5 ms·
You're repeating the totally fallacious argument in the article that this was a "crime" in some Agatha Christie sense and therefore they have to dig up the chil
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
You're repeating the totally fallacious argument in the article that this was a "crime" in some Agatha Christie sense and therefore they have to dig up the children's bodies or they're liars and there are neither bodies nor crimes.
The original claim made by the people who did the survey was that they think they've found graves of children who went to the school.
You're talking about people overreacting and making things up in foreign newspapers, then making an argument based on stuff that you've just claimed isn't true.
And it appears intended to distract from the fact that we know for a fact there are graves and we know for a fact there were crimes. But by laser focussing and saying, this particular potential grave has not been proved to be a grave to my satisfaction, you get to cast doubt on all the known graves and known crimes.
- int_19h 4y ago> you're repeating the totally fallacious argument I'm not repeating the argument that the bodies must be dug out because there was a crime (although I also don't see how it is invalid, because this discovery is combined with oral sources which do claim some very serious crimes). What I'm saying is that if this is all true, then there are people responsible for it, who would be rightly held to account - if not legally, then in court of public opinion. So when newspapers publish articles that strongly imply that it's all definitive when it actually isn't, someone's reputation is ruined. > you get to cast doubt on all the known graves and known crimes. Here's the thing, though. Every denialist article I've looked at trying to figure out what exactly they claim - and there were like 5 - clearly spelled out that, yes, there was plenty of abuse in those schools in general, and that said abuse did result in dead children. On the other hand, almost every article criticizing them makes the same claim you do - that them casting doubt on the claims made in this particular case casts doubt on the whole thing, somehow. All disclaimers are ignored. This looks like a classic strawman to me, not a good-faith attempt at fair discourse.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYeah, and climate denialists don't actually deny that climate change isn't happening, they just think it wasn't human caused, and if it was it's not a bad thing, and if it is it's not fixable anyway, and if it is then it's not worth it and wind turbines cause noise cancer and on and on and on... Except of course they did deny it was happening and very slowly retreated further and further as more and more proof mounted, only giving up when their lies are totally destroyed in the court of public opinion while still being shrilly outraged at every new "lie" or "exagerration" from the people who were right all along. Things that in future they'll deny believing when its convenient and then bring up again later. So the climate or Holocaust victims are never allowed to make a single mistake, or its a media fueled panic, while the deniers get to construct their own reality as they please, again and again, and it's rude to point that out to them, because they're just being skeptical about children's graves for purely scientific reasons.
- int_19h 4y agoEverybody is allowed to make a mistake. What's wrong is denying that one has made a mistake and/or doubling down on it.