5 ms·
That's weird. Given how many other useful similar tools remain, it would seem extremely odd this was removed intentionally. But on the other hand, given all o
by crazygringo 4y ago
That's weird.
Given how many other useful similar tools remain, it would seem extremely odd this was removed intentionally.
But on the other hand, given all of Google's infra/tests/quality/etc., it would also be extremely odd for this to be removed by accident.
Maybe some component being deprecated internally meant this was easier to shut down than upgrade, but for a feature this simple that wouldn't make a lot of sense either.
This is... kinda baffling, to be honest.
- bhawks 4y agoSearch is a very old codebase comprised of several large monoliths that are mostly tested by end-to-end diffs. There is no central repository of all search features and if the timer is tested, it is likely forced to trigger with debug flags. For timer to disappear like this would most likely be caused by a ranking change which prevents it from appearing as the top result (the only position it can render itself in).
- cmeacham98 4y ago> For timer to disappear like this would most likely be caused by a ranking change which prevents it from appearing as the top result (the only position it can render itself in). Does Google really not have some sort of "Always rank this result first" flag?
- rwmj 4y agoBack in their Don't Be Evil days they actually clamped down on another part of Google that gamed their search results: https://searchengineland.com/google-penalizes-google-japan-16541 https://searchengineland.com/google-penalizes-google-japan-1...
- bornfreddy 4y agoYeah well... Those days are long gone. :-/
- themacguffinman 4y agoI'm sure they did at some point, but worth noting that prioritizing Google's own tools have been challenged in EU courts for being anti-competitive.
- micromacrofoot 4y ago> There is no central repository of all search features huh so I suppose it’s possible there are ghost features no one maintains but might still work?
- reaperducer 4y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=askew https://www.google.com/search?q=askew
- bhawks 4y agoAn approximate ratio of the prevalence of feature without a dedicated team (or singleton) would be 99/100. That said we could argue for days about what a feature is.
- chrsig 4y agoI'm less interested in what a feature is, and more curious if there's some exhaustive list internally - or if there's even awareness of all of them spread throughout the corporation. That is, in a large org like google (or msft, or...), how much stuff is there that no current employees are aware of? I work at a relatively small company for a number of years, and it's definitely been a challenge to maintain knowledge of feature creep that has occurred, let alone anything more in depth like what the features were _supposed_ to do.
- bhawks 4y agoBuilding a registry has been very seriously attempted at least twice but ended with the acceptance of the futility of the endeavor.
- bun_at_work 4y agoIs it possible Google removed the timer because of the EU DMA? If the widget was a search result, it seems like that would be a violation of the new legislation, along with other things people have mentioned disappearing in this thread. It also would explain why the DDG one remains, as they don't meet the definition of a gatekeeper.
- sabjut 4y agoI think in such a legislation it has to be clearly defined what a "search result" is I'd be surprised if the legislation would count the timer widget as such.
- guitarbill 4y agoIf this were the case, they would've used it as a PR opportunity to bash the legislation. It wouldn't have happened silently.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> they would've used it as a PR opportunity to bash the legislation To what end? Needlessly pissing off lawmakers isn’t a smart strategy.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoIt's basically their goto strategy though. For instance, responding to third party payment provider laws by saying "okay, but you still have to pay us 27% anyways" is pretty much purposely intended to respond by following the letter of the law and not the spirit of the law, forcing lawmakers to go back and be even more clear on the demand. They know the law was intended to address their abusive pricing arrangements, but they decided, of course, to thumb their nose at it and add a new "platform fee" instead.
- soraminazuki 4y agoBut they're already known to do exactly that. Here's how a lobbying group representing Google, among other companies, went full scaremongering in reaction to a proposed anti-trust law: https://inv.riverside.rocks/jXf04bhcjbg?t=1297 https://inv.riverside.rocks/jXf04bhcjbg?t=1297
- graderjs 4y agoDoes that mean if you play with results per page P, and get it to land on the P+1 position, you might be able to coax it back into being? ^^ Or maybe you can pick "results from custom range" to a couple weeks ago when it was still active? ;p ;) xx ;p
- philipov 4y agoMaybe the only person interested in maintaining it left the company.
- thewarrior 4y agoNo one gets promoted for maintaining the timer widget on Google search. One of the most successful engineers I know in big tech told me this once - “thewarrior you need to understand. In these companies everything happens mainly for one reason - does it get someone promoted or not ?” I’ll wait to see if this was an accident or not. But I suspect there are systems in place to prevent changes like these from being shipped by accident. This is one of those tragedy of the commons situations that has bedeviled the industry. Every org , team , project and task is a pawn in an elaborate multiplayer game of promo chess. Career success is defined not only by technical excellence but also in how well you can align and deliver your projects within the chess game that is currently in play. Fail to learn this and you will burn out or be forced to quit. What this does to the companies in the long term remains to be seen.
- bhawks 4y agoThe way you get promoted for maintaining the timer widget is to create some platform which drastically minimizes search features maintenance costs and tooling that largely automigrates legacy features onto it. Easy path to Google fellow if you can do it.
- thewarrior 4y agoSometimes I feel there are more platforms than products.
- bhawks 4y agoThe best platforms are those that build a single product. Then we can argue for days about whether it's the platform teams responsibility to do X or the product engineering teams responsibility. In close second are the platforms that are used for a fraction of a product and will never be wholely migrated onto because they are not fit for purpose. Third place goes to the platforms that never actually have any product built on top of them - a theme so exciting people love recreating it at there own workplace. We're all just temporarily embarrassed Linus Torvalds that want the world to build on our apis.