3 ms·
> private companies legislating morality This was one of the problems cryptocurrencies were invented to solve. It shouldn't be up to Visa whether to cut off fu
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
> private companies legislating morality
This was one of the problems cryptocurrencies were invented to solve. It shouldn't be up to Visa whether to cut off funding to anyone in particular.
- dizzant 4y agoAre you defending the position that as a society, we should continue to allow funding the creation of child pornography through means of crypto? Visa states openly that they weren’t aware of the situation at issue, don’t support child pornography, and have taken steps to avoid supporting it. This isn’t a case of cutting off some “industry”; child pornography is already widely and rightly maligned.
- mbg721 4y agoOf course not, child pornography is strictly within the domain of public schools, until those pesky parents infiltrate the boards.
- georgia_peach 4y agoCan't speak for matheusmoreira, but I think Visa should handle payments & law enforcement should handle diddlers. Turning payment processors into an extra-judicial enforcement system on top of the existing one is a mess in so many different ways (jurisdiction, lack of due process, arbitrary enforcement, financial motives, conflict of interest, lack of transparency, etc...).
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI'm saying it's the police's job to go out there, investigate and arrest child molesters, not some payment technology's. Money companies turning into extra-judicial law enforcement by means of risk assessment is how you get bullshit like PayPal's constant freezing of accounts.
- tomc1985 4y agoToo bad they have utterly failed at their stated purpose
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYeah, it sucks. They turned into stocks the second exchanges showed up. The worst part is there are good projects out there like Monero but nobody really cares because price doesn't go up.
- PainfullyNormal 4y agoI can't sign off on any cryptocurrency being a "good project" unless I can easily exchange it for goods and services. I haven't found a single cryptocurrency that qualifies, including monero.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI got paid for my services in Monero once. It was a great experience, I wish all money worked that way. Unfortunately I had to sell it for USD because of the price fluctuations.
- tomc1985 4y agoNot to mention that using a lot of these altcoins are likely to put you on some FinCEN watchlist, if it ever gets traced back to you
- matheusmoreira 4y agoWhich is why everyone should use it. What good is a watchlist if everyone is on it?
- tomc1985 4y agoIt's a chicken and egg problem. Who's going to stick their neck out long enough for "everyone" to get in on it?
- smoldesu 4y agoThese private companies aren't legislating morality, though. As a private business, they have complete autonomy over who they choose to partner with. If a Pornhub deal falls through, they have no legal obligation to continue processing payments for them (especially if their lawyers are documenting the problems). Cryptocurrency doesn't solve this, nor was it really invented to address this issue. Decentralization is a nice side-effect of a low-trust network, but it also completely sabotages any moderation efforts on the platform, and preserves an entire population's porn habits in an openly-availible, transparent ledger. I don't think your average Pornhub visitor will be terribly excited to adopt this radical new technology since it presents a scenario where their purchases could be completely deanonymized. > It shouldn't be up to Visa whether to cut off funding to anyone in particular. It's not. Chase Bank or Mastercard are welcome to jump in and take Visa's place if they think the platform is a safe place to make money. It sounds like this is more of a Pornhub issue than a Visa one though, so I wouldn't expect it to get fixed very soon.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> These private companies aren't legislating morality, though. They are. If you're a banker, you effectively choose which direction society evolves towards by choosing who gets banking services and especially access to credit. Deny someone banking and credit and they're pretty much done. That's way too much power. > it also completely sabotages any moderation efforts on the platform "Moderation" is the job of law enforcement. > preserves an entire population's porn habits in an openly-availible, transparent ledger Which is why people should choose privacy cryptocurrency like Monero.
- smoldesu 4y ago> They are. If you're a banker, you effectively choose which direction society evolves towards by choosing who gets banking services and especially access to credit. Deny someone banking and credit and they're pretty much done. That's way too much power. That's why we have fair lending laws. If you're denied private services with a bank on the basis of a protected characteristic, you can take them to court. Deny someone banking and credit, and you get sent to jail. I don't know where you're citing some of this stuff, but some sources might be nice. > "Moderation" is the job of law enforcement. That would be a completely new precedent to me and the United States of America. As a platform runner, you are responsible for the data that you host. You can't just make a social media site, have a bunch of people post gore on it, and then tell the judge "but they did it, not me!". They're going to chuckle, force you to testify that you stored the illegal content on your own server, and then lock you up for as long as they'd like. This has happened many times in the past. Platform owners are not exempt from moderating their own platform. Even 4chan needs moderators, or else they too would get shut down. > Which is why people should choose privacy cryptocurrency like So... you're saying that the average person, who fears things like Bored Apes and CryptoPunks, is going to start using the premier currency for human trafficking and the drug trade? No, I don't think they will. My radical prediction is that people will continue to buy porn the same way they have for the past 30 years, because none of the boons of cryptocurrency directly benefit them.