4 ms·
I always enjoy reading this magazine, but always saddened when they (unwittingly?) give support to climate change denier talking points. It's entirely possible
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I always enjoy reading this magazine, but always saddened when they (unwittingly?) give support to climate change denier talking points.
It's entirely possible for a tech to be more sustainable than another tech, yet not be perfectly sustainable.
Gas can be better than coal, wind can be better than gas and so on without having to continually harp on the exceptions and edge cases to the point that the truth gets lost.
Solar panels are recyclable and have become much more sustainable over the decades. To say otherwise is absurdly wrong.
edit: they link to one of their own articles about PV sustainability, which contradicts what they said in the preceding paragraph, so it might just be really bad writing:
> Meanwhile, solar cells are becoming more energy efficient, and the same goes for the technology used to manufacture them. For example, the polysilicon content in solar cells -- the most energy-intensive component -- has come down to 5.5-6.0 grams per watt peak (g/wp), a number that will further decrease to 4.5-5.0 g/wp in 2017. [2] Both trends have a positive effect on the sustainability of solar PV systems. According to the latest life cycle analyses, which measure the environmental impact of solar panels from production to decommission, greenhouse gas emissions have come down to around 30 grams of CO2-equivalents per kilwatt-hour of electricity generated (gCO2e/kWh), compared to 40-50 grams of CO2-equivalents ten years ago. [7-11] [12]
- jaclaz 4y ago>Solar panels are recyclable ... The question revolves more around whether they are actually recycled. From the article: >Silicon cells can only be recycled by a combination of thermal, chemical, and metallurgical steps. That is an expensive process with an impact on the environment. Although you can find statements claiming that around 10% of solar panels are “recycled", they are more likely to be “downcycled”. The modules are shredded, and the resulting material is used as a filler material in asphalt and cement industries.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThey're mostly glass and aluminium which can be and are widely recycled. Oh no, does that involve thermal steps? It probably involves those suspicious sounding "metallurgical" steps too, what even is that, it sounds positively diabolical. Wait, chemicals? No one told me they had chemicals in them. I never touch anything with chemicals in it. Totally banned them from my life. They are well known to cause cancer apparently.
- jaclaz 4y ago>They're mostly glass and aluminium which can be and are widely recycled. Can be, not necessarily are. Check "Recycling Process" here: https://www.epa.gov/hw/solar-panel-recycling https://www.epa.gov/hw/solar-panel-recycling Particularly: >The industry is new and still growing, with researchers examining how to commercialize recycling to economically recover most of the components of a solar panel. Elements of this recycling process can be found in the United States, but it is not yet happening on a large scale. The question revolves around the existence of suitable recycling plants and whether the capacity of these plants is enough (particuarly in times when a "first generation" of panels is progressively approaching an "end of service life"). See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32098575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32098575
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYour link says: > Many of these components can be recycled. Glass composes most of the weight of a solar panel (about 75 percent), and glass recycling is already a well-established industry. Other materials that are easily recyclable include the aluminum frame, copper wire, and plastic junction box. Which is almost exactly what I said, with a few extra details and less sarcasm about "chemicals'.
- jaclaz 4y agoThere are no doubts that some parts (glass, aluminium) can be recycled. The BIG doubt is IF they are actually recycled (as in the main article probably largely "downcycled"). As per the EPA site (and also the other thread I linked to), they are NOT recycled (at the moment), or - even if they are - they are not - yet - recycled on a large scale. Here it is an article by MIT (2021) stating how only about 10% of discarded panels are recycled: https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/08/19/1032215/solar-panels-recycling/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/08/19/1032215/solar-pa... and, soon, the amount of discarded panels is going to increase.