3 ms·
> Well your past history of housing problems would suggest your optimism here is misplaced Who is 'you' in that sentence? I can see that I have optimism, but
by eru 4y ago
> Well your past history of housing problems would suggest your optimism here is misplaced
Who is 'you' in that sentence? I can see that I have optimism, but what's my past history of housing problems?
And what makes you so sure that those past problems were caused by not enough regulation? (Instead of eg too much regulation, the wrong kind of regulation, or they might have nothing to do with regulation at all.)
> If you can pick a property based on the reputation of the builder than you're already in a class above most people.
Huh? It's always a trade-off. All else being equal, I'd grab a house from a builder (or landlord) with a great reputation before one without a reputation or even a bad reputation. I might even pay a bit extra for a great reputation.
Your argument would apply equally well to jobs: people need a job just as much as they need housing. Yet, employers with great reputation still find it easier to attract good applicants than those with lousy reputations.
> I know you want to believe that a free market fixes all of life's problems but it's really not that simple.
Who said that? Huh?
I suggested that in this specific case more regulation is not required.
The free market won't get you a girlfriend, for example. But neither would any sensible regulation.
> We have much stricter regulations in Europe and it doesn't harm our commerce. So you absolutely can have a vibrant market and regulations to protect consumers.
You know that European real GDP per capita is quite a lot lower than in the US? (You can pick almost any European country. Or pick the average etc.)
And the US is also still pretty overregulated.
I grew up in Germany, but put my money where my mouth is, and now live in rather more pro-market Singapore.
- hnlmorg 4y agoI think we're just going to have to agree to disagree on this. Partly because this is really more of an opinion-based discussion but also because comparing Singapore to the US or Europe is never going to work given how massively different their cultures are. So there's far more variables at play than just how the markets are run. That all said, one part did stick out for me: > Your argument would apply equally well to jobs: people need a job just as much as they need housing. Yet, employers with great reputation still find it easier to attract good applicants than those with lousy reputations. I'd argue that disproves your point rather than proves it. The reason being, lousy jobs still exist because employers know that people need jobs. So there's no incentive for employers to change. Hence why we need employment laws.
- eru 4y agoYour argument would prove that almost all jobs are lousy and only provide the legal minimum required for pay, safety, etc. In Singapore our legal minimum wage is 0. However good luck finding anyone working for 0 dollars. I would suggest checking why jobs exceed the legal minimum, and how we can ensure more people can have better jobs. (My view is perfectly compatible with there being some crappy jobs, and some people even taking those crappy jobs.)
- hnlmorg 4y agoThis comes back to my point about different cultures. For example some American and UK companies have been gaming the system, arguing that people who work from them are not employees. In the UK we call them gig workers (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gig_worker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gig_worker) and they're effectively working for 0 "dollars" if business is slow that day. Yet some people work them simply because they have no other choice.
- eru 4y agoIn Singapore, we just have employment laws that aren't as strenuous on the employer, so there's less need to 'game the system'. Oversimplified: legally everyone is already a gig worker in Singapore. Seems to work out fairly well. This is also closer to how the system worked in eg the US until a few decades ago, when it was easier to get a job just by walking into the shop and asking and also work your way through college etc. I remember, Slatestarcodex had an article about the dangers of outsourcing your social welfare to employers.
- hnlmorg 4y agoI feel this point is getting lost on you but Singapore has a vastly different culture to America. The fact that Singapore doesn't need to "game the system" isn't because there are fewer regulations. It's because it's a different culture. The reason America needs legislation is because American companies have a culture of abusing a free market. What works for one country doesn't automatically work for another.