3 ms·
> > trusted civic authorities > They'll need to be resistant to threats and bribes, so it will be difficult to have these on-site at the library. That's why I
by acdha 4y ago
> > trusted civic authorities
> They'll need to be resistant to threats and bribes, so it will be difficult to have these on-site at the library.
That's why I mentioned things like APP: some people do have a threat model where that's realistic but it's a much smaller number than the people who are inconvenienced by being locked out so it seems like it'd be a net-win for most people to be able to get unlocked easily. There are also ways to mitigate some of that risk like having notifications for all actions with an easy way to report unapproved requests, geographic restrictions, enforced MFA for the civil servant (“tap your FIDO token to approve this request”), rate-limiting, etc. which are all bread-and-butter tasks for one of the major tech companies.
The other thing I think is relevant here is the degree to which things fall back on civic authorities anyway — e.g. Facebook's process where they require scans of your government ID or the various ways you can report a deceased relative. It seems to me like it'd be better to embrace that and work better together rather than pretending there isn't already a fairly large trust relationship.