4 ms·
Was this actually theft? The smart contract basically said “ask and you shall receive”. I’m trying to think of a banking analogy. Maybe their website has a pag
by kstrauser 4y ago
Was this actually theft? The smart contract basically said “ask and you shall receive”.
I’m trying to think of a banking analogy. Maybe their website has a page that says “enter your checking account number to get $1,000”, but the web service had the authorization code commented out. If someone discovers that and tells their friends, have they stolen from the bank?
Note that I’m thinking of “theft” and “stealing” from a legal point of view. The moral angle may be very different.
- misnome 4y agoYes, I imagine that would be counted as stealing, if it wasn't intended. However, if the bank had spent large amounts of time absolutely promising irreversible transactions, and publicly opened itself to attackers, then - no, that's just an intended operation of the system.
- johnbellone 4y agoThis is akin to going to an ATM and finding a bug that lets you withdraw money out using the information from a receipt that someone threw out in the trash bin. It is definitely illegal.
- mathattack 4y agoIf you find a way to get the ATM to spit out $100K to you by mistake, legally you have to pay it back. Same if it’s the bank’s error.
- badpun 4y agoI'm not sure if it's theft but they most certainly have to give the money back. It's just an honest mistake, an equivalent to accidentally dropping a wallet full of cash on the street.
- tgv 4y agoBut that wallet has a signed, notarized affidavit that says "finders keepers".
- chrismorgan 4y agoBut there’s a fair chance that the courts will eventually declare this style of affidavit invalid, being trumped by some law or other.
- powerhour 4y agoUnfortunately they won't be able to do much about it, besides jail someone (who may in fact be unable to make the victims whole).
- chrismorgan 4y agoWhen the executives of cryptocurrency firms start getting jailed for contempt of court (when they fail to comply with a legitimate court order), the industry will collapse, which will take the value of cryptocurrency with it, which will return cryptocurrency to niche status, even if the governments in question don’t just decide to make it illegal. This may not be the way things unfold, but it’s legally completely plausible.
- doix 4y agoBut if you allow the courts to dictate which crypto transactions are legal/illegal and to undo illegal ones, what's the point of all the decentralisation? You can just use the existing systems. Which country's laws apply? What if one country considers the Ethereum contract binding, but the other doesn't? It feels like having your cake and eating it too. I met lots of crypto bros, they all talk about how they use it so they can be immune to government censorship/intervention etc. They gloat about using crypto to avoid taxes and laws. Relying on the same institutions that you are trying to get away from to overcome flaws in your framework seems entirely hypocritical to me.