3 ms·
> Why is it that I am comfortable crossing the intersection when I have a green light? Because I have confidence that those who would break the social contract
by lapcat 4y ago
> Why is it that I am comfortable crossing the intersection when I have a green light? Because I have confidence that those who would break the social contract of following agreed upon laws will be punished, so they are deterred from breaking them.
I would say it's because most people have no desire to murder other people, even if they could get away with it legally.
- closeparen 4y agoRiding a bicycle around cars would pretty quickly dispel that notion.
- lapcat 4y agoYou think I haven't ridden a bicycle around cars? Are drivers sometimes headless? Yes. Are they murderous? No. Otherwise you and I would be dead now.
- mantas 4y agoA possibility of punishment is a great way to remind to check whereabouts of one’s head…
- pasiaj 4y agoRoad rage and horribly antisocial driving behaviour exists. I don't think it usually includes murderous intent, but intentionally dangerous behaviour is quite common.
- lapcat 4y agoYes, they exist, they're illegal, and the legal consequences don't actually stop them. If the argument is that everyone would road rage and drive dangerously if there weren't legal consequences, I dispute that. Many people don't do it simply because they don't feel like doing it.
- Ekaros 4y agoMaybe not everyone. But probably sizable proportion of road users would. And I think that is the point. Punishment is effective tool for stopping at least sizable fraction of them.
- watwut 4y agoI am someone who used to ride bike for transportation a lot. It was nit that bad. It may be cultural, but people were not horribly antisocial.
- closeparen 4y agoI'm very familiar with environments where people drive however the fuck they want. A cyclist wouldn't last long there. Maybe it's not murderous intent, but it's at least reckless disregard for life.
- lapcat 4y agoWhich environments would those be? Every major city has a large number of non-dying cyclists.
- nickelpro 4y agoThe person who runs a red light doesn't intend to murder, they intend to be reckless under the belief they are skilled enough to avoid hurting others. That the rules were meant for others, less capable than they. The consequences for rule breakers exist in part to deter those lacking the wisdom to understand why the rules were created in the first place, not because society believes that class of rule breakers wants to hurt others.
- lapcat 4y agoBut the consequences don't actually deter them, as evidenced by the countless cars that run red lights. Those who believe they are skilled enough to avoid hurting others also believe they won't get caught by the police running a red light. The question is, which is the worse consequence, getting a ticket for running a red light, or killing another person in a crash? I would say the latter, in the minds and hearts of most people.
- Ekaros 4y agoI think it comes back to failure of enforcement and size of punishment. I think lot less people would run red lights if they were reliably punished for it and the punishment were non-trivial. This is why I support Finnish model of income based fines. You end up paying some fraction of your monthly income. So it will hurt rich and poor more equally. The fines are often very trivial for certain fraction of population.
- lapcat 4y agoIf you have a whole society that mostly doesn't have inherent respect for social norms or laws, then it would be incredibly difficult to enforce those norms or laws effectively. You'd need a police state. Massive levels of surveilance. And how could you even trust the police themselves, if people generally don't respect social norms or laws? Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
- nickelpro 4y ago