4 ms·
> Last I heard, the big "solution" was to stick it in sacred Native American mountains in Nevada and New Mexico and let future generations worry about it. Sorr
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> Last I heard, the big "solution" was to stick it in sacred Native American mountains in Nevada and New Mexico and let future generations worry about it.
Sorry, but given that the climate catastrophe is the most pressing concern for humanity, I think that gives more weight that religious superstition over the "sanctity" of a mountain in the middle of the desert miles from any humans.
Securing nuclear waste to decay at the bottom of a mountain is a pretty good solution, the only thing against it really is political nimbyism.
- reaperducer 4y agothe only thing against it really is political nimbyism Actually, from what I've read in the local newspapers in the areas affected, the politicians are all for it, so you're making assumptions there. The people who are against it are the people who actually have to live with the stuff for the next thousand years. If it's so safe, so stable, so easily rendered harmless, why not bury it in the bedrock beneath Manhattan, or Boston, or Virginia? All places that are far more geologically stable than, for example, Yucca Mountain.
- TulliusCicero 4y agoAbundance of caution, defense in depth. If nobody lives there, nobody has to live with it.
- c1ccccc1 4y agoI haven't checked the geological suitability, but assuming you're right about that, putting the waste in those places seems perfectly fine to me.
- josephcsible 4y agoBecause in major cities, it's more likely that you'll need to dig that area up again for something else.
- troyvit 4y agoPolitical nimbyism is what put the waste where it is. It ended up in the back yard of the least powerful political force in America. Curating nuclear waste for longer than any human can actually comprehend isn't something to just brush off. You'd be trading one climate catastrophe for another. And that doesn't even account for securely transporting the waste across the country. Imagine scaling nuclear to the size of coal. What does waste transport look like then? Maybe this waste belongs precisely in the back yards of those of us who create it. Then we'd be truly careful.
- jfim 4y agoKeep in mind that the US is generating about 20x the amount of high level nuclear waste than if it were to recycle spent fuel. The French do it, but Americans won't.
- panick21_ 4y agoAnd the French use a very expensive wasteful method. There are much better ways to reprocess fuel if you can target modern advanced reactor designs.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe US doesn't recycle waste because it's economically pointless to do it right now. The separated plutonium has negative value.
- Brybry 4y agoI think nuclear is already scaled to the size of coal. Electricity generation by source in the US in 2021: Coal - 21.8% Nuclear - 18.9% [1] https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427&t=3 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427&t=3
- panick21_ 4y ago> You'd be trading one climate catastrophe for another. No you actually don't. Even under the most absurdly bombastic delusional fantasy of nuclear-haters the amount of damage nuclear waste deep in a cave in a desert can do is about a billion times less then climate change. And even based on the pessimistic assumptions, it would be save for 1000s of years. Are you seriously gone tell me that we should worry about 1000+ years into the future. If we do not have massive technological decay, the people in the next 1000+ years will have the technology to reprocess the fuel if they feel like it. And if you do assume massive technological decay then the nuclear fuel is in a cave in a desert that will be essentially uninhabited and will most likely never seriously impact humans. Even further this whole debate is incredibly dumb since putting into a deep cave is terrible idea anyway. As a human society we can just store it above ground in a save location and in case some danger is identified, we just move it to another location. Moving a few tons of nuclear fuel around ever couple 100 years is really no big deal. And again, if society collapses to a point where this isn't possible, that nuclear fuel is the least thing to worry about. And even all of that is totally irrelevant, because the real actual solution is to simply ut it into advanced reactors, burn it up to a point where it is only 300 years away from matching natural uranium and you simple put it back into the mine where it came from. If you do it correctly, we can get every person in the world using US like energy and we can store the complete output of world nuclear waste on a single abandoned Walmark parking lot in Gary Indiana. If we used basic rationality this would be a non issue. This is a cultural political issue, not really a technical one. > What does waste transport look like then? Mhhh well it would be an occasional train going along the train network that would never hurt anybody. And nuclear isn't that far away from coal level of production. > Maybe this waste belongs precisely in the back yards of those of us who create it. Then we'd be truly careful. I'm totally fine with storing all nuclear waste around the Whitehouse if that gets people to stop bringing it up as a problem.
- briandear 4y agoThere is no climate catastrophe. That’s simply a modern version of the superstition you lament. The end of the world is always conveniently just 12 years away. I’m old enough to remember the Prophesy of Al Gore (peace be upon him) and how none of that came to pass. 2009: “the North Pole will be ice free by 2013.” I also remember the dire predictions of acid rain, the ozone hole, and numerous other proclamations that stirred up the anti-capitalist faithful. There’s always some sort of catastrophe just looming just over the horizon of the next election. Televangelists have made careers from warning the faithful that their doom is assured — unless you reprint (and contribute.) The climate alarmist crowd has taken pages right out of the tent-revival handbook of the 19th century. Snake oil.
- ikrenji 4y agomega droughts, record heat waves, wildfires, more numerous and violent storms of all kind but sure there is no problem with the climate. shaping the climate doesn’t happen overnight and if no action is taken now the world will be very different in 50-100 years. just because dinosaurs lived on a hotter earth doesn’t mean than 10 billion people can comfort at do so too ...
- puppable 4y agoThe only reason you're not hearing about the acid rain or the ozone hole anymore are because decisive international action was taken to stop both, and wouldn't you know it, it worked. And, are you really "old enough to remember" a single politician mis-stating a climate forecast during a speech, or are you just "old enough to remember" seeing it repackaged into a meme on social media a decade or so after the fact? Either way, it is an asinine basis for your leading claim.
- otikik 4y agoThe world is a very complex system and it is of course logical that people will not be completely accurate in their numbers and dates. > the North Pole will be ice free by 2013 The tendency is unmissable if you look at the data[1]. People might have been wrong about the exact date at which it would happen, but you should not let the exactitude of the date distract you. It will eventually happen (unless something changes drastically). And we honestly don't know how the weather will behave on an iceless Earth. Some people speculate that the arctic ice is a sort of heat shield. It makes some sense intuitively: all that white ice reflects a lot of heat back up. Once it is gone... the blue water will absorb and accumulate more heat. > I also remember the dire predictions of acid rain, the ozone hole, and numerous other proclamations that stirred up the anti-capitalist faithful. Everyone is starting to feel the change, it's no longer "just words". If you have not started yet you will start feeling it soon. In my country (Spain), this summer we have had 3 heatwaves in a row, as well as two very unusual clouds of Sahara dust, the first of which reached Finland. I was born in the south of Spain, were's the hottest. When I was little the max summer temp used to be 41 degrees Celsius (105F). Now it's 47C(116F). Max temperatures have increased through the Iberian Peninsula, 41C is "the new normal" in all places except some coastal fortunates and some very northern regions. My options for escaping the summer heat are dwindling. In the United States my understanding is that the most visible exponent is the extreme drought, in particular the water levels in the Colorado river basin seems worrisome. You might find more information about where you live in [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_sea_ice_decline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_sea_ice_decline [2] https://www.drought.gov https://www.drought.gov