4 ms·
As I said 48 days ago when this last came up on YC, the classic "Why your idea for stopping spam sucks" list applies.[1] Go re-read that and you'll see the same
by Animats 4y ago
As I said 48 days ago when this last came up on YC, the classic "Why your idea for stopping spam sucks" list applies.[1] Go re-read that and you'll see the same identity problems and proposed solutions.
If people can create and abandon identities cheaply. they will use those identities for annoyance or fraud. Hence spam, robocalls, etc. This is also why the "federated" social networks are not too useful.
On the other hand, publicly visible identities that are very strongly tied to a person or physical place lead to strong tracking and the abuses associated with that.
So, explain how "Web5" avoids those problems.
[1] https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt
- ThalesX 4y agoWould having all data produced by a DID being verifiable mean that I could stop any nugget of information coming out of that producer from reaching me just by a simple computation?
- conradev 4y ago> The process of binding a DID to something in the physical world, such as a person or an organization — for example, by using verifiable credentials with the same subject as that DID — is contemplated by this specification and further defined in the Verifiable Credentials Data Model [VC-DATA-MODEL]. https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/#proving-control-and-binding https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/#proving-control-and-binding Here is the diagram: https://www.w3.org/TR/vc-data-model/#lifecycle-details https://www.w3.org/TR/vc-data-model/#lifecycle-details The idea there is that identity providers and other authorities (governments, credit agencies, etc) issue credentials after the person authenticates with them. This isn't much different than how it works today with, for example, a cookie on the Experian website, but the idea is that I can now take this cookie, show it to a third party and the third party can verify the credential's validity.
- rektide 4y agoWow now it sounds awful for other reasons. Still pie-in-the-sky, but I still think we've been low ambition & not had good decentralized-identity-preconditions to begin exploring web-of-trust models. Past behavior is a huge indicator, one we can judge, & which many others will have judged. Trying to filter those other judges, decide what trust anchors we have & what biases to give, is a place where humanity would have a lot of freedom to tweak & explore, if we had these modest adequate technical underpinnings to begin to explore from. But we just lost a decade to blockchain mania & consensus computing, rather than exploring anything actually genuinely distributed & decentralized & non-consensus. Also worth admitting AI just got good enough to convincingly fake being an online person fairly well, which can potentially massively outperform any attempt at moderation & seeking truth/genuineness that humans might ever make; said explicitly, bad/business-motivated actor's ability to fuck up anything but an ultra-conservative/paranoid web-of-trust has gone up orders of magnitudes in the past couple years.
- Animats 4y ago> web-of-trust models Been there, done that, seen it abused for SEO.
- rektide 4y agoHi John. Where has it been done distributedly ever and at any decent size of adoption? To me, the premise that we start with some self soverign moderation opens to the door to endless creatives refinements & betterments we can collaboratively explore? Afaik Earth has never had that privilege, has never really tried this at any degree. We've had some keysigning parties but actual reputation & moderation... no. Im not sure what evidence we have to stick a fork in this one & call it done. Doesnt feel to me like we hardly ever began.
- Animats 4y agoGoogle's original backlink-based rating system was a web of trust model. A whole industry developed around gaming it.
- bawolff 4y ago> but the idea is that I can now take this cookie, show it to a third party and the third party can verify the credential's validity. Or you know, like oauth. Or if you want to really play up the credential angle, how tls client certificates work, if anyone would ever use them.
- judge2020 4y agoPerhaps TLS client certificates are unpopular because pretty much everyone uses some sort of anti-ddos or caching server in front of their services (cloud load balancers, fastly, akamai, cloudflare) so any TLS client certificate authentication and validation has to be baked into the service[0] (another possibility could be the service encoding the client's information and shipping it to the origin server via headers). Another options for companies is only signing request bodies and validating a request signature in the header like discord does[1]. 0: https://developers.cloudflare.com/api-shield/security/mtls/configure/ https://developers.cloudflare.com/api-shield/security/mtls/c... 1: https://discord.com/developers/docs/interactions/receiving-and-responding#security-and-authorization https://discord.com/developers/docs/interactions/receiving-a...
- bawolff 4y agoTLS client certs were unpopular way before external TLS termination became popular. Besides, it would be fairly easy to implement at a cdn layer. Just give it a list of valid CAs, and have it set some header. The real reason is that UI challenges for client certs are really hard. You can see it in the fact that people actual do use client certs in server to server communication (e.g. like between cache and backend)
- nibbleshifter 4y agoHaving worked with TLS client certificates before, I like them, but I wouldn't inflict them on anyone else.
- Proven 4y ago
- helloworld11 4y agoBullshit on at least a couple fronts. First, even when people strongly have their real identity tied to their digital or other activities, it amazingly often does nearly nothing at all to stop them from all kinds of spammy abuse, fraud, lying, trolling and all sorts of bad behavior. This happens across the board, world-wide in any non-personal social or digital setting. Secondly, I'd argue that the ability to "decentralize" ID and anonymize oneself is more than worth having as at least a moderate bulwark against the pervasive parasitic, predatory modern corporate/government surveillance world that we increasingly live in. It's nice to talk about keeping people "respectful" with a strongly tied down identity but how ideal is this when these people live in a world of giant institutions that respect next to nothing whenever it's convenient for their interests?
- RL_Quine 4y agoYeah, in no small part that "identity" is transferable. It can be stolen, resold to other parties for a profit, or rented out.
- thomassmith65 4y agoeven when people strongly have their real identity tied to their digital or other activities, it amazingly often does nearly nothing [...] Is that based on any particular example? Off the top of my head, I can think of several mechanisms by which tying a pseudonym to a real identity could deter or address malicious behavior: law suit, jail time, loss of collateral, permanent ban of a human being from a service, etc. the ability to "decentralize" ID and anonymize oneself is more than worth [...] Well, the downside is unstoppable crime, harassment, dis/misinformation... but let's entirely ignore all that, and just daydream about the valiant freedom fighters it will save from oppressive government /s
- ipaddr 4y agoConnecting your digital identity opens you up to stalking, data mining, identity fraud and a host of other things not government related.
- gonehome 4y agoUrbit solves it by making the ID scarce with a cheap, but non-zero cost that makes spam prohibitively expensive. It also makes blocking and moderation easy and the pseudonyms accrue reputation.
- linksnapzz 4y agoYeah...wonder why it wasn't mentioned...