbitant construction cost is suddenly amortized over much less energy. But comparing nukes to coal is pointless. Wasting money building nukes instead of the much larger amount of renewables the same money could buy brings catastrophe nearer. Burning coal for ten years while the nuke is built brings catastrophe nearer. To avert catastrophe, we will need to build out renewables radically faster than we are doing this far. And, we will need to build out factories for the equipment we will also need, particularly hydrogen and ammonia synthesizers to provide portable fuel for vehicles that cannot rely on batteries.
- njarboe 4y agoI bet nukes, wind, and solar have very different material needs so ramping up all of them as fast as possible should be the course of action. Why exclude nuclear?
- ncmncm 4y agoMoney is fungible. Our industrial capacity could cope with a great deal more activity than it will be devoting to building renewables. But money directing it to that activity, and not some other instead, is the limiting factor.
- LatteLazy 4y agoRight now, you're not charged the cost to humanity. You're charged the cost to you. That is the system. It's wrong, because it let's you externalise a lot of costs. But that is the system. So you very much CAN sweep those things under the carpet. Now as soon as every nation on earth agrees to a carbon price and emission limits and passes those costs down you might be right about the cost of coal being higher. But that isn't the world we live in. That's the problem here: people conflate what is moral with what is actually happening. So you can go bankrupt building nuclear, and you'll be morally right (maybe, I still think the costs are way too high), but you will still be bankrupt and the world will still be emitting...
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's both moral and economics. Basically every country already passes on costs for pollution and emissions. This is not a new problem. Some do it in complicated hidden ways, and some have the price set too low but in general it's happening, because it would be stupid (and immoral!) not to. China now has a national carbon price for example and is responsible for more than half of all coal usage. They're not doing that to be woke, it's just efficient, and it'll almost certainly mean their nuclear plants run more than they would otherwise. And make investing in renewables, which they're already world leaders in, even more attractive.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI think you have missed my point: If you build nuclear YOU can't pass the costs on. So YOU will pay them. So YOU will go bankrupt. Then the nuclear power stations will close and the coal guy will expand his plants. That is how this works. So you either need everyone to change how it works, globally (good luck with that), or you just have to operate within the system as is.