3 ms·
I strong disagree. This isn’t a tech issue, it’s a poorly delivered solution that didn’t consider the needs of the users. The solution is so poorly delivered li
by Spooky23 4y ago
I strong disagree. This isn’t a tech issue, it’s a poorly delivered solution that didn’t consider the needs of the users. The solution is so poorly delivered librarians are an ad hoc support team for thousands of people.
Google in particular created a moral problem by choosing to implement a security solution that doesn’t serve people who depend on the services. They have the metrics to know better, but didn’t consider the use case.
I provide services to users in these use cases. It’s very possible to serve them in a way that is both secure and respectful to humans.
- Mezzie 4y agoI honestly can't remember who implemented 2FA in this case first, but it's not only a Google problem. People also end up locked out of their Yahoo and AOL accounts fairly regularly. > The solution is so poorly delivered librarians are an ad hoc support team for thousands of people. Well, yes. We're also expected to be teachers, social workers, etc. Everybody has been outsourcing/dumping the unprofitable work on us for decades now, why would Google and other tech companies act any differently? It's a problem that goes deeper than Google and the tech companies; it's a general assumption that infrastructure design can ignore the worst off parts of society and that people like volunteers and librarians will step in without considering whether or not we have the capacity for that as a society. I just think instead of 'Google, fix it', it would have been wiser to make clear that this is a general problem (not a Google specific one) and to suggest things like partnerships between the GMail team and the PLA, etc. I'm saying this in the spirit of 'yes, we need to take this territory but maybe a cavalry charge isn't the best way to do that given the other side has machine guns'.