10 ms·
Net-zero commitments could limit warming to below 2 °C
- PaulHoule 4y ago"Net-zero" seems like a major setback, just as it was when the term "global warming" that people understood got replaced with "climate change" which is much muddier. If the goal is "stop burning fossil fuels" there is a large precedent of non-fossil power sources such as solar, wind, hydroelectic, nuclear, etc. Real progress is happening on electric cars. One thing that all of these have in common is that they produce a wanted product: they might be expensive or they might be intermittently available but you spend money to get something you want. "Net-zero" includes the use of systems that capture carbon directly out of the air, either all mechanical or with plants part of the system. These systems basically don't exist. I mean, there are a handful of prototype systems but there is no trend to scaling them up. The most common form of CO2 "disposal" is to inject it into an old oil well to get more oil. A large carbon capture (from the output of a power plant) system in Texas was recently shut down because they shut down the oil field. All of those systems need somebody to spend money for a product they don't want to meet an externally imposed requirement. It's going to be very hard to put a system in place to move the money around because of the perception (and reality) that anything that concentrates money in one place is going to be a nexus of corruption.
- ElectricalUnion 4y ago> "Net-zero" includes the use of systems that capture carbon directly out of the air, either all mechanical or with plants part of the system. "Plants" are very inefficient at CO2 capture. Most of the CO2 captured in Earth (by anthropogenic action or just by natural causes) is by algae/bacteria action. > If the goal is "stop burning fossil fuels" there is a large precedent of non-fossil power sources such as solar, wind, hydroelectic, nuclear, etc. > All of those systems need somebody to spend money for a product they don't want to meet an externally imposed requirement. It's going to be very hard to put a system in place to move the money around because of the perception (and reality) that anything that concentrates money in one place is going to be a nexus of corruption. If a conflict in Europe happening right now isn't a good enough incentive to make Europe immediately carbon-free, not much really is.
- Tuna-Fish 4y agoThe conflict is not going to make Europe carbon-free, it's going to reverse the trend on emissions and make Europe emit more carbon. Renewables alone cannot power the grid. You need something dispatchable for that, or the grid will fail the first time there is a night with low wind. All electricity storage in Europe is a rounding error, and will remain one for at least a decade, no matter what is done. The dispatchable power used to back up wind and solar in Europe is traditionally gas, of which much is Russian. The rapid need to decouple energy needs from Russia is causing European operators to spin coal plants back up, and even build new ones.
- adregan 4y agoIn the ideal form of net-zero, the direct air capture of CO2 is only needed to offset the hard to abate emissions—ie. jet fuel, global shipping, embodied carbon (like concrete). That future is dependent on wide scale decarbonization (in progress, albeit slowly) and, as you mention, an externally imposed requirement—from either governments or consumers. However, that period of net-zero should be a waypoint on the path to sequestering historical carbon (the real goal) but the only way to get there is to first decarbonize everything that we can. In a way, carbon credits/offsets might actually be a deterrent to that future. There is a notion of a “circular carbon economy” where CO2 is made into useful products in addition to sequestering for carbon credits, but you are right that the dominate use case for captured CO2 is enhanced oil recovery (EOR). Put to that end, there are very few practical long term benefits to sequestering carbon. That said, one benefit of offsets, tax credits, etc. is funding the creation of the carbon dioxide removal technology we will need by 2050 to offset the hard to abate emissions, but that tech is only useful if we first decarbonize as it hard to imagine it can be scaled up to the 40 gigaton level based on the data today.
- vkou 4y agoSo, we only need to do incredibly inefficient atmospheric capture of a one per two thousand part gas at a planet-wide scale with technology that nobody uses in production, with economic incentives that will somehow arise, in a world where gas prices going up 15% causes governments to fall. We are well on track to get there.
- adregan 4y agoIt is a very steep climb and nearly impossible given the status quo, and it's easy to get discouraged, so I understand your sarcasm. I've spent the past few months studying up on the state of the carbon removal world, and I was encouraged by a couple technologies (there is a lot of cool stuff out there, but there are some which seem more practical than others), which are in the "carbon utilization" bucket—appealing because the CO2 is turned into something with value rather than an abstract credit. 1) using captured carbon to create concrete aggregates as well as in the curing of concrete can make for a stronger material, a carbon sink, and doesn't require much change in behavior 2) turning captured CO2 into carbon fiber more cheaply than the current process could have knock on climate benefits if carbon fiber becomes cheap enough that it enjoys widespread use. I hope the circular carbon economy pans out because it has the power to stimulate minds. Making something of value out of the air is very "sci fi" and doesn't really ask as much from the populous at large in terms of understanding a pretty complex issue like carbon sequestering.
- lm28469 4y ago> just as it was when the term "global warming" that people understood got replaced with "climate change" which is much muddier. If by muddier you mean accurate then yes. We also replaced Newtonian physics with the much "muddier" theory of relativity. > money ... money ... money ... money Well that might be the problem, money won't do shit when 2B people will flee to the north. "We can't do X because my stack of magic paper with numbers on it will be smaller if we do so"
- 988747 4y agoAlso, "global warming" could be considered a good thing by many people. I mean, who likes cold weather? So we went from positive term, to neutral, and I guess we shift to some negative one next.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> just as it was when the term "global warming" that people understood got replaced with "climate change" which is much muddier. For the record the "climate change" phrasing is attributed to republican consultant Frank Luntz and pushed by the Bush administration allegedly as a way to make it sound less frightening. [0] Some climate organizations are correctly using the expression "climate emergency" which is more apt given the current circunstances. As a sidenote "Carbon footprint" was also a concept fabricated by Ogilvy & Mather a PR company hired by BP, with the purpose of deflecting attention away from Oil&Gas industry and onto consumers. [1] [0] https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/frank-luntz-the-man-who-came-up-with-climate-change-and-regrets-it-6v6pp00pc https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/frank-luntz-the-man-who-c... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/aug/23/big-oil-coined-carbon-footprints-to-blame-us-for-their-greed-keep-them-on-the-hook https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/aug/23/big-oi...
- PaulHoule 4y agoRight, politicians can say things like "the climate is changing all the time" to buy another 20 years of inaction. Now we are seeing big "net-zero" promises 30 or 40 years down the road, what's mostly likely is that in 15 years there is another big fad for taking action in 50 or 60 years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gruez 4y ago>For the record the "climate change" phrasing is attributed to republican consultant Frank Luntz and pushed by the Bush administration allegedly as a way to make it sound less frightening. [0] >Some climate organizations are correctly using the expression "climate emergency" which is more apt given the current circunstances. Isn't this the same thing as "climate change", but in the opposite direction?
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoNo, it is absolutely justified. CO2 emissions are still rising. We are currently cheering and celebrating reductions... in acceleration. Feedback loops like methane emissions due to permafrost melting are still gonna hit us even if we all went into caveman lifestyles right now. That means that we go into a positive feedback loop where temperature keeps raising irrespective of our actions. There are already densely populated regions getting close to 'wet bulb temperatures' which means they won't be able to sustain life much longer. There are regions that have no readiness for floods or draughts or cyclones who will now face them. Emergency sounds about right to me.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoI can't read the article due to the paywall but when I read the IPCC reports, the net-zero pathway for <2C required basically ceasing all fossil fuel consumption within a very short period of time (for <1.5C it was practically instantly). I have seen no credible plan for how we would actually do this. Especially given we haven't even managed to stop (or greatly slow) the growth of global emissions much less reduce them to zero.
- timerol 4y ago> we haven't even managed to stop (or greatly slow) the growth of global emissions We definitely have managed to greatly slow emissions growth, and it seems pretty likely that humanity's greatest carbon emitting year will happen before 2030. https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1517943601124229120/photo/1 https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1517943601124229120/ph... This is slower than it should be, but there's very promising progress to build from
- arethuza 4y agoAre those reductions (which, of course, are a very good thing) actually reflected in the Keeling Curve? https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/ https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/
- PheonixPharts 4y agoPeople like to get optimistic about accounting tricks, we're in the Eron reality when it comes to climate change. The Keeling curve shows that not only is atmospheric CO2 increasing, but the rate it is increasing is also increasing. The difference between the Keeling curve and all other measures of industrial pollution is that the CO2 in the atmosphere can be directly measured, everything else has to be estimated based on reported figures. It doesn't matter how clever you are in accounting, the atmosphere doesn't care if your reported emissions show progress towards climate goals. The methane situation is even worse[0]. 0. https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends_ch4/ https://gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends_ch4/
- esoterica 4y ago
- eloff 4y agoThere's no chance of limiting warming to 2 degrees anymore. Not only are emissions still rising, but the rate of increase is also still accelerating. It's just not a realistic goal. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2022/04/un-ipcc-1-5-degree-report-global-warming/629486/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2022/04/un-ipcc-... https://www.iea.org/news/global-co2-emissions-rebounded-to-their-highest-level-in-history-in-2021 https://www.iea.org/news/global-co2-emissions-rebounded-to-t... https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-022-00285-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-022-00285-w
- pentae 4y agoImho it will all depend on China and India coming to the party, and considering cheap oil and coal funds their expansion i can't really see that happening any time soon
- nebula8804 4y agoCan you blame them? Cheap oil and coal made the west into what it is today. Should they be denied the same ability to get to where we are today?
- nh23423fefe 4y ago"I can retire by 65... I just need a budget." Catching up to meet some goal no one understands isn't possible. The world will get warmer and warmer until some market/military/survival barrier is reached. "We need to pass this law so that in 1000 years sea levels will be X" is complete farce. I'm not saying the science is wrong. I've read the ipcc reports and im convinced of human caused warming. I'm saying being right about the science says almost nothing about what changes need to be made in the world. Humans dont care about altering the environment to meet our needs. The Holocene Extinction carries on.
- melenaboija 4y ago> I'm saying being right about the science says almost nothing about what changes need to be made in the world. What? Maybe reducing CO2 emissions? Maybe you meant that being right about the science says almost nothing about what human beings are willing to do to solve it. And I guess “science” does not have an opinion about the system we live in, arguably.
- djfobbz 4y ago
- hotpotamus 4y agoHave you considered any scientific evidence besides one article from a popular magazine 5 decades ago?
- melenaboija 4y agoAnd Columbus as someone being born in ~1400 was expecting to arrive to India sailing west.
- teraflop 4y agoA "global ice age" was never something that climatologists were seriously worried about, even in the 1970s. It was a media distortion based mainly on research into the possibility of an ice age in the distant future -- like, 10,000 years -- due to normal climate cycles. Even at the time, the much more immediate threat of anthropogenic global warming was recognized. See e.g. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26220900 https://www.jstor.org/stable/26220900 for a more detailed explanation of where this myth came from.
- lm28469 4y agoAlmost as if science is about updating our knowledge with up to date data/methods and not just living in the past
- SilverBirch 4y agoI followed your link and read the cover story. It's an article about how a middle-east oil embargo which caused Nixon to put a restriction on heating fuels and gasoline. The "Global Ice Age" you quote isn't in the article at all.
- midislack 4y ago"Could" isn't good enough to go back to the stone age on the cusp of WWIII. Sorry.
- thedogeye 4y ago
- politician 4y agoI'm sure some of you are reading or have heard of "The End of the World is Just the Beginning" by Peter Zeihan. One of the claims in his book is that the world is rapidly aging and so much so that many countries are now terminal. By "terminal" he means that the populations are past the age where they can have enough children to replace the population. Examples include Germany, China, Japan, Russia. If you believe in the evidence supporting that claim, then I think we'll be able to hit the IPCC targets simply by waiting for half the world's population to age out over the next 20-30 years. Without a replacement generation in these countries industrial output will collapse along with the energy demand. We might not need to do anything else, but of course more nuclear would help along with wind and solar if we can sort out grid storage.
- jnwatson 4y agoShort of a bigger plague than COVID or nuclear war, the static population numbers in developed countries will be dwarfed by population increases in the rest of the world.
- politician 4y agoThis is unlikely because as globalization shuts down, trade in fertilizer will slow and countries will be forced to downshift population growth in order to feed themselves according to what their own lands can produce without imported fertilizer. So, no, there won’t be large increases in population from the rest of the world.
- lm28469 4y ago> We might not need to do anything else That's just for the 2c part of the story. Because what you describe will be hell on earth for the transition generation(s) in every other aspects
- politician 4y agoAgreed. The second and third order effects of not having enough people to support the elderly population will be extreme. Still, it’s unavoidable, so we’d better come to grips with what is happening.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 4y agoBetween the walk-back of basic human rights in the West through COVID, nuclear superpowers currently appearing to be locked in a state of war and the US on a path of unchecked money printing I'm not sure global warming is in my top 3 civilisational crisises at the moment. Arguably I suppose a monstrous heat wave in India could bump it back up, but really even then we'd be better off facing with cheap energy than walking back from the gains made with fossil fuels over the last 20-30 years. And the environmental activists are serious contributes to the instability in Europe with their weird insistence that people put ideology before energy security. The Germans screwed up their energy policy because they insisted on policy by ideology and unfounded fear of nuclear.
- weakfish 4y agoWhat basic human rights were violated through COVID?
- biofox 4y agoPeople don't like being told to cooperate for the greater good. Wish more people knew about the tragedy of the commons, and how the survival of our species depends on selfless cooperation.
- ch4s3 4y agoEven if you're strongly in favor of the more sever restrictions of early 2020 in the US and Europe you have to acknowledge that a lot of normal rights were suspended with the aim of combatting the pandemic. New Zealand even suspended the right of its citizens to return home for a long period of time, which is a pretty harsh violation of rights, and runs contrary to international law. New Zealand's own high court found that to be the case.
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoNew Zealand’s high court found the lottery system used to allocate quarantine spots and the wait time infringed on its citizens’ rights, not forcing a quarantine. However, Mallon did find that requiring returning New Zealanders to quarantine was not in itself an unjustified infringement. https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/new-zealand-high-court-finds-quarantine-allocation-system-infringed-rights-2022-04-27/ https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/new-zealand-high-...
- photochemsyn 4y agoHere's where we are headed at present I think, just a question of how fast: > "Carbon dioxide concentration during the mid-Pliocene has been estimated at around 400 ppmv... However, the global average temperature in the mid-Pliocene (3.3 Ma–3 Ma) was 2–3°C higher than today, global sea level 25 meters higher, and the northern hemisphere ice sheet was ephemeral before the onset of extensive glaciation over Greenland that occurred in the late Pliocene around 3 Ma." (pliocene climate wiki) This article is paywalled but it essentially looks to be very similar to an open-access paper (2020) by the same research group. The permafrost and soil carbon feedbacks under different scenarios (Fig 3) are worth looking at: https://gmd.copernicus.org/articles/13/3571/2020/ https://gmd.copernicus.org/articles/13/3571/2020/ Realistically, the only things that would noticeably slow the current climate trajectory over the next 100 years are major supervolcanoes or asteroid impacts. Hence, adaptation to new regional climate norms is going to be necessary. However, continuing to burn fossil fuels at current rates for the next 100 years would accelerate that trajectory somewhat and have major consequences for the 2100-2200+ timeline.
- trention 4y agoNet zero worldwide will never be achieved with pure emission reduction because neither China nor the industrializing third world will ever accept trading carbon usage for lower (than potential) living standards. The only way this works is with massive investment in carbon capture. Reducing emissions is nice but alone will never solve the problem.
- thepangolino 4y ago
- throwawaymanbot 4y ago
- Ekaros 4y agoIs net-zero even technically feasible on any reasonable time-scale we operate? And I mean actual net-zero that is permanently not emitting more CO2.
- haltingproblem 4y agoWhat confuses me is that everyone is pledging net-zero by some date but emissions keep rising. So somehwere someone is "laundering" emissions. A quick perusal of the offset-credit industry shows that there is massive recycling (reuse) of credits, relabeling of existing sinks as offsets and all the financial engineering and shenanigans that happen when commons are financialized. This all makes me very skeptical of lean towards the opinion that climate salvation lies in an alternate energy source which makes fossil fuels uneconomic.
- gruez 4y ago>What confuses me is that everyone is pledging net-zero by some date but emissions keep rising. So somehwere someone is "laundering" emissions. Nah it's way simpler than that. They're just setting targets and not following them. >Climate Action 100+, a pressure group formed by 700 investment funds, aims to ensure that 166 of the world’s biggest greenhouse-gas emitters align with the Paris targets. It said this year that 69% of them were committed to reach net zero by 2050 or sooner. However, only 17% had set medium-term targets or produced quantified decarbonisation strategies. Almost two-thirds of oil and gas companies are still pursuing projects inconsistent with limiting global warming below 2°C, it noted. https://www.economist.com/special-report/2022/07/21/internalising-the-externalities https://www.economist.com/special-report/2022/07/21/internal...
- gmuslera 4y agoNet-zero is a compromise by most countries that by 2050 they will somewhat "compensate" what they will keep emitting. That doesn't mean reducing the excess of GHG from the atmosphere, doesn't deal with positive reinforcement loops like permafrost thawing or running into a blue ocean event, and will keep worsening the environment like ocean acidification, extreme(r) weather event and more unwanted consequences. And, of course, to keep unearthing fossil carbon and adding it to the system, the compensation may not be so long lasting (I don't know, like planting trees that ends being burned up). It would be like stop accelerating, but to keep going at an already dangerous speed, like falling after reaching terminal velocity. Yes, we might not be accelerating anymore, but we should expect more than just broken bones.