5 ms·
Not sure why you'd need any legislation? The higher insurance premiums already send exactly the right incentives, don't they?
by eru 4y ago
Not sure why you'd need any legislation? The higher insurance premiums already send exactly the right incentives, don't they?
- kortilla 4y agoWhen you’re a hammer, all you see are nails.
- eru 4y agoMost people are not regulators by trade, yet they see a lot of need for regulation.
- kortilla 4y agoIf you live in a representative democracy and vote for politicians that expand regulations, you are effectively regulating. > yet they see a lot of need for regulation Of course they do, their ideology reaches for that solution by default. Look at this particular thread just to see how misguided the recommendation for regulation was in this case.
- eru 4y ago> If you live in a representative democracy and vote for politicians that expand regulations, you are effectively regulating. Yes and No. I have a lot of sympathies for that argument, but also for the view that individual votes don't matter.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoDoes the person choosing the wire know about and pay the ongoing future insurance premiums? See builders/landlords and insulation.
- eru 4y agoI would assume that a house that has fewer ongoing maintenance costs would sell or rent for more (in a competitive market)? If buyer or renters are totally oblivious, why offer any features at all?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYeah, with perfect information these wouldn't compete. This is why some countries put energy efficiency labels on products and on property sales. To make the market work better. Some countries just prefer to ignore long term problems for short term "gains" though, in a tragic fractal way.
- eru 4y agoI'm not sure why you talk about countries? I don't think there's any law anywhere that prohibits a manufacturer from sticking the required information on their product and in their marketing. As a customer, I can draw my own conclusions when a manufacturer doesn't provide the information: I'll assume that thing is a gas guzzler and will avoid it. (Unless I read trusted reviews to the contrary.)
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's not the law that prevents the people in a Prisoners Dilemma situation from freely choosing the best outcome for themselves. It's the lack of enforcement of rules which incentives defection. In this case: good guy installs insulation bad guy doesn't good guy publishes info on future savings bad guy publishes fake info good guy publishes trusted reviews bad guy publishes fake reviews. and so on. The good guys want the legislation, not to force then to do the thing they wanted to do anyway, they want it to stop bad guys putting them out of business via scamming customers.
- eru 4y agoIterated prisoners dilemmas evolve cooperation naturally. > bad guy publishes fake info That's already illegal. > bad guy publishes fake reviews. That's already illegal.
- r_hoods_ghost 4y agoNot really. If the higher insurance costs are born by the building owner rather than the person who installs the wiring (which is likely the case), then increased insurance premiums aren't likely to haveuch effect. Classic externality
- eru 4y agoSurely there must be some causal connection between the building owner and the wire installer? (If not, why bother installing wires at all?)
- tibbetts 4y agoThe causal connection can be remarkably tenuous, especially if you add securitization or other financialization into the mix. The people supplying the money often care more about hitting standards than maximizing overall eventual profit. Understanding this aspect of human and market behavior is useful for realizing why a lot of libertarian ideas are unworkable in practice.
- eru 4y agoNot sure, it's very workable for lots of other aspects of buildings. Eg I don't think there's a legislation that floorplans have to be useful (and how would you even define that in the abstract). Yet, most buildings have quite reasonable floorplans. There's some transaction costs in that its hard for the eventually consumer of the building to express all their preference to the builder. As you say, for some aspects the price signals can be weak. More competition can help. See also how it's pretty easy to find restaurants that serve tasty food, despite taste not being legislated nor regulated.
- midenginedcoupe 4y agoHa! Thanks, I needed a laugh this morning. But seriously though, since when did Laissez-faire economics and legislation ever lead to sufficient safety not to kill people or burn down their homes willy-nilly? HN is the only place I visit that has such wild ideas as "safety regs are too burdensome, let the free market sort it out".
- eru 4y agoCompare eg https://www.econlib.org/dont-regulate-health-and-safety/ https://www.econlib.org/dont-regulate-health-and-safety/ I did not suggest throwing out any existing regulation, merely that we don't need more regulation. Surely you can not argue that we need an infinite amount of more regulation? There must be some level that's enough?
- londons_explore 4y agoIn the UK, only around 1 person per year is killed by electricity in the home. And often that person is doing something totally non-standard, for example building a tesla coil, or deliberately committing suicide. Contrast that to 250,000 deaths per year (in the USA) by medical mistakes or preventable adverse effects. At some point, we have to decide where to put our efforts. Electrical safety is arguably oversolved - ie. we put too much effort into it compared to the safety gain of any extra effort, compared to medical accidents which is likely undersolved. Even simple things like requiring a doctor to not do more than an 8 hour shift, like we require of truck drivers, would probably save a lot of lives. The idea of 'more safety is always better' needs to be broken.