3 ms·
> What is the current legal thinking on the right to privacy while driving I think it’s pretty clear from precedent you have none. Every vehicle displays a un
by gumby 4y ago
> What is the current legal thinking on the right to privacy while driving
I think it’s pretty clear from precedent you have none.
Every vehicle displays a unique number in large, readable type, and has for longer than any person has been alive. I haven’t seen any objections.
The same applies to driving licenses that are covered in very personal information which is handed over willy-nilly to anyone who asks for it.
In California they make it clear that driving is a “privilege”, not something in which you have any rights.
Edit: another example: notice that the automatic toll collection systems are always implemented as registration+billing based systems rather than as any kind of privacy-protecting cash-like schemes.
- dahart 4y agoI mostly agree on precedent, as far as I know, but I would say that recent developments like the GDPR and others targeting digital practices are probably starting to broach this topic of what is public and what is private. And I’m asking because I don’t know whether precedent is changing right now; I imagine that it is changing in some locales. Googling just now I noticed that California passed a new privacy act in 2020. I’ve seen a lot of discussion and debate, and the idea that cheap mass surveillance technology is a marked departure from what was available before this century does legitimately question whether we can continue operating under the framework where anything done in public is free for someone else to record and consume. That idea is now much, much more prone to abuse than it was 30 years ago, right?
- kortilla 4y ago> Every vehicle displays a unique number in large, readable type, and has for longer than any person has been alive. I haven’t seen any objections. Because the bar to getting that data used to be quite high and limited in scope. Now with license plate reader software in conjunction with street light cameras, the dynamic has completely shifted to easily record and store a detailed tracking log for all observed license plate numbers in a city. Big power dynamic changes like that result in fundamental shifts like “right to be forgotten”, the GDPR, etc. The only thing that has prevented an uproar so far is that you can’t go type in your neighbor’s license plate into a website and get that detailed tracking log at the drop of a hat. Similar thing for cell phone location records from cell companies.