3 ms·
> Tons of local people will come out against denser housing and against public transit and against protected bike lanes, This is true in almost every city in t
by avianlyric 4y ago
> Tons of local people will come out against denser housing and against public transit and against protected bike lanes,
This is true in almost every city in the world. But not because that “what the people want”, but rather only those who hold very strong opinions ever bother to turn up to planning meetings. Most people only have strong negative opinions about public infrastructure, especially public infrastructure that’s seen “take something from them”. Public infrastructure that works well is mostly ignored, with the vast majority of people being entirely indifferent to changes to the infrastructure. Unfortunately it means that making any attempt to improve infrastructure, where that improvement isn’t “more of the same please”, is difficult because the only people who hold strong opinions are experts who have studied the problem, and people that hate change. Which, as it happens, is exactly the mix of people you say are in these meetings.
If you want to get a real understanding of peoples views on walkable areas, bike lanes etc. you need to build it, then survey the locals a year or so after the work has completed. Only then can you remove the selection bias seen in city meetings, and also remove peoples initial dislike for change, before they’ve had any opportunity to realise the positives brought by that change.
It turns out, that if you actually do all that leg work, most people like being able to venture outside and do things, without getting in a car and driving first.
- vel0city 4y agoSo you're arguing the government should act against the wishes of the people being governed and ignore the desires of the people who care enough to actually vote? I'd argue we need more people showing up to these kinds of public planning meetings who do want these things which are supposedly incredibly popular online and actually vote for candidates who say they'll do these things.