5 ms·
If a large percentage of computer users who use the library exclusively have ID, the library could purchase a MF device or cheap android phone running an MFA ap
by gumby 4y ago
If a large percentage of computer users who use the library exclusively have ID, the library could purchase a MF device or cheap android phone running an MFA app and use the same device for every user or many users: show your ID, librarian verifies that you're registered, and then come over and log you in with key + username (user still enters password).
Would it be possible for some nefarious person to grab these keys? Yes, but essentially you're reducing the MFA back down to SFA, a cost I think likely worth it for this group.
- asciimov 4y agoForcing public libraries to use a workaround to fix a problem Google created isn't an ideal solution.
- gumby 4y agoI'm not sure what an ideal solution might look like. Do you have a thought on that? OTOH this library use case is a specific kind of outlier: I imagine this issue occurs in most/all libraries; it's a situation where changing the level of security is worth the tradeoff; it doesn't affect the security of anyone else; it's relatively inexpensive. I don't consider this a "blame the victim" solution to the problem. I see it as an accommodation for people with specific but special needs.