4 ms·
> Dave is hired merely as an act of workplace tokenism before wrapping up with what appears to be an attempt at a thinly-veiled transphobic joke. That particul
by rayiner 4y ago
> Dave is hired merely as an act of workplace tokenism before wrapping up with what appears to be an attempt at a thinly-veiled transphobic joke.
That particular strip is actually a hilarious joke that is probably lost on people who have never been in the position of being the minority who isn’t meeting expectations for “adding diversity.” It’s not directed to trans people at all, but rather pokes fun at some people’s rigid notions of race (it’s defined by how other people perceive you) in contrast with their fluid notions of gender (it’s defined by how you perceive yourself).
- fknorangesite 4y ago
- beckingz 4y ago
- fknorangesite 4y ago
- rayiner 4y agoThe helicopter joke cruelly and flippantly dismisses the feelings and distress felt by trans people. That’s not what’s going on in the Dilbert strip. The punchline isn’t “it’s ridiculous for a minority to identify as white.” The butt of the joke is instead the white boss, who wants the minority employee to fit into a socially constructed identity for “diverse” people. And mocking the Judith Butler theories embraced by mostly white progressives isn’t the same as attacking the disadvantaged groups that white progressives like to use as shields.
- tim333 4y agoMaybe but identifying as a different race is a thing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transracial_(identity) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transracial_(identity)
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s not even an unusual thing. Do my kids identify as white, like their mom, or “brown,” like me? It shouldn’t matter, but in the progressive world view it does. The problem is that progressives, like racist conservatives, don’t see race as only skin deep and attach a bunch of other social and political stuff to it. So whole “identifying as a different race” makes no sense from a traditional liberal view, it is almost a necessary concept within the progressive worldview.
- tptacek 4y agoHe's obviously not making a joke about the experience of biracial children.
- rayiner 4y agoI didn’t say that. My point is that race is to a much greater degree a fluid and socially defined construct than gender. And Adams is “obviously” making a joke at the expense of white people on positions of power who view them in the exact opposite way.
- tptacek 4y agoThe joke is unambiguously not a comment on the fluidity of racial identity.
- rayiner 4y agoThe joke is mocking the beliefs of the managerial class. That’s Adams’ whole shtick. In this case his mocking the contradiction in how ideologies ascendant among the managerial class view the fluidity of race versus gender.
- tptacek 4y agoThe point of this article is that the casual conventional wisdom is that Adams' whole schtick is mocking the beliefs of managers, when in fact Adams is a much more complicated figure who also non-ironically believes we should be preemptively murdering teenaged males who appear to be on the autism spectrum in order to prevent mass shootings. The article points out that Adams deeply warped personal beliefs have thus far not overtly made it into the comic strip, but not only have they now (with this strip as an example), but Adams himself is bragging about it on Twitter. So: no, the joke here is not simply about mocking the beliefs of the managerial class. It's the "identify as an attack helicopter" joke, as a preceding comment correctly observed.