2 ms·
I like to look at these things through the lens of "collective action problems". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_action_problem https://en.m.wikiped
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I like to look at these things through the lens of "collective action problems".
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_action_problem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_action_problem
Notably, this recasts the problem as "we can't do this noble thing because everyone would suffer" to "we can't do this smart thing that will improve everyone's lives, because small connected groups currently profit from everyone else's misery".
It's like the scheme in the original superman film (and Office Space) to become rich by stealing fractions of pennies from lots of people.
In some ways that is more hopeful, if only people could be made to see that it's in everyone's benefit and work together we'd be fine.
But then you look at recorded human history and see that, while "civilization" does overall trend in that direction, it gets fought all the way by the concentrated interests, often to catastrophic ends.
Like WW1 and WW2 essentially being about people trying to hold back the rising tide of democracy (see footnote). The Holocaust arising fairly directly from Russian royalty's anti-democratic propaganda being constantly repurposed for the same ends. A pattern that continues to this day.
Footnote:
> In 1919 Adolf Hitler was recruited into the political department of the German Army in Munich. During his training he impressed the senior officers with his abilities as an orator. Hitler soon became an educational officer whose duties included lecturing soldiers returning from the war on the dangers of socialism, pacifism and democracy. The army considered this important work, as they feared that the Russian Revolution might spread to Germany.
> Hitler was also asked to investigate the radical political organisations that had emerged in the city after the war. In September 1919, he was sent to spy on the German Workers' Party. Hitler reported back that it posed no threat as it was small in numbers (only 40 members) and was extremely hostile to communism. Under the orders of his commanding officer, Captain Karl Mayr, Hitler joined the German Workers' Party with instructions to use his talents to help it grow.