3 ms·
The point is that it's non-trivial to determine whether someone is simply bereaved. Or depressed, and bereaved. If someone is already depressed, bereavement is
by mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y ago
The point is that it's non-trivial to determine whether someone is simply bereaved. Or depressed, and bereaved. If someone is already depressed, bereavement is one of those things that can push them over the edge into attempting suicide. The exclusion criterion was too simplistic to cover the nuance of the differential diagnosis, so it was removed. It is a non-sequitur to say that the removal from the DSM is an endorsement of diagnosing MDD in all bereaved people. Some doctors might be doing that, but then the problem is that those doctors are doing the wrong thing, and whatever societal pressures might have affected them to do so. There is still disagreement about it in the field, and if the consensus shifts again it could very well end up being added back in, but probably I think it will evolve into a more specific diagnostic procedure to tell the cases apart.