7 ms·
"Out of each $2 ticket, roughly 35 cents goes to non-jackpot prizes, about 75 cents goes to fund the jackpot, and the remaining 90 cents goes to the government.
by Animats 4y ago
"Out of each $2 ticket, roughly 35 cents goes to non-jackpot prizes, about 75 cents goes to fund the jackpot, and the remaining 90 cents goes to the government."
Those are really crappy odds.
- ALittleLight 4y agoThe lottery is a voluntary highly regressive tax. Poor people disproportionately play the lottery and are therefore disproportionately funding the lottery taxes.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoThe lottery for rich folks that can prove they have money is called the stock market.
- koheripbal 4y agoI assume this is a joke. If not, you should take some time to understand the financial system.
- tehsauce 4y agoA dollar invested in the stock market has a much higher expected return than a dollar invested in the lottery.
- josephcsible 4y agoThe difference between the stock market and the lottery is that the stock market has a positive expected return.
- willnonya 4y agoSo, you're saying you don't understand the stock market?
- nwah1 4y agoThe lottery is a way for the government to take over the numbers racket, which formerly was a source of revenue for organized crime. It is a net benefit to society for that reason.
- paulpauper 4y agothe mafia had competition though, so probably offered better odds. In Vegas, even under the mafia, the house edge was small...way smaller than the lotto.
- kgwgk 4y agoThey sometimes rigged the game even if it was already very profitable to start with.
- greesil 4y agoThis begs the question for what to do about illegal drugs.
- nwah1 4y agoPennsylvania has a state monopoly on retail liquor sales. Liquor is at least as bad as most illegal drugs. That is probably better than the approach of some states which make obtaining licenses to sell alcohol or marijuana expensive. In most cases they are capriciously controlled by politicians and bureaucrats, involving prohibitive fees and outright bribery. At least PA's approach is more equal in effect.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- listenallyall 4y agoSo by that logic, the government could benefit society by selling credit card numbers and fake identities, by executing ransomware attacks, creating open marketplaces for military weapons, and creating a GitHub for espionage documents.
- voz_ 4y agoThis is a weird take, very HN/Reddit. At best it misses the point, and at worst it insults the poor. Its not a "tax" - it's just fun. The odds are terrible, but the dream / "what if?" aspect of it is fun. Theres no downside to playing (Who doesn't have a dollar or two? even when I was broke and lived in my car, I had a spare buck here and there), but the potential upside is limitless.
- stingraycharles 4y agoEh, I know more than a few people who, over decades, spent small fortunes on these lotteries. $10/month over multiple decades really adds up, especially when you’re already poor. I’m not saying I agree with the “it’s a tax” position, but I definitely don’t agree with the “it’s just fun” position. It’s an industry that preys on poor people’s poor (monetary) decision making skills.
- voz_ 4y agoDoes it prey? I think scratchers / casinos / sports betting / online poker / more general kinds of gambling is far more addictive and malicious, because the dopamine fueled reward->attempt cycle is a far tighter loop with those.
- Parmenidea 4y agoThe counter argument is that a lot of those games reward “skill”. Through study/statistics your odds improve, in the same way that equity research can lead to a good stock pick. The lottery is naked chance.
- Swenrekcah 4y agoWould you say the same about a $14/month Netflix subscription? Because that actually has zero upside potential and does not fund local nonprofit activities (like lottery often does, depending on your location).
- jimkleiber 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y ago> The lottery is a voluntary highly regressive tax. Poor people disproportionately play the lottery and are therefore disproportionately funding the lottery taxes. If you are a regular non-connected, non-Ivy League folk, your odds of becoming a billionaire via day zero equity appreciation are roughly the same as becoming one via playing the lottery. And yet this website is full of people deluding themselves that they can become one, and also cheering on other people posting their billion dollar delusions. It's always a real pain to watch the contempt that people who are doing well for themselves have for people who live in inner cities, while engaging in the same behavior, only from a relatively higher vantage point. It's not even necessary to go all the way up to 1 billion, 100m net worth odds for a regular non-connected, non-Ivy League folk are also kinda the same playing lottery vs. day zero equity appreciation. The crossover is somewhere below 100 million dollars, maybe even less than 10 million dollars or there about
- listenallyall 4y agoThis comment is sarcasm, right? Perhaps becoming a billionaire is out of reach, but growing your portfolio by 5-20% annually is highly likely, as opposed to -100% growth via lottery tickets.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoPeople aren't attacking the delusional and temporarily embarassed billionaires and telling them to focus on a more realistic FIRE. They are pouring gas on their delusions, big difference compared to the reaction to people who play the lottery.
- antisthenes 4y ago> This comment is sarcasm, right? Perhaps becoming a billionaire is out of reach, but growing your portfolio by 5-20% annually is highly likely This is incredibly out of touch. The GP comment was talking about the kind of people who don't even own stocks and probably can't afford to buy even a single share, because it would eat into their budget much more than a $2-5 lottery ticket. Also, lottery ticket EV isn't -100%, it's anywhere between -50% and -80%. The stock portfolio growth numbers are also wrong for long-term, but we'll let that one slide.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 4y agoJust play slots...
- lowercased 4y agoWhich government? Is it split between all participating states? Or just the state the ticket was bought in? The multi-state lotteries - unsure how that works.
- ericmcer 4y agoDon’t forget that the $1.10 that does get distributed as prizes also gets taxed at almost 50%.
- yojo 4y agoI used to think of the lottery as a suckers bet, until I realized that for some people it is basically their only shot at transformative wealth. Put another way: If you’re poor, unconnected, and uneducated, your odds of becoming a billionaire are zero. If you’re poor, unconnected, uneducated, and play the lottery, your odds are ever so slightly higher.
- listenallyall 4y agoThis is ridiculous. First, it's untrue. Ask Dre or Jay-Z. More importantly, since when is "transformative wealth" hundreds of millions of dollars? If you grew up truly poor and uneducated, making a steady $80,000 a year -- decent house, raise a family, put a little away -- is a transformation.
- alphabettsy 4y agoThe odds of ending up like Dr. Dre or Jay-Z are worse than the lottery and require even more significant time and monetary commitment. You’re better off going with your latter suggestion of trying to make a decent living which has pretty good odds.
- armchairhacker 4y agoehh, going from poor to successful is hard and unlikely, but it’s a lot more likely than winning the lottery. Maybe your best shot at becoming a billionaire is indeed winning some jackpot. But if you’re looking for anywhere from moderate wealth to millions, you’re much better off trying to find a job and start a business.
- WelcomeShorty 4y agoNeither am I poor, unconnected or uneducated, but I play the lottery once or twice a year since I enjoy the prospect of ridicules "transformative wealth". So I buy my tickets as long as possible before the draw, get to fantasise about what if and have a couple of weeks of happy, crazy dreams. To me that is worth the 10 or so bucks, no matter the odds being so badly stack against me, I guess that is so for many people (who are not addicted to gambling).
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe odds on this draw were much better. Earlier stories said they expected to sell $400M in tickets, so they paid out about 3X as much as they took in. If you bought tickets to every draw the expected value of a ticket is $1.10/$2, but if you only bought for this draw the expected value was much better. The expected value before the draw was not 3:1, only slightly above unity because the biggest likelihood was no winner, and a significant likelihood of a shared jackpot.
- listenallyall 4y ago> The odds on this draw were much better The odds were the same, but the EV was certainly higher than most draws. Still, the EV was likely negative. $2 ticket x 303 million-to-1 odds would require a post-tax cash-in-hand value exceeding $600 million, which the winner is unlikely to see after tax, despite avoiding a split with a second winner.
- bryanlarsen 4y ago35 cents goes to minor prizes, so that's $1.65 x 303 million, which is borderline achievable.