7 ms·
About a decade ago, a broken iPhone caused me to experience how bad Google's MFA reset process was — there were multiple _years_ where the “hard landing” form t
by acdha 4y ago
About a decade ago, a broken iPhone caused me to experience how bad Google's MFA reset process was — there were multiple _years_ where the “hard landing” form triggered a flow which sent an email to an internal mailbox which didn't exist! — and while I was able to use printed backup codes after I returned home the experience left me concerned enough that I went to one of their identity group's public meetings here in DC.
One of the things which I was struck by was how unseriously they appeared to view their role in modern life. People were generally very casual about the need and were especially uninterested in anything which required them to work with outside parties.
My suggestion was that they consider a protocol where trusted civic authorities could be allowed to confirm someone's identity, which sounds like it would be useful for this case: let the person initiate a mediated reset flow where someone like a librarian, police officer, etc. could authenticate in their official capacity and check a box saying that they've confirmed the photo ID for the person standing in front of them. Most of the benefits from MFA are preventing things like phishing attacks which are also stymied by limiting it to people in your geographic area, although you might want to disable this for high-risk people enrolled in Google's Advanced Protection Program.
- _wldu 4y agoI agree with your suggestion. I think Post Offices, DMVs, and large reputable retailers (Walmart, Target, Cellular Phone companies, etc.) could verify our identities for a small fee and help us reset our social accounts when needed. I arrived at the same conclusion and wrote a blog post about it a few years ago: https://www.go350.com/posts/now-they-have-2fa-problems/ https://www.go350.com/posts/now-they-have-2fa-problems/
- lesuorac 4y agoAren't half of those things you listed (Walmart, Target, Cellular Phone companies, etc.) also exactly how people get unauthorized access? You convince the employee to port "your" number and they do so and then you reset that accounts password? https://www.wptv.com/money/consumer/phone-porting-leads-to-stolen-identity-and-bank-funds https://www.wptv.com/money/consumer/phone-porting-leads-to-s...
- eli 4y agoMake it a choice. It sure sounds like the patrons of this library would opt in.
- rob74 4y agoWell, good old Yahoo Mail does that. Time and time again it tries to convince me to set up 2FA (for an account I use rarely), and time and time again I say "No" - and that's it! The library patrons would probably be very happy with that...
- izacus 4y agoI distinctly remember lynching from HN security crowd when SIM cards were being unlocked and moved to new people from "trusted companies" like Verizon and AT&T. HN demanded for such security holes to be disabled and prevented - what changed since then?
- dereg 4y agoWhat changed is that we're starting to learn about the breadth of needs by people with different lives and opportunity sets, and feel at least a desire to talk through potential solutions for a subset of people who opt into it. If the worst thing that people could commit in this discussion is hypocrisy, I'm sure they're willing to step over that line.
- ebiester 4y agoWhat changes is that there are different needs from different segments of the world, and we have reached a problem (authentication in general) that is truly impossible to solve with our current toolset. For me, the larger threat is that someone impersonates me and takes everything I have. If I lost my email, it would be a nightmare but I could work around significant portions of the system. For my cousin, the larger threat is losing her email, as she has no significant assets to steal but could run into every problem in the email. There are likely people in the middle as well, and other threat vectors. (For example: caregivers committing fraud, dementia, state actors, and 20 other we could brainstorm pretty quickly.) Perhaps the right answer is that we need 20 different services that can segment. Perhaps the problem is that some sectors aren't profitable: maybe we need a grant for emails for poor people with a circle of trust. I don't have answers. Maybe we need a collection of people to think deeply about this problem.
- vkou 4y agoWalmart may be a reputable retailer, but it is utterly disreputable in being a reliable arbiter of identity. It doesn't train its employees well, its employees are often not the brightest bolts an the box, and those that are often don't give a shit. As for post offices, they aren't eligible because half the government is actively trying to kill them.
- Nitramp 4y agoThis is widely implemented and used in Germany: https://www.deutschepost.de/en/p/postident.html https://www.deutschepost.de/en/p/postident.html It's a lot easier to implement reliably due to the requirement for everyone to have ID cards though (and the ID cards carry your residence address).
- jethkl 4y agoThat sounds like a good idea! Perhaps expand what notaries do?
- sumtechguy 4y agoIt sounds nice. if everyone plays nice. Slip some underpaid gov worker a 50 and suddenly you are someone else. There would need to be abuse provisions put in place. Then a whole org around that too. Not saying it can not be done, but it looks like to me is Google has a poor customer service issue, even if not true. Roping our govs into doing googles customer service seems odd.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Slip some underpaid gov worker a 50 and suddenly you are someone else. by that logic, slip some policeman a $50 and they might plant drugs on your enemy or shoot him because he had a wallet that looked like a gun. Have employees of private conoaniea never been involved in fraud?
- bumby 4y agoIt's a real concern, but how is this different from the current ink & paper scenario? I know people who use county notaries to keep important documents and we, as a society, have apparently deemed that an acceptable risk. Is the distinction the potential scope and scale of digital theft?
- paulryanrogers 4y agoLibrary op-sec is pretty weak IME. Mine accepted seeing an email of a utility bill on my phone. Which is probably fine for just checking out books. I still love libraries and the services they provide. But wouldn't want them to be an arbiter of identity any more than a faceless, human hostile corporation.
- robjan 4y agoI wonder if that's deliberate. My bank also accepted an email utility bill but they said they only ask for the utility bill to prove that you didn't make a careless mistake when entering your address.
- Semaphor 4y ago> Mine accepted seeing an email of a utility bill on my phone. To be fair, tons of places use those as proof of residence. It’s not as if it makes a real difference if you print them first.
- eli 4y agoIt's supposed to be easy to get a library card! The threat of an out-of-towner getting a local library card is nothing like a stranger getting access to your inbox.
- rob74 4y agoSo we have come full circle: starting from a call for help from a librarian seeing lots of people unable to access their accounts because of 2FA, we have proposed various methods of avoiding that, and then concluded that it's better if 100 people are locked out of their own accounts rather than letting one unauthorized person access an account that isn't theirs? I guess that's Google's position as well, because if they let someone unauthorized log in they might be liable, whereas if they lock 100 people out they can say it's their fault...
- eli 4y agoNo, I'm saying those situations aren't comparable. We should not conclude librarians will be poor stewards of MFA reset powers just because they are lax in giving out library cards.
- Mezzie 4y agoI think something like this could work iff the accounts were required to be set up by said civic authorities with confirmable paperwork. Otherwise, librarians are stuck awkwardly trying to decide if 'John Doe' really owns the email account 'ILoveButts64@gmail.com'. I also doubt this will ever happen since it would require more $$$ for things that are not profit generating and supports a population that is useless from the tech companies' POV.
- ryukafalz 4y agoOr now that I think about it… for 2FA in particular, what about enrolling a software FIDO token with an extension on every library computer that can be triggered by a librarian from their desk? Doesn’t require hardware for each patron, only applies to accounts that have been enrolled at the library. Feels like it could work.
- robertlagrant 4y agoThen it opens up a backdoor for malicious (or socially engineered) library staff to access email accounts.
- Mezzie 4y agoAnd given that a lot of the staff working those desks aren't librarians + are working part time, it's also great incentive for bad actors to get jobs in libraries specifically to start stealing that data.
- warkdarrior 4y agoNot sure data theft from homeless or poor people is a major threat. What could an attacker gain from that?
- Mezzie 4y agoI can see some value in it for scammers, hackers, and businesses that pray on the poor. (For example the 'buy now, pay later' Aaron's Rent-A-Center type businesses). Or for identity theft.
- trasz 4y agoWhy would Google want to do this? Current 2FA suits its role perfectly: it prevents a large scale leak, one that would result in bad PR. There is no incentive for Google to care for individual users.
- Spooky23 4y agoThe government is slowly figuring out digital ID and will show up to regulate it. Identity is too critical a business for services companies like Google to walk away from. It’s stupid, because once the camel gets it’s nose in the tent, it will cost them more.
- jjoonathan 4y ago> trusted civic authorities They'll need to be resistant to threats and bribes, so it will be difficult to have these on-site at the library. I think we've overlooked an option. Note that the article's objection to FIDO keys was financial, not UX. This sort of confirms the hunch I got when first playing with them: "hey, the key metaphor is so strong and intuitive that these might be even better than passwords for people with low tech literacy." I held off on saying anything until their compatibility actually lived up to the hype, which IIRC only happened in 2020 (all major browsers, all major platforms, by default), but it did happen. As for the financial barrier, yeah, it's wild that these are still $30/ea on Amazon. Can they be bought cheap in bulk? Or does the market need some aggressive new entrants? In any case, they are "near practical" and the shove needed to make them "very practical" is probably 100x smaller than, say, creating a Central Bureau of A12N.
- raisin_churn 4y agoIt is not uncommon for unhoused people to lose all their possessions, so even if purchasing multiple hardware security keys wasn't a huge financial hurdle, the recovery model I use (Yubikey on my keychain, two in my safe, mail one to my parents) falls apart for those on the margins of society. If email is an essential service in modern society, recovering access to it from some first principle of identity is essential. I don't have an easy answer for how to do that, but I also don't have a trillion dollar market cap.
- jjoonathan 4y agoThat's true, we still need a good last-ditch fallback. FIDO could still save a lot of people from the hard login screen, the phone number gotcha, and the need to become literate in information-keys. Last-ditch fallback becomes a lot more viable at any given expenditure level if it doesn't have to serve as the primary authentication mechanism for half of the library's elders.
- deepdriver 4y agoThe CEO of Fastmail, a company which deals directly with the ID problem as an email provider with customer service, has made some insightful comments on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15864579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15864579 I am a happy Fastmail customer, in a large part due to trust inspired by Bron’s comments.
- fluidcruft 4y agoIn this situation, maybe one thing that could help is if the library holds on to the backup codes for patrons. So they can sort of act as a quasi trusted authority. In fact if these people can't even log in without backup codes, they can just keep their password in their wallet. Of course, yubikeys also work very well in this situation. So the library could sell a yubikey and keep backup codes on file for in case the yubikey is lost. Or since you can store so many identities on an individual yubikey, just give the librarians one.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI was thinking among options: - Library is a Group Administrator for patrons' Google accounts. - Library offers its own email services to patrons. - Library holds recovery codes (perferably under some sort of escrow). All of these put burden on the library, of course. Though there's already a substantial burden. There's also the issue of itenerant / mobile patrons who may only be using a library on a temporary basis or operate between several locations. How much this is a use pattern I've no idea. The USPS offering email services might be yet another option. Points of presence in every ZIP code, often several. Given other ongoing challenges (housing is now a full-blown crisis), the problem of mobile / indigent / precarious indivudal will only grow. The pattern is also likely to be repeated in other global regions.
- Spooky23 4y agoLots of services are available to opt-in to validate identity. In fact, Google sells solutions on the cloud side.
- highwaylights 4y agoIt’s an absolutely catastrophic experience, that they clearly don’t take seriously. Regulation solves this. I hate to say that, as so much of tech regulation is a ham-fisted disaster that misunderstands the problem and creates even bigger ones, but this is really a very serious problem that can ruin lives, and regulators really should step in here. I’ve known a couple of people who have been through this experience, and one in particular who not only couldn’t get back in to their account - but had no way of knowing if someone else was able to get in to the account later. They’ll never know. It will never be possible to know. The kicker is that they could never have their data deleted due to the same problem. And no amount of help or time spent with chat support ever changed anything.
- kova12 4y agoCan you describe how regulation solves this problem, how exactly are you proposing for this regulation to work?
- prepend 4y agoI’m not GP, but I expect that regulation could help by requiring customer service. Similar to banking. And there could be an agency similar to CFPB where citizens could appeal who would then make formal investigations. So regulation would force the workflow described in the article to not have a grim outcome for elderly users of gmail.
- skybrian 4y agoSince opening all these offices costs money, this means that the accounts can't be free anymore. I suppose they could be subsidized by the state for low income people.
- prepend 4y agoNot necessarily. The margin is really high on Google services even though they are free. I don’t know Google well enough to know what they would need to do to offer non-shitty service. Maybe they show more ads. I also think they could automate good service if they wanted to, but it’s not a priority and they aren’t required. I used financial services before and after CFPB and I don’t remember price increases on my bank accounts. So perhaps something similar would apply here.
- afiori 4y agoIn EU (Italy) there is eIDAS (SPID) that could allow this. It is essentially a national SSO. Today it requires almost always a Android/iOS phone AFAIK, but it could easily be massaged to solve this problem. The system is set up so that your account is owned by the state, and you can register with documents to providers; then after certification they run the actual SSO process. A library provider could set up a computer that automatically passes the SSO login for your national account after certificating your identity. Honestly this feels a bit too open to social engineering attacks, but probably there is a good middle ground. Edit: Maybe in the US this is already almost possible by extending something like https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIPS_201 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIPS_201
- reaperducer 4y agoa protocol where trusted civic authorities could be allowed to confirm someone's identity This is already a solved problem, and without getting the government involved. There are plenty of identification confirmation companies out there. If you've ever requested your credit report, or applied for a new apartment online, you've probably interacted with one. Oh, but that's an expense. It might costs pennies per user! Google doesn't do expenses. It would rather spend money on rooms full of toys and gourmet catering than on helping people use its own products.
- vkou 4y agoA credit report on John Doe doesn't prove that I'm John Doe, it only tells you whether or not John Doe is likely to pay his bills on time. This thread, in general, is a great example of engineer hubris. It looks at a complicated problem, and all the top discussion sub-threads are highly up-voted non-solutions to it.
- acdha 4y agoThat doesn't show that you're that person, however, only that you've learned some trivia about them — often details which are visible on Facebook, pilferable from their mail, or known to no longer trustwothy family members & friends. My hope would be that we could find a way to reliably fall back on a government ID check since, for example, an abusive ex who knows all of those details doesn't look like their target.