3 ms·
The solution to solving the "swindles" problem will be reputation. With the internet it's possible to record an incredible level of detail regarding the reputat
by malandrew 15y ago
The solution to solving the "swindles" problem will be reputation. With the internet it's possible to record an incredible level of detail regarding the reputation of people seeking investments and the business they are building (if it already exists).
If swindling becomes a problem, you can be sure that the market will work to provide a solution to that problem.
- wmf 15y agoIt will be argued that reputation is a way of keeping down the innovative little guy who is most in need of funding. Also, any reputation service will be opt-in, so we can imagine that cons will just move elsewhere. Also, intermediaries may have a vested interest in remaining ignorant of scams.
- buff-a 15y agoI think the cons run the reputation system. Its just gambling anyway. If it wasn't, there wouldn't be any risk. So how can you tell the difference between a "genuine" reputation system, and one that has been gamed by con-men? I don't think the sample size will be big enough to distinguish between cons and legitimate failures.
- Zakharov 15y agoIt's also possible to convincingly falsify that information, and appear to be reliable to uninformed investors. The market will provide a way to find only reliable investments, but it will also provide many ways for swindlers to find their marks. I think a lot of people are going to have really great ideas funded that would otherwise be impossible, and a lot of people are going to be cheated out of their money. Unregulated crowdfunding is more of a gamble than an investment.
- ScottBurson 15y agoI'd like to think so, and it certainly would be nice if it turned out that way, but it's not entirely clear to me that that's inevitable. A difference between investments of this kind and ordinary purchase transactions is that in the latter situation, the business selling the product expects to have repeat business. That is, there's a cycle wherein the business can sell a product, and the purchaser's reaction to the product can propagate through the market to influence subsequent transactions. In the case of an investment like this, however, the good being purchased, which is a future return, may not even be expected to be produced for years after the transaction occurs. There's no chance for the information cycle to work; all the investment occurs up front. A swindler may not even need to establish a positive reputation to attract investment; a good story would likely suffice. Indeed, that's the whole point, isn't it? I like the idea, but I think the per-person limits should be reduced by a factor of 10, maybe even 100. That won't lock swindlers out, but it will force them to work quite a bit harder.
- wmf 15y agoOTOH, a person who gets relieved of $100 is not going to ask too many questions about how it happened, encouraging the "entrepreneur" to try again. Someone who lost $10,000 might lawyer up.