7 ms·
This isn't a problem Seattle can solve on its own -- whether resident, business owner, police, mayor, or otherwise. Hyperfocusing on RV vs concrete blocks is mi
by solardev 4y ago
This isn't a problem Seattle can solve on its own -- whether resident, business owner, police, mayor, or otherwise. Hyperfocusing on RV vs concrete blocks is missing the forest for the trees. This is the new face of urban America, where rampant wealth inequality makes it so that many people have no viable alternative to living on the streets. Instead of depression-era tenements, we have luxury apartments next to tent cities. There is a lot more money these days, but it's so concentrated in the hands of so few that everyone else is left fighting over scraps. Seattle is dying. San Francisco is dying. Portland is dying. All victims of their own successes, that perfect storm of a gilded, top-heavy society crushing those beneath them, combined with public policy that has turned a blind eye to decreasing real purchasing power for decades, all veneered over by a thin layer of new money and bravado.
Blame drugs, blame political opponents, blame the government, blame developers, blame tech bros, blame whatever or whoever you want... but at the end of the day, still no solution is in sight. There is no widespread push for affordable housing or a pathway out of poverty, no real long-term care for people fighting addictions or mental illness. There is only the relentless push for profit for a few as society crumbles around them and more and more Americans get displaced.
It's going to get a lot worse before it gets better. We're circling the drain with no end in sight.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoSan Francisco spends $61k/year/tent [1] on homeless tents, which is more than median income in the US. The problem is not funding. The problem is that the local population would rather spin performative activism instead of taking real action (i.e. institutionalizing mentally ill people and forcing people off the streets and to stop using heroin and meth). [1] https://sfist.com/2021/03/04/insanely-it-is-costing-san-francisco/ https://sfist.com/2021/03/04/insanely-it-is-costing-san-fran...
- woodruffw 4y agoForced institutionalization is plainly unconstitutional, and there's no particular evidence that you can disappear whichever group of undesirables you see fit and guarantee that more won't appear. The homeless don't spontaneously generate from other homeless; they come from the same households that you and I do. The solution is what it's always been: a universal housing mandate, and adequate social services (including harm reduction). The things stopping that aren't "performative activism"; it's Seattle's pathological disdain for housing and a polite-society liberal ethos that values property values over human lives.
- ceeplusplus 4y ago> Forced institutionalization is plainly unconstitutional It is not illegal to arrest someone for stealing/drug use/etc. and then have a psychiatrist examine them to determine whether they should go to jail or be institutionalized. Courts regularly examine criminals for mental fitness to stand trial already. > no particular evidence that you can disappear whichever group of undesirables you see fit and guarantee that more won't appear Funny, because that's exactly what lots of cities do and it works pretty well. Take a look at any wealthy SoCal city and you'll find no homeless. > a universal housing mandate, and adequate social services (including harm reduction) So, spending more than the median American makes per year on tents? Or allowing crazy drug addicts to trash temporary housing and hotels? Because that's what happens in SF. From the SF Chronicle, which is a super left leaning publication: "Residents have threatened to kill staff members, chased them with metal pipes and lit fires inside rooms, incident reports show. At the Henry Hotel on Sixth Street, a tenant was hospitalized after a neighbor, for a second time, streamed bug spray into their eyes, public records show. Last May, less than a mile away at the Winton Hotel, a resident slashed another tenant’s face with a knife, leaving a trail of blood out of the building" [1] And from the director running one of these programs: "“We throw all these people into our hotels who have no demonstrated ability to live independently, who have severe problems and need to be elsewhere,” Shaw said" Clearly the problem is not housing, it's the lack of support around getting mentally ill people the treatment (i.e. institutionalization) they need. And obviously, a crazy person is not going to consent to treatment for their craziness, so you need to force them into institutionalization. [1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/projects/2022/san-francisco-sros/ https://www.sfchronicle.com/projects/2022/san-francisco-sros...
- solardev 4y agoI'm all for forced institutionalization, as long as we start with our politicians.
- woodruffw 4y ago> It is not illegal to arrest someone for stealing/drug use/etc. and then have a psychiatrist examine them to determine whether they should go to jail or be institutionalized. Courts regularly examine criminals for mental fitness to stand trial already. It is if the arrest is pretextual; that’s functionally no different from rounding up whichever group you think is bad and working backwards to disappear them. In any case, nobody who lives in a van, tent, or even on the street meets the standard for forced institutionalization by those conditions alone. See the other thread. > Funny, because that's exactly what lots of cities do and it works pretty well. Take a look at any wealthy SoCal city and you'll find no homeless. I was under the impression that Los Angeles is both extremely wealthy and has lots of homeless. I’ve only visited once, however. Either way: you surely understand that “move them somewhere else” is not a sustainable solution. You can’t sweep human lives under the rug in a country that has due process, as threadbare as ours might be. The rest of the comment ignores what “housing mandate” really means: it means a combination of shelters, supported living (including mental institutions), and independent living based on the needs and capabilities of the individual.
- zmgsabst 4y agoThe huge expense per homeless to little effect has been dubbed the “Homeless Industrial Complex”: A lot of money goes to politicians, their supporters, and bourgeois — while only a small percentage goes to fixing homelessness. This is essentially looting the public by corrupt actors under the false guise of moral action.
- dmix 4y agoIt might sound like some intentional conspiracy but it's mostly just a natural consequence of the stalemate. As long as new home development is crippled by zoning, NIMBYism, and the endless related issues it's only natural for those who care to become cynical and team up with those who don't to find ways to feed the never-ending demand for performative action (backed by millions of dollars) with a supply of expensive temporary solutions.
- collegeburner 4y agoi urge you to talk to ppl who have run low income housing. from the people i know who done it they quit bc it cost more to maintain it with all the damage and crime then a modest blue collar unit. "building more housing" dont fix nothing if the ppl who live there treat it like shit attract crime and don't reliably pay.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoWhy do you avoid proper capitalization and spelling out words in full? Have you intentionally modified your auto-correct so that it does not do this?
- zmgsabst 4y agoWhat you just described sounds like an intentional conspiracy: > team up […] to find ways to feed the never-ending demand for performative action (backed by [billions] of dollars) with a supply of expensive temporary solutions [that enrich themselves] If you’re spending most of the money on politicians, their friends, and bourgeois — for the purpose of virtue signaling rather than fixing the problem — you’re a second problem. Government looting the public.
- stevage 4y agoClarifying that's $61k per year per tent space. Crazy.
- Maursault 4y agoSo this is not a figure for the cost of the tent itself, but to lease the space the tent occupies? That would make more sense, but not much. For $5000/month I would expect to be able to rent an actual apartment there, you know, with an actual kitchen, den, bathroom and bedroom.
- Maursault 4y ago> San Francisco spends $61k/year on homeless tents, which is more than median income in the US. The problem is not funding. The city has 815,201 residents as of 2021. I think they can spend more than 13¢ per resident per year on this. Maybe there are other details that compound the problem, but the math insists that funding is obviously a massive part of the problem. They should be spending $20M a year at the very least, just to start, and increase from there. $20M/yr is $25 per resident per year. Even a homeless person could probably afford $25/yr, while the median household income in San Francisco is $120K/yr. If they want the problem fixed, paying for it to be fixed is really the only option.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoTo be clear, it's 61k/year/tent. Not 61k/year overall. Overall spending is in the billions [1]. [1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/S-F-has-an-unprecedented-1-1-billion-to-spend-16318448.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/S-F-has-an-unpre...
- Maursault 4y agoWhat the hell kind of a tent costs $61K every year?! I think maybe this is the problem. A $500 tent is about the best you can buy, so spend $1000 per tent for an extremely luxurious tent, and save $60K per year per tent.
- stjohnswarts 4y agothe vast majority of the people are not mentally ill, that will do nothing for this. It could possibly help tent cities and homeless. A lot better scheme would be to end crazy restrictive building and zoning laws and letting the market fix it and stop letting NIMBYs keep prices artificially high
- diogenescynic 4y ago>the vast majority of the people are not mentally ill The vast majority of homeless people are drug users AND mentally ill. If you are living on the street when we have 3.6% unemployment--it's most likely drugs and mental illness (yes, there are rare exceptions).
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYou are completely wrong. Look up statistics. -Chronically- homeless people are likely drug users. That's the only part where you are partially correct.
- solardev 4y agoThese go against every statistic I've seen regarding American homelessness. If you truly believe this, could you please provide a cite?
- mynameishere 4y agono end in sight Rest assured, other parts of the world have this all figured out. My favorite term is Favela which Wikipedia assures me is "also known as community". Eventually the ruling class throws up their hands. You can't put people in poor houses, jails, mental hospitals, subsidized housing--all too expensive/illegal/impractical. So you let them live in an ill-maintained "community" like the rest of the world does. It's coming.
- collegeburner 4y agowe used to have those in a lot of cities in america, ghettos and tenements. at least they were cheap ig. the problem is we still don't know what else we can do with those people. a lot of them just don't give a shit so we got 0 leverage to make them do anything.
- t-3 4y agoMaybe stop trying to coerce people and offer a little incentive to participate in society? Maybe offer some incentive for the wealthy to create jobs and offer gainful employment? Maybe get rid of zoning laws and force rich NIMBY landowners out of manipulating housing markets for their own gain? If people don't give a shit about their society, that's a problem with the society, not the people.
- TomSwirly 4y ago> we used to have those in a lot of cities in america, ghettos and tenements. Hate to break it to you, but there are still plenty of ghettos and tenements, and replacing some of these with tent cities is not an improvement.
- diogenescynic 4y ago> rampant wealth inequality makes it so that many people have no viable alternative to living on the streets. This is repeated often, but doesn't seem based in reality. Most of the people living on the streets are addicted to meth or heroin or mentally ill or some combination of the those. If you're on meth or heroin, you'll never be able to afford an apartment regardless of what they cost.