6 ms·
If developers could make a small mistake that caused this, imagine what could happen when The Merge goes through.
by latchkey 4y ago
If developers could make a small mistake that caused this, imagine what could happen when The Merge goes through.
- TacticalCoder 4y ago> If developers could make a small mistake that caused this, imagine what could happen when The Merge goes through. I don't get your comment: Ethereum itself has worked without any issue since it came out, in 2015 (?) or so. Many smart contracts, not built by the core Ethereum devs, have been exploited, but from Ethereum's point of view everything worked flawlessly. Why would the Ethereum devs, which have create a blockchain working perfectly fine since seven years (including many upgrades), suddenly screw up the merge to PoS badly? I mean: I don't doubt we'll see many more hacks (and I don't know why so many people are so keen on putting so much money in smart contracts) but the people in charge of Ethereum itself seems to be quite competent and have a track records of several years without any exploit to prove it.
- lesuorac 4y agoNot just that but if somebody bad were to happen they can hardfork like they did in the past ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_DAO_(organization) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_DAO_(organization) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum#Launch_and_the_DAO_event_(2014%E2%80%932016) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum#Launch_and_the_DAO_ev... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum_Classic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum_Classic
- latchkey 4y agoETH had the benefit of PoW working and proven for years prior to deployment. Switching to an entirely new consensus model, that has never been done before, is complicated and a big reason why it has taken as long as it has. Furthermore, there is a giant target (huge sum of money) on ETH's back now. If you had an exploit for PoS, why would you reveal it early? As the person below also states... they could just fork and fix things, but this time, it will be a lot harder to do so without entirely destroying the value of ETH. This is a massively risky venture that takes more than just hope and prayers. As we've seen in many many hacks over the last few years, even the most competent developers can miss something crucial.
- dannyw 4y agoThere's hundreds of blockchains using Proof of Stake for years. Finally, if exploited, everyone will just agree to rollback again; there's no destruction of ETH.
- latchkey 4y agoYou can't just generalize all PoS as being the same code and execution. ETH is quite different from the rest. Furthermore, none of the other blockchains have even close to the level of value (not just $ amount, but also fame) tied up in them. As for rollback... that's what created ETC, but this time, it is different... with PoS, the 'stake' is tied up in the network. It isn't external, like it is with PoW and isn't as easy to just fork. You're effectively now forced to convince everyone to follow another canonical chain, but you don't have an external way to do so. Forking becomes a lot harder. It also becomes a lot more complicated and hasn't even been done before... how much 'testing' has that gotten?
- stagas 4y agoHow are exchanges going to agree to rollback after they have already exchanged those tokens with others? Someone has to burden the loss, so it might as well be the original blockchain that got exploited.
- latchkey 4y agoYes! This is exactly the premise of Jeff's essay [1] that I mentioned in comments below. This gets messy fast when there is an issue and even worse is that there isn't a published plan for how to deal with things when they do come up. Everyone is betting on it all executing perfectly and given the complexity and value at stake here, chances are that at some point now, or in the future, it won't go well. [1] https://github.com/stickfigure/blog/wiki/Proof-Of-Stake-Wears-No-Clothes https://github.com/stickfigure/blog/wiki/Proof-Of-Stake-Wear...
- DennisP 4y agoEthereum's PoS has been running since December 2020. Right now about 10% of all ETH is deposited on it. What's coming up is the "merge", where the rest of the chain starts looking at the PoS network for choosing blocks, instead of looking at mining difficulty.
- tremarley 4y agoEthereum has had many bugs, mistakes and flaws. Before 2018, Ethereum has a similar downtime to Solana Ethereum is continuously developed to remove bugs. For example: Until 2017, it was possible to sent a specifically signed transaction (without the correct private key) that resulted in the msg.sender having null sender address. This was fixed in EIP-86
- 676234e117 4y agoWhat you are describing is a protocol-level bug, rather than smart contract bug. The merge has already occurred successfully a number of times on test networks, so it seems unlikely at this point. But if a catastrophic failure were to occur on mainnet, clients would just revert or fork to a working state. The reason you cannot just roll back a smart contract exploit like Nomad's is that it is very hard to build consensus across the entire protocol unless it is something that affects many users. The only time this happened was with the DAO which held something like 15% of all Ethers at the time, and so it affected the entire network. Compare this to Nomad which held something like 0.1% of Eth's total circulating supply.
- latchkey 4y ago> if a catastrophic failure were to occur on mainnet, clients would just revert or fork to a working state. Except with PoS, it is different. People keep applying the PoW mentality of a fork to PoS and it just doesn't work that way. Jeff wrote a good blog post [1] on this a while back that took me a long time to come to terms with. It boils down to this paragraph: Proof-of-stake is inherently self-referential. It is possible to have two perfectly consistent, equally valid chains - perhaps with different stakers. Since “stake” is defined within a blockchain, it cannot be used to pick between two blockchains. Under the right kind of stress, the real, unwritten meta-consensus protocol that determines "which blockchain do we pay attention to?" will be revealed. Exactly what that is will depend on the nature of the fork. This is untested on ETH PoS and could result in a significant loss in value for ETH holders. Not only that, but it gets even more complicated with stablecoins that are on ETH. What makes all of this quite interesting is the exchanges who get to decide which USDC on ETH they sell to you. Likely a big reason why exchanges, like Coinbase, are some of the largest ETH stakers. [1] https://github.com/stickfigure/blog/wiki/Proof-Of-Stake-Wears-No-Clothes https://github.com/stickfigure/blog/wiki/Proof-Of-Stake-Wear...
- 676234e117 4y agoThe article is not really presenting any strong arguments aside from literal hand waving the "<complexity>". The same hand waves could be made for PoW. See the last time it made discussion[1]. The article suggests that two chains can simultaneously exist but that would invalidate the protocol, which will always choose one using LMD GHOST. You can read more about it here[2]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27235668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27235668 [2] https://eth2book.info/altair/part2/consensus https://eth2book.info/altair/part2/consensus