5 ms·
Shimano 105 Di2: Delivers 12-Speed Shifting, Wireless Performance to More Riders
- rektide 4y agoThe aggressively closed & closed-minded behavior of Shimano, their active legal pursuit of anyone else using the abundant data here, turndd me off incredible from the company. One example: forcing Hammerhead Karoo to remove support. https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2022/05/shimano-forces-hammerhead-to-remove-all-di2-related-functionality-from-karoo.html https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2022/05/shimano-forces-hammerhea... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31604152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31604152 (257 points, 2mo ago, 333 comments) Bikes are such a pure & free thing. Im also a computer lover, but computers are so easy to misuse for control & constraint, to obstruct involvement. It's so sad to see bicycles- a symbol of freedom & personal choice, one where standard(-ish) parts has long been a thing- fall sway to the darker corporatistic evils computing alas so often can encumber the planet with. Di2 is a defiler of spirit.
- lxe 4y agoHammerhead got bought by SRAM, which is the primary competitor of Shimano. It made sense for Shimano to remove support.
- dabeeeenster 4y agoAs a customer of both, it really didn't.
- charles_kaw 4y ago>It made sense for Shimano to remove support But, they didn't remove support. They demanded a 3rd party who had reversed their protocol remove support. They actually put legal work in to put an end to someone else's technical work. A reasonable response would be to say "use at your own risk" and refuse to put any resources to supporting the 3rd party.
- rektide 4y agoThanks! Good job calibrating. Yup!
- xhkkffbf 4y agoI like innovation and this certainly is clever. But do I really need it? I agree that it can be hard to shift cleanly but after I wiggle the levers a bit it all works out.
- serf 4y agoroad bike innovation is rarely needed, it's mostly a step of incremental small improvements that add up to a large quality of life difference. it's much more pleasant to ride a new age ergo-centric composite bike than it is to ride a Gios from the 70s, for a variety of reasons. source : family bike shop; I don't ride myself.
- gpapilion 4y agoThese are justified when looking at the truly elite level. You’re looking for fractional improvements that might add up to a watt or two. Aero frames, internal cables, spandex, are all about things that will make a marginal difference at an elite level. Disc brakes have been a bit of an outlier with extra weight and safety issues brought up by riders. Though it’s easier to internally route cables, and you can stop quicker and more predictably. Maybe the aerodynamic issues of the cables are big enough to switch for the elite riders.
- midoridensha 4y agoDisc brakes are a must-have for me on a bike now. They add a tiny bit of weight, but the performance difference much more than makes up for it. They stop faster, but they're also much easier to modulate, and their performance doesn't change when it's raining, so for real-world riding (I frequently get caught in the rain where I live, and I ride my normal bike for commuting and shopping) it's a huge safety improvement. There's no way I'm going back to rim brakes. In the future, I expect to see some improvements with disc brake hose routing. They're hydraulic, so they don't actually need to be straight like mechanical cables, so this would enable a lot of changes that can't be done with old-style cables, much like electronic shifting allows changes because it uses electric wires or even wireless comms.
- 4y ago
- dijonman2 4y agoAdding electronics to a bicycle shifter seems like an incredibly bad idea. Just because you can doesn’t mean you should.
- NoPicklez 4y agoIs this the first time you've heard of it? Because it was initially released in 2009 and is basically standard across the pro peloton. The brakes aren't electronic, only the gears.
- dijonman2 4y agoYes, first time hearing of this.
- cheeze 4y agoI'm sorry to say this, but you really couldn't be more wrong here. Electronic shifting has been a huge milestone in cycling. It's better than traditional cable shifting in almost every way.
- jamesliudotcc 4y agoIt's a tradeoff. The most recent 11 speed mechanical from Shimano is really superb--if you keep it maintained. The electronic stuff stays true if you don't maintain it, but is a pain to set up. And if anything goes wrong, it is an expensive trip to the shop. If you fancy yourself a competent home mechanic, and enjoy working on bikes, it is a step backward. (Though, internal cable routing has taken all the joy out of working on bikes.) For me, it is about lever feel. The up and down shifts are too close together. I've had this happen before, where I meant to shift down. Didn't work, so I press the button again, it is yet worse. Oh, I shifted the wrong direction, but now it is quite steep and I am quite misgeared. And shifting under load is bad for the system even if a motor drives the mech. Now i make that mistake less often, but I am still generally displeased about Di2. (Why am I on it then? My frame won't accept mechanical shift cables, and SRAM was out of stock. And I really wanted that bike.) Also, nobody really needs 12 speeds. 1x13, you can almost cover the same range as 2x10 but keep the same ratio between shifts (there are a lot of redundancies in 2x10). And then no more front shifting. 1x14 and you are there. Wake me up when that happens. Yes, Campy Ekar, I know.
- tzs 4y agoHave they done a good job at preventing hacking or disruption of the wireless parts of these systems?
- rasz 4y ago> £1,730 / $1,890 / €1,869 At that price point you can convert bike to electric assist and have same effect - easier peddling.