2 ms·
> Firstly, EV chargers aren't as smart as they seem. For many models of car, they can't know how much energy the car will be wanting to be full, or the charge p
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> Firstly, EV chargers aren't as smart as they seem. For many models of car, they can't know how much energy the car will be wanting to be full, or the charge profile of how fast the car can accept said energy. Without that, it's hard to plan ahead when to do the charging most optimally.
Do you have any evidence that this extra smarts and optimization is actually necessary?
How much of an improvement is it over basic "charge slowly during the night at a random point in the off peak zone and avoid or slow down charging during peak times".
That is a net positive in most ways, so it would need to degrade pretty badly from there to actually be a problem to worry about.
And if it is necessary, the current smart chargers are able to be controlled via apps and have internet connection, which means they're effectively unlimited in potential smartness being applied to when they start/stop/modulate charging.
- londons_explore 4y ago> charge slowly during the night at a random point in the off peak zone Even this is difficult. Many home chargers are only 8kW. That means if you park your nearly-empty 80kWh tesla at home at 8pm, you really can't wait long to start charging to be done by 8am. You need to start by 10pm. On the other hand, if the tesla is already 80% charged, you have far more flexibility. But the charger usually has no way to know which case it's facing. But if all chargers must start charging at or before 10pm to be sure they'll be done by morning, very few will be still charging by 5am, since in most cases cars only require a little top-up. Basically, it isn't even close to being a solvable problem with the info that many of today's chargers have. The charger needs more info, which means the cars need updated software to provide that info, and most cars on the road today will never get their firmware updated. Besides, car manufacturers have no incentive to put in the engineering work - they get nothing out of it. Todays solution for many users is manually setting the charger to start at a specific time when the off peak hours are for their utility provider, and hitting the 'override' button for when the battery is nearly empty. That isn't ideal, and only a small number of eco/budget-conscious people will bother with such things.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoAn 80Kwh battery can take an EV 320 miles. Average driving distance in the US is 39 miles per day, 20 in the UK. (EVs and hydrids drive slightly more than the average, probably due to age mostly with regular drivers wanting a cheap and efficient and reliable car) So, all that is needed, and that already exists, as you note, is the ability to plug in your car and start charging now if you for whatever reason, didn't top your battery up to near full the night before, maybe you've just returned from a long road trip, and intend to go on another one tomorrow. The existing smart chargers in the UK, now default to doing the thing you say that only eco/budget-conscious users will do, which covers all other uses. So, problem solved?