3 ms·
> You can store electricity from day to night, but not from Summer to Winter. Hydrogen can do that.
by pfdietz 4y ago
> You can store electricity from day to night, but not from Summer to Winter.
Hydrogen can do that.
- adrian_b 4y agoSynthetic hydrocarbons can do that much better than hydrogen. Also ammonia can do that much better than hydrogen. There are also several types of flow batteries which can store energy for any time desired, without losses. Compared to hydrocarbons or ammonia they have a low energy density (which is not prohibitive for stationary applications), but they have a higher energy efficiency for a charge and discharge cycle, similar to the other kinds of batteries. Hydrogen is the worst solution for long-term energy storage, compared to the many other alternatives, which are also already proven in practice, unlike hydrogen. Hydrogen is good only for rockets, when its low mass is more important than its high volume and all its other disadvantages.
- pfdietz 4y agoSynthetic hydrocarbons requires you either capture CO2 from the atmosphere, or capture, store, and reuse the CO2 of combustion from your turbines (so you're still storing compressed gases underground; you've also made the per-output-power part of your system more costly, which is very undesirable for rarely used backup storage). The round trip efficiency with hydrogen will also be higher, since you don't have to do either of those and the process that makes hydrocarbons starts with H2 and CO2 and is significantly below 100% efficient. Flow batteries would be better than ordinary batteries, but would still be costly for seasonal storage or rare event backup compared to hydrogen (especially flow batteries using vanadium).
- credit_guy 4y agoI agree with you that Hydrogen can do that. Or that at least it stands a chance. Both nuclear and Hydrogen are unproven at this point, for the scale we need. Europe has chosen to bet it all on Hydrogen. Although, in the last one year France decided to get back in the game of building nuclear. I see no talk of Hydrogen in the US.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoSpace X are building the worlds largest Green Hydrogen project in Texas (intended for turning into methane for rockets amongst other things). Will probably be one of those things where there will be a new worlds largest record every month for years and it'll get into arguments about who has actually started production and so on, but it's definately a global thing. Current headlines suggest US Green Hydrogen could be the cheapest in the world due to some mooted subsidies: https://www.rechargenews.com/energy-transition/world-s-largest-green-hydrogen-project-unveiled-in-texas-with-plan-to-produce-clean-rocket-fuel-for-elon-musk/2-1-1178689 https://www.rechargenews.com/energy-transition/world-s-large...