3 ms·
The same way its allowed to provide any other product or service, like security (police), transportation (roads), etc. There is no reason it can't offer other
by zeruch 4y ago
The same way its allowed to provide any other product or service, like security (police), transportation (roads), etc.
There is no reason it can't offer other things, and often in many other places, do. The state is perfectly capable of doing things effectively, but we've conditioned ourselves to believe it can't because corporate America has wanted it that way due to the sheer terror of being out-managed by the state/municipal option (they can't gouge as flagrantly or impose endless layers of their own bureaucratic middle men, so they accuse the government via the dumbest projection).
The state sucks for many reasons, but often for the same reasons corporations do; bad leadership and defection from purpose, often in the process of avoiding transparency. Either can suck, and picking one over the other just because of an ideological crutch is daft.
- jacob019 4y agoTo be fair, in most cases private industry can produce far more efficiently than government. Healthcare in our country is so screwed up that it may be a glaring exception.
- smileysteve 4y agoHeres an example of private contractors for city services going for $21m while the city realized they could do it for $7m. Turns out regulatory capture is great for middle man but horrid for costs https://www.ajc.com/news/local/sandy-springs-amid-reinvention-hires-more-than-100-workers/ntGN0D4tFWZIsXM7mPHL3M/ https://www.ajc.com/news/local/sandy-springs-amid-reinventio...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ahartmetz 4y agoPrivate industry seems best for things with no natural monopolies and high demand elasticity. Natural monopolies: you get Comcast, low demand elasticity: you get US healthcare prices.
- zeruch 4y ago"private industry can produce far more efficiently than government" and yet often chooses not to, because profit does not efficiently produce gains to customers as much as "stockholders" today, and healthcare is far from the only glaring exception, its just the most terrifying to most people. And 'efficiency' isn't the sole determinant of value.